A Causal Graph Approach to Oppositional Narrative Analysis
Diego Revilla, Martín Fernández-de-Retana, Lingfeng Chen, Aritz Bilbao-Jayo, Miguel Fernandez-de-Retana · 2026
Read A Causal Graph Approach to Oppositional Narrative Analysis by Diego Revilla, Martín Fernández-de-Retana, Lingfeng Chen, Aritz Bilbao-Jayo, Miguel Fernandez-de-Retana (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-06135.txt.
Introduction
Revilla and colleagues tackle telling legitimate critical speech apart from coordinated conspiracy narratives, where labeled roles and rigid schemas miss diffuse participation. Their pipeline pulls an entity interaction graph from narratives with a BERT encoder and classifies it with a Heterogeneous Graph Transformer. Counterfactual distillation then estimates each node's treatment effect and prunes extras, leaving a minimal predictive subgraph. On the PAN benchmark the model reaches state of the art accuracy with roughly a third of its nearest rival's parameters. It prunes graphs by about three quarters on average.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Diego Revilla, Martín Fernández-de-Retana, Lingfeng Chen, Aritz Bilbao-Jayo, Miguel Fernandez-de-Retana |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32165 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.06135
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Causal Graph Approach to Oppositional Narrative Analysis Diego Revilla, Martín Fernández-de-Retana, Lingfeng Chen, Aritz Bilbao-Jayo, Miguel Fernandez-de-Retana Abstract Current methods for textual analysis rely on data annotated within predefined ontologies, often embedding human bias within black-box models. Despite achieving near-perfect performance, these approaches exploit unstructured, linear pattern recognition rather than modeling the structured interactions between entities that naturally emerge in discourse. In this work, we propose a graph-based framework for the detection, analysis, and classification of oppositional narratives and their underlying entities by representing narratives as entity-interaction graphs. Moreover, by incorporating causal estimation at the node level, our approach derives a causal representation of each contribution to the final classification by distilling the constructed sentence graph into a minimal causal subgraph. Building upon this representation, we introduce a classification pipeline that outperforms existing approaches to oppositional thinking classification task. 1 Introduction Conspiracy theories pose a significant threat to society on multiple levels. They can be deliberately exploited to manipulate public opinion, and exert pressure on public institutions, thereby influencing their decision-making processes Greenburgh and Raihani 2022 ; Moore 2016 . During the COVID-19 pandemic, conspiracy narratives and targeted attacks circulating on social media became a major risk factor which increases the general distrust in institutions Romer and Jamieson 2020 . Therefore, the automated and fast identification of coordinated narratives and potential aggregated attacks is of critical importance. The identification of key features that enable the distinction between critical speech and coordinated attacks within a narrative constitutes a complex challenge in natural language processing. This task typically involves uncovering the underlying entities with relational structures in the input text that define the roles participating in such attacks. Moreover, identifying the entities actually involved in such narratives is often challenging due to the subtlety of context and the terms that are normally used with hidden intentions, which complicates the automation of the task, and in many cases, annotators may introduce personal biases or fail to properly resolve references. Our main contribution lies in extracting a causal graph representation from narrative text and subsequently distilling this graph to identify the primary entities driving a conspiracy narrative. Unlike approaches that depend on labeled data or predefined role schemas, which often introduce edge cases and fail to capture the inherently continuous and diffused nature of participation Liu and Roth 2026 , our method avoids rigid role assignments. Instead, we enable the model to learn how to select, classify, and filter textual spans in order to construct coherent and contextually appropriate representation of the discourse for classification. In summary, our main contributions are: • Causal Graph Representation: We propose a pipeline to extract entity-interaction graphs, modeling structural interactions without relying on predefined role schemas. • Minimal Causal Graph Distillation: We introduce a distillation procedure to estimate the Individual Treatment Effect (ITE) of nodes, pruning extraneous nodes and extracting the potential minimal causal subgraph. • Graph-Attention Classification Method: We achieve an F_{1} -score of 0.93, ranking first in the designated classification task, demonstrating the efficacy of causal graphs for detecting conspiracy vectors. In this paper, we train the model to generate a bipartite graph consisting of two sets of vertices. The first set, V , is of dynamic size d and represents the entities identified in the discourse. The second set, E , is a predefined set of size k whose vertices correspond to relation nodes that connect entities. The graph structure is represented by an incidence matrix A . During the causality stage, we reinterpret this structure as an undirected hypergraph, where the vertices in E are treated as hyperedges over the entity set V . Although this correspondence does not strictly hold in certain edge cases, such as when no relations exist between entities or when the graph is empty, for clarity and simplicity of exposition, we will be treating the bipartite graph as an hypergraph throughout this work. Table 4 (Appendix) summarizes all hyperparameters and equipment used in the experimental setup. The implementation of the model and the source code to replicate the experiment can be found at Github Repository 2 Related Work Entity Framing : The original task named entity recognition has been approached in various ways. Before the emergence of deep learning Rumelhart et al. 1986 and other black-box models, Natural Policy Framing Blair and McCormack 2016 was proposed as a methodological approach based on content analysis to identify the classic narrative roles of hero, villain, and victim. This framework was later refined with approaches that leveraged role dictionaries and sentiment analysis Gomez-Zara et al. 2018 . The task was then generalized to entity framing, which combines two sub-tasks: identifying characters and classifying the roles assigned to each character. In the present, the predominating technique in the state of the art consist of fine-tuning a foundational LLM for the specific NER task Mahmoud et al. 2025 . Inherent Graph Representation : Many problems and real-world scenarios can be naturally represented as graphs, such as RNA structure prediction Koessler et al. 2010 and Protein-Protein Interaction Xu et al. 2024 . This structural perspective has motivated the development of Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) Scarselli et al. 2009 . However, certain tasks require the explicit modeling of causal relationships within the underlying context, thereby motivating the integration of causal inference principles into graph-based methods. This line of work has given rise to Causal Graph Neural Networks (Causal GNNs) Wein et al. 2020 ; Du et al. 2024 . Subsequently, causal discovery methods were further enhanced through GNN-based probabilistic frameworks that learn stochastic distributions over the space of possible graph structures Rashid and Terejanu 2024 . Moreover, recent efforts have focused on learning robust graphical representations and performing neural architecture search in real-world settings where the i.i.d. assumption does not hold, such as in datasets exhibiting distribution shifts Wang et al. 2025 ; Li et al. 2024a . In the field of natural language processing, several efforts have been made to transform human-readable text into graph-based representations. The main goal is to improve the performance of current state-of-the-art models on tasks such as text classification, where subcontextual information can be captured more effectively in graphs Bugueño and de Melo 2023 . Within this line of research, linguistic approaches use large language models (LLMs) to summarize information and convert it into nodes, which are then connected through semantic relationships Li et al. 2025 . Graph-based text classification can also be improved with contrastive learning and data augmentation, where augmented graphs are generated from the text to improve generalization performance Li et al. 2024b . Furthermore, unsupervised methods based on cyclic training have been proposed, especially for smaller datasets, where the high cost of data collection makes fully supervised learning less feasible Guo et al. 2020 . Graph Interpretation Problem : Evaluating and interpreting graphical representations of real-world information to determine their quality, as well as assessing the extent of information preserved or lost, remains a challenging task. Focusing on the evaluation of a graphical representation, HL-HGAT (Hodge-Laplacian Heterogeneous Graph Attention Network) Huang et al. 2024 , a graphical neural network that extends GNNs to handle not only nodes and edges, but also higher-dimensional simplices (e.g., triangles). In terms of interpretability and explainability, several traditional techniques were