Vertical Structure of Protoplanetary Disks in Scattered Light: A large sample analysis

J. Byrne, C. Ginski, R. F. van Capelleveen, N. Fitzgerald, A. Garufi, C. Coyne, C. Lawlor, D. McLachlan · 2026

Read Vertical Structure of Protoplanetary Disks in Scattered Light: A large sample analysis by J. Byrne, C. Ginski, R. F. van Capelleveen, N. Fitzgerald, A. Garufi, C. Coyne, C. Lawlor, D. McLachlan (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-05599.txt.

Introduction

Byrne and team fit ovals to scattered-light images of protoplanetary disks to extract dust-scattered surface heights. Their pulling and oval fitting method locates shapes via edge spotting and Gaussian fitting. Oval fitting reveals offsets between oval centers and stellar spots, read as vertical height if rings are circles. The method yields height readings for 92 disks, matching flared shapes, but no single power-law link fits the full sample. Big disks with outer radii above about 150 au show a clear flaring trend.

Catalog record

CREATORJ. Byrne, C. Ginski, R. F. van Capelleveen, N. Fitzgerald, A. Garufi, C. Coyne, C. Lawlor, D. McLachlan
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE97162
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.05599

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Vertical Structure of Protoplanetary Disks in Scattered Light: A large sample analysis J. Byrne, C. Ginski, R. F. van Capelleveen, N. Fitzgerald, A. Garufi, C. Coyne, C. Lawlor, D. McLachlan Abstract Context. High-resolution imaging in scattered light has revealed complex morphologies in protoplanetary/circumstellar disks. Measuring their vertical height is key to understanding disk structure, evolution, and the properties of embedded dust. Aims. This work aims to develop a robust methodology for fitting elliptical shapes to scattered light images of protoplanetary disks in order to extract vertical height profiles of the dust scattering surface ( τ = 1 \tau=1 ) across a large and morphologically diverse disk sample. The dataset comprises 92 unique near-infrared polarimetric images of individual systems obtained with VLT/SPHERE. The goal is to identify trends in vertical structure across morphologies and test for correlations with stellar mass, age, and disk dust mass. Using the height profiles, this work also investigates the implications of the constrained height for the masses of potential embedded planets. Methods. A structure extraction and ellipse fitting (SEEF) algorithm, is implemented using edge detection and Gaussian fitting to locate the structure within protoplanetary disks. Fitting ellipses to the structure reveals spatial offsets from the centre of the ellipse and the star, interpreted as vertical height assuming circular ring geometry. Disk inclination, position angle (PA), and aspect ratio ( h τ = 1 / r h_{\tau=1}/r ) are also derived. Results. The SEEF algorithm obtained successful vertical height measurements for 92 unique disks, revealing variations in height profiles consistent with flared disk geometries. Analysis of the full sample shows that the vertical height profile cannot be confidently described by a single power-law relation. Subdivision of the sample by disk morphology revealed no strong correlations within most categories, with the exception of extended disks ( r outer ≥ 150 r_{\mathrm{outer}}\geq 150 au), which exhibited a strong correlation with a single power-law trend. Investigation into underlying disk properties revealed no correlation for its affect to the vertical height structure. Conclusions. This work presents a consistent methodology for measuring the vertical structure of circumstellar disks using ellipse fitting on scattered light images. While trends in height structure remain weakly correlated for the full sample and many disk morphologies, extended disks ( r outer ≥ 150 r_{\mathrm{outer}}\geq 150 au) stand out as the only subgroup showing a clear power-law flaring trend. The lack of a strong correlation across other morphologies and with system properties like stellar or dust mass suggests that either differing disk morphologies exhibit different vertical height profiles or that another, unidentified factor is influencing the disk flaring. 