HARP: HARmonizing in-vivo diffusion MRI using Phantom-only training Publication type: Research Article
Hwihun Jeong, Qiang Liu, Kathryn E. Keenan, Elisabeth A. Wilde, Walter Schneider, Sudhir Pathak, Anthony Zuccolotto, Lauren J. O’Donnell, Lipeng Ning, Yogesh Rathi · 2026
Read HARP: HARmonizing in-vivo diffusion MRI using Phantom-only training Publication type: Research Article by Hwihun Jeong, Qiang Liu, Kathryn E. Keenan, Elisabeth A. Wilde, Walter Schneider, Sudhir Pathak, Anthony Zuccolotto, Lauren J. O’Donnell, Lipeng Ning, Yogesh Rathi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-06696.txt.
Introduction
Hwihun Jeong and colleagues present HARP, a way to line up brain diffusion scans from different scanners with no human test subjects. A small voxel-wise network trains only on a portable diffusion phantom, so it learns how sites differ without memorizing brain shapes. In tests it cut gaps between scanners on key diffusion measures. Fiber directions and tract paths stayed intact after the fix.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hwihun Jeong, Qiang Liu, Kathryn E. Keenan, Elisabeth A. Wilde, Walter Schneider, Sudhir Pathak, Anthony Zuccolotto, Lauren J. O’Donnell, Lipeng Ning, Yogesh Rathi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39558 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.06696
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
HARP: HARmonizing in-vivo diffusion MRI using Phantom-only training Publication type: Research Article Hwihun Jeong, Qiang Liu, Kathryn E. Keenan, Elisabeth A. Wilde, Walter Schneider, Sudhir Pathak, Anthony Zuccolotto, Lauren J. O’Donnell, Lipeng Ning, Yogesh Rathi Abstract 1 Purpose Combining multi-site diffusion MRI (dMRI) data is hindered by inter-scanner variability, which confounds subsequent analysis. Previous harmonization methods require large, matched or traveling human subjects from multiple sites, which are impractical to acquire in many situations. This study aims to develop a deep learning-based dMRI harmonization framework that eliminates the reliance on multi-site in-vivo traveling human data for training. 2 Methods HARP employs a voxel-wise 1D neural network trained on an easily transportable diffusion phantom. The model learns relationships between spherical harmonics coefficients of different sites without memorizing spatial structures. 3 Results HARP reduced inter-scanner variability levels significantly in various measures. Quantitatively, it decreased inter-scanner variability as measured by standard error in FA (12%), MD (10%), and GFA (30%) with scan-rescan standard error as the baseline, while preserving fiber orientations and tractography after harmonization. 4 Conclusion We believe that HARP represents an important first step toward dMRI harmonization using only phantom data, thereby obviating the need for complex, matched in vivo multi-site cohorts. This phantom-only strategy substantially enhances the feasibility and scalability of quantitative dMRI for large-scale clinical studies. keywords Harmonization, Phantoms, Diffusion MRI, Domain adaptation 5 Introduction Diffusion Magnetic Resonance Imaging (dMRI) 18 has emerged as a pivotal modality in neuroimaging, providing a unique, non-invasive probe into the microstructural organization of biological tissues 9 ; 31 . By offering quantitative metrics that reflect tissue integrity, dMRI has extended its utility from fundamental neuroscience research to promising clinical applications for assessing the central nervous system. This transition is increasingly catalyzed by the rise of large-scale, multi-center cohort studies, where dMRI plays a central role in the search for robust imaging biomarkers and the longitudinal characterization of neurological conditions. Despite its clinical and scientific potential, dMRI data exhibit significant systematic variations when acquired across different hardware vendors, magnetic field strengths, or imaging protocols 7 ; 26 ; 25 ; 34 ; 43 . These scanner-specific factors often lead to substantial discrepancies in fundamental image characteristics, such as contrast and signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), even when the same subject is scanned 8 ; 40 . When such multi-site data are pooled for joint analysis, these hardware-driven fluctuations manifest as batch effects, which are non-biological variances that can severely confound the biological signals of interest 46 . Particularly, if the variance attributed to the imaging environment is comparable to or larger than the effect size of the clinical condition, it becomes difficult to distinguish genuine pathological changes from technical artifacts. Consequently, robust data harmonization is an essential prerequisite to decouple these site-specific technical signatures from true biological variability, ensuring the reliability and generalizability of multi-site dMRI findings 14 ; 19 ; 30 ; 21 ; 33 ; 32 ; 38 ; 12 . Existing strategies for dMRI harmonization can be broadly classified into statistical adjustments, signal-based transformations, and deep learning