Querying with Conflicts of Interest

Nischal Aryal, Arash Termehchy, Marianne Winslett · 2026

Read Querying with Conflicts of Interest by Nischal Aryal, Arash Termehchy, Marianne Winslett (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-05704.txt.

Introduction

Aryal and team propose a formal framework for querying when sources return biased answers on purpose. Conflicts arise over reading user information needs. A product search may rank products higher for revenue rather than following the user's desired ranking. Proposed fair-result schemes usually lack use, since biases often increase profits. The framework offers code for spotting whether info can be pulled from biased sources, spotting biased information in results, and changing queries for fitting returns. Tests on real data sets show fast code giving fitting information over large data.

Catalog record

CREATORNischal Aryal, Arash Termehchy, Marianne Winslett
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE112784
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.05704

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Querying with Conflicts of Interest Nischal Aryal, Arash Termehchy, Marianne Winslett Abstract . Conflicts of interest often arise between data sources and their users regarding how the users’ information needs should be interpreted by the data source. For example, an online product search might be biased towards presenting certain products higher than in its list of results to improve its revenue, which may not follow the user’s desired ranking expressed in their query. The research community has proposed schemes for data systems to implement to ensure unbiased results. However, data systems and services usually have little or no incentive to implement these measures, e.g., these biases often increase their profits. In this paper, we propose a novel formal framework for querying in settings where the data source has incentives to return biased answers intentionally due to the conflict of interest between the user and the data source. We propose efficient algorithms to detect whether it is possible for users to extract relevant information from biased data sources. We propose methods to detect biased information in the results of a query efficiently. We also propose algorithms to reformulate input queries to increase the amount of relevant information in the returned results over biased data sources. Using experiments on real-world datasets, we show that our algorithms are efficient and return relevant information over large data. 1. Introduction Due to financial, social, and political factors, the incentives of data source owners (data sources for short) and their users are often not perfectly aligned. For example, data sources that provide information about products may benefit financially from convincing users to buy certain products. In fact, Amazon, Google, and Apple have been accused of returning results that are biased in this manner ( Mattioli 2019 ; Fussell 2019 ; Mickle 2019 ; Nicas and Collins 2019 ) . As an example, Apple allegedly reworked its ranking algorithm so that Apple Music was ranked first and Spotify 23rd in the App Store when a user searched for music apps ( Nicas and Collins 2019 ) . Similarly, a search for podcast apps returned Apple Podcasts in the first place, followed by 12 irrelevant Apple apps, and then finally podcast apps from other publishers. A search for “TV” in 2018-9 would return Apple apps at the top, and Netflix ranked in the 100s ( Nicas and Collins 2019 ) . As experts commented at the time: “I find it hard to believe that organically there are certain Apple apps that rank better than higher-reviewed, more downloaded competitors,” and “there’s just a ton to be gained commercially by dominating” search results ( Nicas and Collins 2019 ) . This conflict of interest is inherent at some data sources, such as shopping websites, which charge sellers a ‘referral fee’ of considerable fraction of the price of items sold on its site ( Amazon 2025 ) , so that it profits more when users buy higher-priced versions of a given product. Cost-conscious users who re-sort the results by price may have to wade through many undesirable results before reaching the first good match. Example 1.1. On the day of this writing, a search for ‘headset’ on a well-known shopping website ( SW for short) returns headphones priced $24.99 to $39.95 in its top ‘Results’ section, and all items on the remainder of the page are indeed headphones. When re-sorted by price, the top hit on the first page is a charging cord, followed by earbuds, microphones, cables, and one $1.98 headset. Only on the seventh page of results do headphones start to outnumber other accessories. Conflicts of interest may also arise from non-financial considerations. To maximize user engagement, some social media sites may promote extreme content, which is not necessarily in anyone else’s best interest. More generally, data sources may return information that is biased toward or against controversial topics and causes, political groups, or demographic groups, e.g., not returning or giving a low rank to information related to these ( Zehlike et al. 2022a ; Zehlike et al. 2022b ) . Perhaps the best known recent example is the removal of all topics related to climate change from US government websites ( Zraik 2024 ) . Data sources that belong to foreign adversaries can also promote content that serves the objectives of the data source owner. In the aforementioned settings, data sources interpret the information in user queries to take actions that do not exactly meet users’ preferences and objectives and, in fact, might largely deviate from what users deem as desirable. Current proposals to combat undesirable data source actions usually require the data source to follow and implement certain protocols ( Stoyanovich et al. 2022 ) . For example, researchers have proposed methods to remove bias and ensure fairness for data sources to implement ( Zehlike et al. 2022a ; Zehlike et al. 2022b ; Zehlike et al. 2017 ; Zehlike and Castillo 2020 ; Tabibian et al. 2020 ; Mathioudakis et al. 2020 ) . However, data sources often do not have any incentive to implement these proposals because these are usually against their objectives and business models. Some might also argue that these restrictions limit the freedom to disseminate information or conduct business and may not be ethical or have long-term adverse impacts on our society. In such a situation, the data source and users do share some interests: the data source would like to satisfy the information needs behind users’ queries well enough to keep them engaged. Users can leverage this partial common interest by modifying their queries so that the data source interpretations of the submitted queries are those desired by users. Example 1.2. Consider again the user in Example 1.1 who looks for affordable headphones on SW. If the results are biased towards relatively more expensive products, she can add a price cap to her query. For example, when we reissued the SW headset query with a $19 maximum price, the second result returned cost $21, but the others on the first page cost less than $19. Thus, SW does not take price caps literally, but they do influence the results. But two can play at this game. The data source may be aware of the fact that users know about its undesirable actions, e.g., users have observed undesirable biases in their previous experiences of using the data source. Thus, it may reason that users aim at guiding its interpretations and results towards the users’ desired results by modifying their original queries. Since it is not in the data source’s best interest to accept the modified query as precisely the user’s true information need, the data source may try to recover the original intent behind the modified query. For instance, it might also use its prior belief about users’ intents, e.g., gained from external sources or previous interactions with users, to interpret the true intent behind the modified query. Consequently, users may reason about the data source reasoning process and try to modify their queries more drastically to influence the data source interpretation. The user and data source reason and make decisions based on possible reasoning and strategies of each other iteratively to find the best method to formulate and interpret queries. Example

Read the complete text