A Control-Theoretic Model of Damage Accumulation and Boundedness in Biological Aging
Tristan Barkman · 2026
Read A Control-Theoretic Model of Damage Accumulation and Boundedness in Biological Aging by Tristan Barkman (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-06657.txt.
Introduction
Barkman develops a control-rule frame of aging, splitting burden into regulatable and information-limited damage. Inner repair tunes tuned damage build-up and clearing, while information-limited damage lies beyond control. An enough theorem states that damage stays bounded if and only if inner repair exceeds tuned damage production. Information-limited damage must be bounded or removed by engineered fixes. Phase diagrams separate bounded, drifting, and runaway regimes across a boundary. Testing finds information-limited making dominates the aging rate, while repair power has weak pull beyond saturation.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tristan Barkman |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 27054 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.06657
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Control-Theoretic Model of Damage Accumulation and Boundedness in Biological Aging Tristan Barkman Abstract Aging interventions frequently improve function and healthspan without arresting long-term deterioration, indicating that existing frameworks do not fully specify the control conditions required for bounded organismal aging. A compact control-theoretic formulation is developed in which total organismal burden is decomposed into two lesion classes with distinct controllability properties: regulatable damage, whose accumulation and clearance are modulated by endogenous systemic repair, and information-limited damage, whose detection or correction is inaccessible to physiological control. Under mild dynamical assumptions, a sufficiency theorem is established: sustained boundedness of total damage is achieved if and only if endogenous repair persistently exceeds production of regulatable damage and information-limited damage is actively bounded or removed by engineered interventions. Deterministic phase diagrams identify distinct bounded, drifting, and runaway regimes separated by a nontrivial control boundary. A global Latin-hypercube sensitivity analysis with partial rank correlations shows that production of information-limited lesions dominates the asymptotic aging rate, whereas increases in physiological repair capacity have weak marginal influence beyond saturation. Stochastic extensions reveal threshold and sequencing effects relevant to oncogenic risk. The framework yields testable predictions and operational guidance for intervention ordering, biomarker selection, and experimental design in aging research. All conclusions are statements about the dynamical model defined here; biological translation requires empirical identification of observables corresponding to the model variables. I Control framework and damage classes Aging research has identified many molecular and cellular hallmarks and interventions that modulate healthspan, yet it remains unclear what minimal control conditions are required to ensure bounded organismal deterioration over time LopezOtin2013 . This paper develops a compact control-theoretic decomposition that reduces the problem to two jointly necessary and sufficient pathways Sanada2025 ; Levine2018 . Total organismal burden D(t) is partitioned into a regulatable component A(t) , whose accumulation and clearance are governed by endogenous, centrally coordinated repair programs, and an information-limited component B(t) , which requires explicit correction or replacement because physiological signalling lacks the requisite information Zhang2013 ; Pickes2011 . Under mild dynamical assumptions a sufficiency theorem is established: the modeled damage burden remains bounded if and only if sustained systemic repair outpaces production for A(t) and engineered removal or bounding of B(t) counteracts its production Jaiswal2014 ; Li2018 . Deterministic phase diagrams illustrate qualitative regimes (Fig. 1 ), and a global Latin-hypercube + PRCC sensitivity analysis identifies the dominant parameters that control the asymptotic aging rate (Fig. 2 ). Implications for safe intervention sequencing, trial design, and biomarker panels are discussed Barzilai2016 ; Horvath2013 . Recent systems-level and dynamical formulations have extended quantitative aging models toward longitudinal forecasting and control-oriented architectures Horvath2013 ; Levine2018 ; Sundial2025 . The present work differs in that it derives necessary and sufficient boundedness conditions for organismal damage accumulation from a control-theoretic perspective, rather than proposing an empirical forecasting architecture. The field of aging research enumerates many molecular and cellular hallmarks (senescence, genomic instability, proteostasis loss, mitochondrial dysfunction, etc.), and an expanding set of interventions modulate lifespan or healthspan in laboratory models LopezOtin2013 ; Harrison2009 ; Fontana2015 . This empirical catalogue leaves open a formal question of control: what minimal set of conditions, stated at an appropriate coarse-grained level, guarantees boundedness of a single scalar measure of organismal