CodeScout: Contextual Problem Statement Enhancement for Software Agents
Manan Suri, Xiangci Li, Mehdi Shojaie, Songyang Han, Chao-Chun Hsu, Shweta Garg, Aniket Deshmukh, Varun Kumar · 2026
Read CodeScout: Contextual Problem Statement Enhancement for Software Agents by Manan Suri, Xiangci Li, Mehdi Shojaie, Songyang Han, Chao-Chun Hsu, Shweta Garg, Aniket Deshmukh, Varun Kumar (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-05744.txt.
Introduction
Suri and team present CodeScout, turning vague requests into usable problem statements via lightweight pre-look of the target codebase. Current code help tools struggle with poorly-defined statements lacking context and needs spec. Failures on vague requests go with longer paths involving extra looking. It performs context scoping and multi-view study, then makes statements with repro steps, expected actions, and study hints. This pre-look reduces non-closing paths. On SWE-bench-Verified, it improves fix rates by 20%, with up to 27 more issues resolved.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Manan Suri, Xiangci Li, Mehdi Shojaie, Songyang Han, Chao-Chun Hsu, Shweta Garg, Aniket Deshmukh, Varun Kumar |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45889 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.05744
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
CodeScout: Contextual Problem Statement Enhancement for Software Agents Manan Suri, Xiangci Li, Mehdi Shojaie, Songyang Han, Chao-Chun Hsu, Shweta Garg, Aniket Deshmukh, Varun Kumar Abstract Current AI-powered code assistance tools often struggle with poorly-defined problem statements that lack sufficient task context and requirements specification. Recent analysis of software engineering agents reveals that failures on such underspecified requests are highly correlated with longer trajectories involving either over-exploration or repeated attempts at applying the same fix without proper evolution or testing, leading to suboptimal outcomes across software development tasks. We introduce CodeScout, a contextual query refinement approach that systematically converts underspecified user requests into comprehensive, actionable problem statements through lightweight pre-exploration of the target codebase. Our key innovation is demonstrating that structured analysis before task execution can supplement existing agentic capabilities without requiring any modifications to their underlying scaffolds. CodeScout performs targeted context scoping, conducts multi-perspective analysis examining potential fixes and exploration opportunities, then synthesizes these insights into enhanced problem statements with reproduction steps, expected behaviors, and targeted exploration hints. This pre-exploration directly addresses the identified failure patterns by reducing non-converging agent trajectories while clarifying user intent in natural language space. We evaluate CodeScout using state-of-the-art agentic scaffolds and language models on SWEBench-Verified, demonstrating a 20% improvement in resolution rates with up to 27 additional issues resolved compared to the default baseline method. Our results suggest that systematic query refinement through contextual analysis represents a promising direction for enhancing AI code assistance capabilities. 1 Introduction The rapid advancement of large language models (LLMs) has revolutionized software development assistance, with AI-powered coding tools becoming increasingly integral to modern workflows 8 ; 5 . Yet a fundamental challenge persists: these systems often fail not because the underlying models lack reasoning capability, but because they are asked to operate on poorly specified problem statements 12 . Developers frequently provide concise, context-dependent descriptions—omitting reproduction steps, technical details, or clear expectations—that assume a shared understanding of the codebase. In contrast, LLM-based agents work optimally with explicit, well-scoped specifications to reason effectively 13 . Empirical studies validate this phenomenon: 12 found that resolvable bug reports exhibit drastically higher description quality scores, with relative differences ranging from 110% to over 2700% compared to non-resolvable ones. Similarly, 13 showed that rejected code suggestions in Google’s LLM-integrated development tools strongly correlate with low-quality user inputs. Recent analysis by 4 reveals that software engineering agent failures exhibit specific behavioral patterns: over-exploration where agents fail to reach the root of the problem due to context overload, and repeated application of the same fix without proper testing or evolution, demonstrating stubborn agentic behavior and lack of understanding of code or user intent. Together, these findings highlight that input quality—not just model capacity—forms the critical bottleneck in AI-assisted software engineering. Figure 1: The original SWEBench problem statement for Instance django__django-11790 lack relevant initial context. As a result, the downstream agent is not able to fix the issue, despite spending 21 steps exploring the repository, analyzing code, iterating the fix patch. In contrast, the enhanced problem statement generated by our approach resolves the issue in 6 agentic steps, as it includes