1 Introduction Figure 1: Gallery of representative disks from the sample, grouped by morphological geometry. Ellipse fits made in this study to the scattered-light disk structures are overplotted. The scale bar in each panel denotes 1 arcsecond. Circumstellar disks are the birthing grounds of planets. High spatial resolution observations taken in the past decade have revealed complex disk morphologies, such as multi-ringed disks, spirals and gaps, which are evidence of ongoing dynamical processes. Understanding the physical geometry of these disks is essential for constraining the disk evolution and the processes that lead to planet formation. However, it still remains unclear how the current observed planet population relates to the disk properties. In this context, understanding the vertical height structure of the dust is a necessary step toward linking observed disk features to the mechanisms that shape planetary systems. While several studies have measured the dust vertical height in individual disks or small samples ( 15 ; 31 ; 5 ; 51 ; 29 ) , a large-scale analysis is needed to identify broader trends. The first set of imaged protoplanetary disks mostly consisted of Herbig Ae/Be stars ( 33 ; 23 , e.g.,) , which are traditionally divided into two groups: Group I sources, whose spectral energy distributions show strong far-infrared excesses interpreted as flared disks with large inner cavities, and Group II sources, which display weaker far-infrared emission corresponding to flatter disks with small or no inner cavities ( 28 ; 38 , e.g.,) , leading to the long-standing study concerning the presence of a disk cavity and the disk height. Group II disks have been found to be inherently faint in scattered light ( 34 ) , thus any large sample is systematically biased towards their exclusion, making a comparison in scattered light difficult. However, by investigating the dust vertical height structure for different categories of disk morphology it is possible to identify trends that may indicate the presence or absence of a cavity. Further, the disk height may be affected by other properties of the disk. The degree of disk flaring is expected to correlate with the disk’s total mass. The disk becomes more optically thick with an increase in total dust mass, therefore observations of the optically thick scattering layer trace higher layers within the disk. Therefore, a relationship between dust mass and the measured aspect ratio is physically motivated. Over time, the disk’s aspect ratio is expected to decrease as the system evolves. This reflects the physical processes that cause the disk to become geometrically thinner, such as radiative cooling, mass depletion due to accretion or expulsion from the system, and reduced vertical support from a lack of gas pressure, resulting in a smaller dust vertical height relative to radius. If this is correct, the aspect ratio should decline with increasing stellar age. Alternatively, the clearing of the cavity observed in older (transition) disks could enhance the irradiation of the outer disk, heating it more strongly and thereby increasing its flaring. Lastly, the vertical height of the dust may correlate with stellar mass (see Appendix G for dependency derivation), since the classical mass-luminosity relation (MLR) established for main-sequence stars is not expected to hold during the pre–main-sequence phase (e.g., 6 ) characteristic of protoplanetary disks. Further, 20 propose that the MLR for main-sequence stars may be described by L\propto M^{\beta}_{*} with differing values for \beta depending on stellar mass, reflecting transitions in the dominant energy transport mechanism. Therefore, there may be a correlation between vertical height and stellar mass. In this study, we present a large-sample analysis of the vertical height structure of the optically thick dust scattering surface ( \tau=1 ) within 92 protoplanetary disks, comprised of polarimetric near-infrared (NIR) scattered-light observations. This sample represents a substantial fraction of all NIR scattered-light images of protoplanetary disks currently available. This paper is organised as follows. In Sect. 2 details of the dataset used throughout this work are presented. Sect. 3 , outlines the methods used to extract the disk vertical height structure. Finally, Sect. 4 contains the results and discussion of the full dataset, two example individual systems, multi-ringed systems, an investigation into system properties that may affect the dust’s vertical height structure and the calculation of planet masses opening gaps, a use case for the constraint of the dust vertical height structure. 2 Observations Figure 2: The distribution of year and filter within the initial dataset (totalling 294 images), showing a greater tendency towards H-band images. Figure 3: Schematic illustration of the projected geometry of an inclined multi-ringed circumstellar disk (this also holds for continuous disks). When viewed at an inclination angle i ,

Read the complete text