burden D(t) for all future times? The present paper addresses that question by treating aging as a control problem and identifying two logically distinct lesion classes: (A) lesions whose clearance rates are modifiable by endogenous systemic regulation, and (B) lesions whose clearing requires engineered detection and correction because physiological observability or controllability is lacking Campisi2013 . The resulting two-pathway sufficiency statement is precise, testable, and operational, and it leads directly to experimentally falsifiable sequencing prescriptions intended to minimize oncogenic and systemic risk Jaiswal2017 ; Abbosh2017 . The biological literature supplies the necessary phenomenology to make this decomposition plausible. Central regulation of repair programs via hypothalamic and neuroendocrine circuits can alter systemic setpoints and clearance rates Zhang2013 ; Tracey2002 , and numerous interventions that elevate repair (exercise, caloric-restriction mimetics, mTOR inhibitors) produce healthspan effects without eliminating age-associated lesion accumulation Harrison2009 ; Fontana2015 ; Longo2014 . Conversely, fixed informational lesions such as somatic driver mutations, deleterious mtDNA heteroplasmies and permanent cell loss are empirically resistant to native repair and require direct removal, correction or replacement Jaiswal2014 ; Li2018 ; Lindvall2010 . This paper contributes three explicit advances. First, it formalizes the otherwise informal “information-limited” lesion class using observability and mutual-information criteria that are empirically estimable from longitudinal biomarkers Levine2018 ; Horvath2013 ; CoverThomas2006 . Second, it proves a two-pathway sufficiency theorem for halting growth of the modeled damage burden (regulatable repair and explicit control of information-limited lesions are jointly required), and it derives control-theoretic sequencing prescriptions via an optimal-control argument Sanada2025 . Third, it quantifies these claims with deterministic phase diagrams and global LHS–PRCC sensitivity, and shows how stochastic fixation amplifies tail risk and enforces sequencing constraints Jaiswal2014 . II Phenomenological model and sufficiency condition The model is intentionally coarse-grained. Variables A(t) and B(t) represent classes of processes distinguished by controllability and observability properties rather than specific molecular species. The results therefore concern structural constraints on dynamical regulation and not immediate clinical outcomes. Any biological application requires identifying measurable proxies for these variables in a given organism or tissue. To formalize the control problem, a coarse-grained phenomenological model is introduced in which total organismal damage is represented by a single scalar burden with distinct dynamical components. A scalar organismal damage burden D(t)\geq 0 is introduced and partitioned operationally as D(t)=A(t)+B(t), where A(t) denotes regulatable damage (clearable by changes in systemic control S(t) ) and B(t) denotes information-limited damage (requiring engineered actions for reliable removal) Pickes2011 ; Li2018 . The corresponding deterministic skeleton is \boxed{\;\dot{A}=\alpha-R_{A}(S)\,A,\qquad\dot{B}=\beta-R_{B}\,B\;} Notation (compact): A(t) = regulatable damage (arbitrary units), B(t) = information-limited damage; \alpha,\beta = baseline production rates (time -1 ); R_{A}(S) = endogenous removal rate (monotone increasing in systemic setpoint S ); R_{B} = engineered removal rate (zero unless active). This deterministic skeleton is used for the formal statements below; stochastic terms \xi_{A,B} are retained for rare-event analyses vanKampen2007 . A compact phenomenological dynamical model is proposed: \displaystyle\dot{A}(t) \displaystyle=\alpha(t)-R_{A}(S(t))\,A(t)+\xi_{A}(t), \displaystyle\dot{B}(t) \displaystyle=\beta(t)-R_{B}(t)\,B(t)+\xi_{B}(t), with \alpha,\beta>0 baseline production rates, R_{A}(S) endogenous multiplicative removal that is monotone in S and bounded above by physiological ceilings, and R_{B}(t) engineered removal which is negligible absent deliberate interventions. Stochastic terms \xi_{A,B} permit analysis of rare events and demographic noise; the main sufficiency argument uses the deterministic skeleton with \xi\equiv 0 . The distinction between regulatable damage A(t) and information-limited damage B(t) can be formalized using concepts from observability and information theory. Consider a coarse-grained physiological state vector x(t) evolving under endogenous dynamics and producing systemic signals y(t) (circulating factors, inflammatory markers, metabolic readouts, etc.) accessible to native control systems. Let L(t) denote a latent lesion state (e.g. a somatic mutation, mtDNA deletion, or lost cell population) contributing to total burden. A lesion class is said to be endogenously observable if the mutual information I\big(L(t);y(t)\big)>0 over physiologically relevant timescales, and endogenously controllable if variations in the control signal S(t) can induce a compensatory response that reduces the expected lesion load, \frac{\partial}{\partial S}\mathbb{E}\!\left[\dot{L}(t)\right]<0. Lesions satisfying both conditions can, in principle, be regulated by native feedback and are classified as A