Classical Explanations in (and of) General Probabilistic Theories
John Harding, Alex Wilce · 2026
Read Classical Explanations in (and of) General Probabilistic Theories by John Harding, Alex Wilce (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-05627.txt.
Introduction
Harding and Wilce define what it means for one broad chance model to explain another: a special kind of span in Prob, the group of chance models and maps. They join under a standard pullback build, even though Prob does not support any pullbacks. Every locally-finite chance model then has a standard, sharp classic explanation. This rule spreads this to every locally-finite chance theory, giving a standard, sharp classic picture, though usually non-local.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | John Harding, Alex Wilce |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 61074 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.05627
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Classical Explanations in (and of) General Probabilistic Theories John Harding, Alex Wilce Abstract We introduce a notion of the “explanation” of one (generalized) probabilistic model by another as particular kind of span in the category Prob of probabilistic models and morphisms. We show that explanations compose under a standard pullback construction (notwithstanding that Prob does not support arbitrary pullbacks). We then show that every locally-finite probabilistic model has a canonical, sharp classical explanation. The construction is functorial, so every locally-finite probabilistic theory has a canonical, sharp classical (though of course, usually non-local) representation. 1 Introduction Classical probability theory contains the tacit assumption that all experiments have common refinements, and can, therefore, effectively be performed jointly. QM suggests that this is not a reasonable assumption. Attempts to generalize probability theory in order to accommodate incompatible experiments have proceeded along two main lines: the “quantum-logic” approach, in which Boolean algebras are replaced by more general orthocomplemented posets (typically, orthomodular lattices or posets), and the “convex” approach, in which the simplex of probability measures on a classical measurable space is replaced by a more-or-less arbitrary convex set (typically compact, or at least radially bounded) with states represented by so-called effects. The literature is replete with theorems showing that models of either of these types can be represented — in one way or another — in terms of a classical probabilistic model, provided we are willing to accept (i) failures of contextuality and (ii) loss of locality. However, these results are obtained within several different formal frameworks, and the representations they offer are not all equivalent. Our purpose in this paper is to provide a unified, and somewhat more general, picture; one that we believe is ultimately clarifying. We begin by reviewing a framework for generalized probability theory that includes both the quantum logic and convex approaches as special cases, and, within this, constructing a category Prob of concrete probabilistic models, following [ 9 , 24 , 25 ] . We then propose a precise definition of an explanation of one probabilistic model by another (briefly: a particular kind of span in Prob ). Reworking a construction first detailed in [ 21 ] , we show that there exists an endofunctor \mbox{\sf Bor}:\mbox{\bf Prob}\rightarrow\mbox{\bf Prob} sending each probabilistic model A to a classical Borel model \mbox{\sf Bor}(A) , in terms of which A has an explanation. We explain how this generalizes the classical embeddings and extensions of Beltrametti and Bugajski [ 3 ] as well as the framework of ontological models [ 15 ] . We also note that any probabilistic theory — a functor M:{\mathcal{C}}\rightarrow\mbox{\bf Prob} , where {\mathcal{C}} is a category representing physical systems and processes [ 23 , 24 , 25 ] — has a classical representation, namely, \mbox{\sf Bor}\circ M . Finally, we explore the ways in which this canonical “classicalization” interacts with composite systems. The results are unsurprising: if AB is a nonsignalling composite of A and B , then if AB admits a classical explanation in our sense, then all of its states are separable as joint probability weights, but not necessarily as joint states, of A and B — a distinction we explain in Section 4. It follows that entangled probability weights on AB have no classical explanation, even in our quite generous sense. We also consider how Bell’s Theorem can be formulated in this framework. What novelty there is here consists in the level of generality (e.g., we do not assume local tomography or finite-dimensionality, and allow for a broader notion of classical explanation than is usually dealt with in the literature), and in the detailed development of the mathematics supporting this generality. In Section 5, we conclude with some quasi-philosophical reflections on the different attitudes one can reasonably take about the significance of this result for our understanding of the world. Somewhat similar ideas are explored in an earlier paper by Gheorgiu and Heunen [ 11 ] in the more restricted context of ontological models of quantum theory. Specifically, Gheorgiu and Heunen consider an ontological model as a functor from Hilb to the category Markov of measurable spaces and Markov processes. However, [ 11 ] are more concerned with reproducing existing no-go results; our focus here is on positive results. 2 Probabilistic models and theories In discrete classical probability theory, a probabilistic model is usually understood to consist of the outcome-set E of some experiment, together with a single probability weight thereon. There are two obvious ways in which to generalize: one is to allow for multiple experiments (and thus, multiple outcome-sets); the other is to allow for multiple probability weights. One motivation for the former is to better understand theories like QM in which distinct statistical experiments can be incompatible. The motivation for the latter is simply to allow for some uncertainty as to the true probability weight, e.g., in situations in which many different probability weights can be prepared (either deliberately or “by Nature”.) These ideas motivate the following notions (see, e.g., [ 6 , 9 , 22 ] ): A test space or manual 1 1 1 “Manual” is the older term; it motivates our notation, and survives in the names of some of our examples. is a collection {\mathcal{M}} of non-empty sets, understood as outcome-sets for some catalogue of possible experiments. We refer to X=\bigcup{\mathcal{M}} as the outcome-space for {\mathcal{M}} . A probability weight on {\mathcal{M}} is a function \omega:X\rightarrow[0,1] summing to one on each test. We write {\mathcal{P}r}({\mathcal{M}}) for the set of all probability weights on {\mathcal{M}} . Note that {\mathcal{P}r}({\mathcal{M}})\leq[0,1]^{X} is convex. If {\mathcal{M}} is locally finite , meaning that all tests are finite, then {\mathcal{P}r}({\mathcal{M}}) is also pointwise closed, and hence, compact. 2.1 Definition . A probabilistic model — PM , for short — is simply a pair ({\mathcal{M}},\Omega) where {\mathcal{M}} is a test space and \Omega is a set of probability weights on {\mathcal{M}} , referred to as the state space of the model. A very simple example consists of single test E and a single probability weight \mu thereon. For another, consider {\mathcal{M}}=\{\{a,b\},\{u,v\}\} with \Omega={\mathcal{P}r}({\mathcal{M}}) : it is easy to see that a probability weight on {\mathcal{M}} is determined uniquely by its values on a and u , so we have an affine isomorphism {\mathcal{P}r}({\mathcal{M}})\rightarrow[0,1]^{2} . Any subset \Omega of [0,1]^{2} can serve as the state space for a model based on {\mathcal{M}} . We will consider further examples immediately below. At this stage, we impose no conditions on either {\mathcal{M}} or \Omega . 2.1 Classical and Quantum Models We now outline how standard measure-theoretic probability theory and its non-commutative analogue based on von Neumann algebras both fit into the current framework. 2.2 Example ( Borel models). If S is a topological space, the corresponding Borel test space is the collection {\mathcal{B}}(S) of finite or partitions of S by Borel sets. Thus, outcomes of {\mathcal{B}}(S) are non-empty Borel sets, and events are finite pairwise disjoint collections of Borel sets. Two events are perspective iff they have the same union; using this, it easily follows that probability weights on {\mathcal{B}}(S) are essentially the same things as finitely-additive Borel probability measures on S 2 2 2 Indeed, a finitely-additive Borel probability measure is simply a probability weight on