architectures 44 . Statistical approaches, such as ComBat and its derivatives, primarily target cross-site variances in derived microstructural metrics, including fractional anisotropy (FA) and mean diffusivity (MD) 14 ; 19 ; 37 . In contrast, signal-level methods utilizing spherical harmonics provide a more direct approach to data integration. For instance, techniques based on rotationally invariant spherical harmonics (RISH) features aim to harmonize the diffusion signal itself by calculating voxel-wise scaling factors between source and target sites within the spherical harmonic domain 30 ; 21 ; 10 . More recently, deep learning-based frameworks have been introduced to capture complex, non-linear mappings between disparate imaging sites, thereby offering enhanced flexibility in modeling site-specific variations compared to traditional linear models 33 ; 32 ; 15 . Despite the progress in mitigating batch effects, conventional dMRI harmonization strategies are often constrained by stringent requirements for specialized datasets during model construction. A prominent approach involves the use of traveling subjects, where the same individuals are scanned across multiple sites to establish a ground truth for cross-site differences 30 ; 13 . While effective, the recruitment of such subjects imposes significant logistical burdens, including prohibitive costs, extended timelines, and complex ethical considerations. To circumvent the need for traveling subjects, alternative methods such as LinearRISH have been proposed 21 ; 32 ; 27 , which utilize a multi-site dataset with matched distribution at the group level. However, these approaches still necessitate large and meticulously matched cohorts across all participating sites, requiring that demographic variables such as age and sex be equivalently distributed to prevent confounding the harmonization process. The acquisition of either traveling subject data or such matched multi-site cohorts remains highly impractical for most large-scale applications, thereby limiting the scalability and flexibility of existing harmonization frameworks 11 . To alleviate the dependency on matched cohorts, recent investigations have explored more flexible harmonization architectures. Some approaches utilize a deep learning network as a prior for a specific site, allowing a model trained on target site data to be applied across diverse source sites 17 ; 4 . While these methods show promise, they have primarily been validated on T1-weighted structural images and often fail to explicitly characterize the intricate signal relationships between disparate sites. Another emerging strategy involves accounting for potential demographic biases when learning harmonization parameters using unmatched training groups 11 . Although this approach demonstrates robust performance, it remains reliant on large-scale in-vivo datasets to achieve statistical stability and may not account for all sources of acquisition bias. Figure 1: Conceptual overview of the HARP framework. (a) Comparison between conventional harmonization and the proposed HARP. Unlike traditional methods that necessitate the acquisition of matched or traveling human subject data from multiple sites, HARP utilizes easily accessible diffusion phantom data for network training. (b) Architectural overview of the 1D voxel-wise neural network. The network receives spherical harmonics coefficients from the source site as input and estimates harmonized spherical harmonics coefficients. This non-spatial architecture ensures robust generalizability when transferring the learned relationships from phantom training to in-vivo human inference. Recently, sophisticated diffusion phantoms that closely emulate the microstructural properties of in-vivo white matter tissues have been developed 23 ; 47 ; 3 . These phantoms offer distinct advantages over human subjects: they are inherently motion-free, maintain stable material properties, and exhibit high reproducibility regardless of environmental fluctuations. Such stability facilitates the efficient and repetitive acquisition of large-scale datasets across diverse scanner hardware and parameter configurations. Furthermore, the ability to manufacture multiple phantoms with identical specifications provides an ideal, controlled environment to establish a uniform reference for training robust harmonization models. If a harmonization framework can be constructed using paired phantom data and subsequently generalized to in-vivo datasets, the logistical and ethical burdens associated with large-scale data acquisition could be substantially mitigated. Therefore, we propose HARP, a novel deep learning-based framework that utilizes exclusively phantom data for training, yet can be directly applied to in-vivo dMRI data (Fig. 1 a). The primary objective of this study is to demonstrate that a model optimized on standardized phantoms can successfully capture and correct for site-specific variations, effectively generalizing to the complex architecture of human brain data without the need for matched in-vivo cohorts. Table 1: Diffusion