relevant insights that can be used off-the-bat by the agent. This specification gap is exacerbated by how current agents operate, but why do current agentic workflows struggle with this challenge? We hypothesize this occurs for several fundamental reasons. First, agents plan and implement simultaneously at a step-by-step granularity through reason-execute-observe loops, lacking the long-horizon understanding necessary for complex debugging tasks and accumulating deviations from the true problem scope. Second, without comprehensive upfront context, agents become trapped in reactive exploration, facing information asymmetry where they must discover codebase structure incrementally while lacking the hierarchical abstraction capabilities to build strategic mental models. Figure 1 exemplifies this: a sparse Django bug report leads to 21 steps of unfocused exploration and failure, while an enhanced problem statement enables success in just 6 targeted steps. This observation motivates a shift in perspective: instead of expecting agents to "leap" directly into problem-solving, we argue they must first look—building comprehensive understanding before attempting fixes. We introduce CodeScout, a contextual problem statement enhancement method, that transforms vague developer queries into rich, repository-aware actionable problem statements. Compared to traditional localization or context retrieval methods that merely identify relevant code, CodeScout provides detailed exploration plans, task decomposition, fix hints, and strategic guidance. Key advantages include: supplementing existing agents without requiring scaffold modifications, enabling long-horizon strategic alignment, reducing non-converging trajectories, and working universally across agent architectures. Main contributions : 1. CodeScout, a systematic approach for contextual problem specification enhancement that improves input quality through repository-aware analysis, demonstrating 20% improvement in resolution rates with up to 27 additional issues resolved. 2. Empirical validation demonstrating CodeScout’s effectiveness across multiple software engineering tasks and agent architectures, showing consistent performance gains. 3. Detailed analysis of how CodeScout’s contextual augmentation influences agent trajectories, tool usage, and problem-solving strategies, revealing cross-validation performance gains that generalize across different agent implementations. We demonstrate compelling cost-efficiency dynamics: smaller models can effectively perform problem statement enhancement to improve larger model performance, while strong models can augment problem statements to dramatically boost weaker model capabilities. Our results suggest that investing computation in upfront problem understanding offers a powerful complement to advances in model capacity and agentic reasoning, pointing toward more reliable AI-assisted software engineering. 2 Related Work LLM-based Software Agents LLM-based agents 20 ; 16 have emerged as autonomous systems that use large language models as reasoning engines to perform complex software engineering tasks through planning, tool usage, and iterative problem-solving. These agents substantially extend the versatility of LLMs by enhancing them with capabilities for perceiving and utilizing external resources and tools, providing autonomy through key components including planning, memory, perception, and action 10 . The sophisticated capabilities demonstrated by these agents directly motivated our work: while they excel at execution and reasoning, their performance degrades significantly when operating on poorly specified problem statements—a fundamental limitation that CodeScout addresses. The evolution from traditional LLM applications to autonomous agents represents a significant shift in software engineering automation. While earlier approaches typically operated through single prompts or hard-coded feedback loops for tasks like code completion 24 ; 2 , automated program repair 5 , and test generation 9 ; 17 ; 22 , modern LLM agents 4 can autonomously plan and execute sequences of actions while adapting based on feedback from tools and environments. Several prominent agent frameworks have demonstrated effectiveness across software engineering tasks, but also revealed the input quality bottleneck that CodeScout targets. RepairAgent 3 treats the LLM as an autonomous agent capable of planning and executing actions to fix bugs by invoking suitable tools, freely interleaving information gathering, repair ingredient collection, and fix validation. AutoCodeRover 23 combines LLMs with sophisticated code search capabilities, working on program representations like abstract syntax trees rather than viewing projects as mere file collections. SWE-agent 21 introduces custom agent-computer interfaces that significantly enhance agents’ abilities to create, edit, navigate repositories, and execute tests. However, these agents share a critical limitation: they cannot compensate for fundamentally under-specified input problems. Unlike CodeScout, which proactively enhances problem understanding before agent execution, existing agents rely on reactive exploration that often leads to the over-exploration and repeated fix application patterns identified by recent analysis 4 .