On Thrust Resummation Ambiguities in e + e − e^{+}e^{-} Annihilation into Hadrons Preprint: CERN-TH-2026-029
Luca Buonocore, Paolo Nason, Luca Rottoli, Paolo Torrielli · 2026
Read On Thrust Resummation Ambiguities in e + e − e^{+}e^{-} Annihilation into Hadrons Preprint: CERN-TH-2026-029 by Luca Buonocore, Paolo Nason, Luca Rottoli, Paolo Torrielli (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-06091.txt.
Introduction
Buonocore, Nason, Rottoli, Torrielli ask whether other legal re-summing rules for thrust in e-plus-minus wipeout can shift forecasts a lot. Fixed-order QCD forecasts near the two-jet limit use re-summing, yet matching rules differ through sub-leading terms. The authors compare paired-space re-summing against direct-space re-summing in the thrust value. At the double-log level, flipping the Laplace change yields meeting terms. From leading-log score the Landau pole makes the spread long-run, and setup biases exceed quoted doubts.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Luca Buonocore, Paolo Nason, Luca Rottoli, Paolo Torrielli |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 102217 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.06091
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On Thrust Resummation Ambiguities in e + e − e^{+}e^{-} Annihilation into Hadrons Preprint: CERN-TH-2026-029 Luca Buonocore, Paolo Nason, Luca Rottoli, Paolo Torrielli Abstract In e + e − e^{+}e^{-} shape-variable studies, and in particular for the case of thrust, fixed-order QCD predictions are typically supplemented with the resummation of contributions enhanced near the two-jet limit. In this work we examine whether different, yet legitimate, resummation prescriptions can induce significant differences in the resulting predictions. This can occur because formally equivalent prescriptions may differ by terms that, although subleading, are characterised by asymptotic expansions and may therefore lead to slow convergence. We first compare two alternative formulations of resummation: the conjugate-space (or Laplace-space) approach, in which resummation is performed in a variable conjugate to thrust, such that the observable factorises exactly in the soft-collinear limit; and the direct-space formulation, where resummation is instead carried out directly in the thrust variable. We show that, at double-logarithmic level, the inverse Laplace transform generates a convergent tower of subleading terms. Starting from leading-logarithmic accuracy, the expansion becomes asymptotic due to the presence of the Landau pole, leading to a mild log-factorial growth of the coefficients. When including the highest available logarithmic order in the resummation, matched to fixed-order results, we still find non-negligible differences between predictions obtained in the two spaces. We then consider a formulation of the resummation that avoids certain approximations commonly used in the derivation of conjugate-space resummation. We observe that this also has a non-negligible numerical impact. In general, we find that the systematics stemming from the adoption of different formalisms typically exceeds the quoted theoretical uncertainties, suggesting the need for more conservative theory-error estimates when using the thrust distribution in determinations of the strong coupling. 1 Introduction The electron-positron annihilation into hadrons at high energy is perhaps the simplest framework in which to test perturbative QCD. Its advantage over deep-inelastic scattering and hadronic collisions is due to the fact that inclusive quantities in the asymptotic limit can be computed as functions of the strong coupling alone. It turns out, however, that the determination of the strong coupling constant from the distribution of shape variables in e^{+}e^{-}\to hadrons is affected by uncertainties that are, at the moment, difficult to control. Shape variables have been computed in fixed-order QCD calculations up to the third power in the strong coupling constant (i.e. N 3 LO order) Gehrmann-DeRidder:2007foh ; Gehrmann-DeRidder:2007vsv ; Gehrmann-DeRidder:2008qsl ; Weinzierl:2008iv ; Weinzierl:2009ms . Resummation of enhanced contributions near the two-jet limit is routinely performed, using either traditional QCD resummation methods Catani:1992ua ; Catani:1998sf ; Dokshitzer:1998kz ; Banfi:2001bz ; Monni:2011gb ; Banfi:2014sua ; Tulipant:2017ybb ; Banfi:2016zlc , or Soft-Collinear Effective Theory (SCET) Becher:2008cf ; Chien:2010kc ; Becher:2012qc ; Becher:2011pf . Furthermore it is known that non-perturbative effects cannot be neglected even at a scale as high as LEP energies. These are treated either by using the hadronisation models of shower Monte-Carlo generators (see for example Dissertori:2009ik ; OPAL:2011aa ; Bethke:2008hf ; Dissertori:2009qa ; Schieck:2012mp ; Verbytskyi:2019zhh ; Kardos:2018kqj ), by using analytic models Akhoury:1995sp ; Dokshitzer:1995qm ; Dokshitzer:1997iz ; Dokshitzer:1998pt ; Gardi:2001di ; Gardi:2002bg ; Gardi:2003iv ; Berger:2004xf ; Agarwal:2020uxi , or by relying upon factorisation in QCD Korchemsky:1999kt ; Korchemsky:2000kp ; Bauer:2003di ; Lee:2006nr , mainly in the SCET framework Bauer:2000yr ; Bauer:2001yt . Determinations performed in the analytic models typically lead to very low values of the strong coupling constant Abbate:2010xh ; Gehrmann:2012sc ; Hoang:2015hka ; Benitez:2024nav ; Benitez:2025vsp . In Refs. Luisoni:2020efy ; Nason:2023asn ; Nason:2025qbx it has been argued that the standard approaches to the parametrisation of non-perturbative effects, that were extrapolated from their two-jet limit value, were unjustified, and that this extrapolation might have been the cause of the small values of \alpha_{s} in the analytic and SCET approaches. Furthermore, it was argued there that large uncertainties are to be associated in general with the determination of \alpha_{s} from shape variables. Thrust was among the first shape variables to be introduced Brandt:1964sa ; Farhi:1977sg , and it was also one of the first for which the resummation of logarithmically enhanced contributions was studied. Thrust is defined in the centre-of-mass frame of the hadronic system in terms of the three-momenta \vec{p}_{i} of all particles, as T\,=\,\max_{\vec{t}}\,\frac{\sum_{i}|\vec{p}_{i}\cdot\vec{t}\,|}{\sum_{i}|\vec{p}_{i}|}\,, (1) where \vec{t} (the thrust axis) is a unit vector. One also usually defines \tau\,\equiv\,1-T , and the two-jet limit is recovered when T\to 1 , i.e. \tau\to 0 . In the earliest works on thrust resummation, it was observed that the factorisation of the phase space for soft gluon emission can be conveniently achieved by considering the Laplace transform of the \tau distribution, thereby introducing a Laplace variable, usually denoted by N . Resummation was therefore typically performed in N space, and only at the end was the distribution in \tau obtained by means of an inverse Laplace transform. We will refer to this approach as the “conjugate” space one. An alternative method, called “direct” space method, works instead directly in \tau space. The two approaches differ by terms that are subleading with respect to the declared logarithmic accuracy of the resummation. In Ref. Aglietti:2025jdj ; Aglietti:2025ezs it is claimed that these subleading terms are instead numerically important, and lead to sizeable differences in the results. In particular, the fitted value of \alpha_{s} obtained in Ref. Aglietti:2025jdj is fully compatible with the PDG average, at variance with the results in direct space, that yield low values in tension with the world average. 1 1 1 We remark that the fitting strategy adopted in Ref. Aglietti:2025jdj differs substantially from that of other groups. In particular, the peak region of the thrust distribution is included in the fit, and non-perturbative effects are modeled by means of a shape-function-inspired two-parameter Gaussian ansatz. There has been one interesting instance in the past where the choice of resummation space made a substantial numerical difference in the value of the predicted cross sections, i.e. the resummation of threshold-enhanced contributions in hadronic collisions Catani:1996dj ; Catani:1996yz . In that case, large differences arose between the conjugate- and the direct-space results, because the latter contained logarithmically subleading terms with factorially-growing coefficients. The associated perturbative expansion was thus asymptotic, with a resummation ambiguity corresponding to an inverse power of Q^{a} , with a<1 , and Q being the hard scale of the process. In the context of threshold resummation it was easy to show that the growth of the perturbative coefficients in direct space is due to the violation of longitudinal momentum conservation, which is instead conserved in conjugate space, leading to the conclusion that the latter approach is preferable. It is thus interesting to investigate also in the case of thrust whether there are reasons to prefer one formulation over the other, based on the convergence properties of the perturbative expansion. More in general, in the present work we focus on formally subleading effects that can in practice have an important numerical impact on the results. In addition to those arising from the inversion from conjugate to direct space, we consider a different mechanism that can potentially generate large subleading terms, which we dub here the “theta-function approximation”. This approximation has been used in the derivation of the conjugate-space formula since the seminal paper