Extending spin-lattice relaxation theory to three-phonon processes
Nilanjana Chanda, Alessandro Lunghi · 2026
Read Extending spin-lattice relaxation theory to three-phonon processes by Nilanjana Chanda, Alessandro Lunghi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-05393.txt.
Introduction
Nilanjana Chanda and Alessandro Lunghi stretch spin relaxation to three-phonon processes, applied to chromium nitride van der Waals crystal. Spin-lattice theory built over almost a century with unverified key interaction assumptions. Weak coupling enables small-step dynamics and one- and two-phonon accounts. Three-phonon contributions only matter at temperatures inaccessible to tests, giving unprecedented weak-coupling validity evidence. Number results show a small coupling lift would make a crossover between three- and two-phonon leanness at room temperature, illustrating possible three-phonon effects and strong-coupling exploration.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nilanjana Chanda, Alessandro Lunghi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37522 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.05393
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Extending spin-lattice relaxation theory to three-phonon processes Nilanjana Chanda, Alessandro Lunghi Abstract Spin-lattice relaxation theory has been developed over almost a century, but some cardinal assumptions on the nature of the interactions involved have never been fully verified. This includes the weak coupling approximation, which makes it possible to describe spin dynamics perturbatively and leads to the canonical description of spin relaxation in terms of one- and two-phonon processes. Here, we extend the first-principles theory of spin relaxation to three-phonon processes and apply it to the vdW crystal of a spin-1/2 Chromium nitride complex. Results show that three-phonon contributions to spin relaxation only become relevant at temperatures inaccessible to experiments for this molecule, thus providing unprecedented evidence for the validity of the weak spin-phonon coupling assumption in spin relaxation theory. At the same time, we numerically show that a relatively small increase in spin-phonon coupling would lead to a crossover between three- and two-phonon processes’ efficiency at room temperature, illustrating the possibility for three-phonon effects in molecular materials as well as paving the way to a systematic exploration of strong coupling in spin systems. Introduction In solids, the process of the energy exchange between an electron spin and the lattice vibrations, or phonons, has been of significant importance for nearly a century, particularly in the study of restoring the thermal equilibrium in magnetic resonance experiments, referred to as the spin-lattice or spin-phonon relaxation. Recently, with the advancement of quantum information science and quantum technologies, a quantitative understanding of spin-phonon relaxation has also become essential across a broad range of magnetic materials and quantum architectures, including molecular nanomagnets 1 , transition metals 39 , rare-earth ions 41 and solid-state qubits, e .g. nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centers in diamond 20 ; 38 , quantum dots 24 , and defects in 2D materials 16 ; 38 . The first theoretical treatment of spin-lattice relaxation in solids was given by Waller in 1932 54 . He performed the first calculation of relaxation times modulating the dipole-dipole interaction by phonons and discussed the processes of transfer of energy by the spin to the lattice by the one-phonon direct processes as well as the two-phonon Raman processes. However, Waller found very long relaxation times at low temperature, which did not agree with the experimental results obtained by Gorter in 1936 18 . Around the same time, Heitler & Teller (1936) 21 and Fierz (1938) 13 considered the modulation of the crystalline electric fields by phonons and showed that modulation of the crystalline fields led to a spin-lattice interaction much stronger than that produced by modulations of the magnetic dipolar interaction. Kronig (1939) 27 and Van Vleck (1939, 1940) 52 ; 53 provided quantitative calculations of the effects of modulation of the crystalline electric field in the iron group alums and obtained quantitative agreement with the experimental results of Gorter (1936) and Teunissen & Dijkstra (1938) in the high-temperature range, but failed to explain many of their results in the liquid helium range. Building on these early results, Orbach later proposed to employ the theory of spin-lattice relaxation in a phenomonological way 41 rather than attempting to make predictions from first principles and eventually led to the canonical picture of spin relaxation as mediated by either the exchange of one resonant phonon (Direct relaxation), multiple one-phonon processes (Orbach relaxation), and simultaneous two-phonon processes (Raman relaxation). In parallel to these early attempts to predict spin-lattice relaxation in solid-state magnetic systems, a general theory of open quantum systems was emerging. In 1946, Bloch proposed a set of phenomenological equations in terms of the magnetization, widely known as the Bloch equations, to explain the relaxation process in the context of nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) 6 . Within this formalism, the establishment of thermal equilibrium is determined by two time constants, namely spin-lattice relaxation time T_{1} and spin-spin relaxation time T_{2} . Motivated by this, Redfield (1957) came up with a microscopic description of the relaxation process and derived an equation of motion for the density operator of the spin system, referred to as a quantum master equation (QME) 44 . The process of relaxation is mathematically represented in the form of a superoperator calculated employing a second-order perturbative treatment on the system-environment interaction of a generic form. As such, Redfield’s theory can be considered the first formal theory in the study of open quantum system dynamics, including coherent processes. Few years later, in 1976, Gorini, Kossakowski, Sudarshan 17 and at the same time, Lindblad 30 independently came up with the most general form for the generator of a quantum dynamical semigroup, known as the GKSL form which defines a Markovian QME. This has been used as a standard result for both microscopic and phenomenological studies in open quantum systems 3 ; 26 ; 48 ; 55 . However, the Born-Markov or weak-coupling approximations may break down in many realistic cases, e.g. when the timescale separation between the system and environment breaks down, for strong system-environment coupling, large initial system-environment correlations, structured or finite reservoirs, low temperatures, etc. 9 . In such cases, more general tools are required. The formally exact description of open quantum systems dynamics is usually studied through two distinct approaches: the time-nonlocal Nakajima-Zwanzig quantum master equations (NZ QMEs) 40 ; 56 ; and the time-convolutionless, or time-local, quantum master equations (TCL QMEs) 47 ; 11 ; 46 , as expressed by \displaystyle\frac{d\hat{\rho}(t)}{dt}=\hat{\hat{R}}(t,t_{0})\hat{\rho}(t)\>. (1) Even without leaving the Markovian regime, QMEs in the TCL formalism can be used to study open quantum systems dynamics through a perturbative expansion of the generator \hat{\hat{R}}(t,t_{0}) with respect to the system-environment coupling. Using this method, the relaxation and decoherence processes in any quantum system, not necessarily weakly coupled to its environment, can be explained. A wide range of validity of this method has been discussed in detail in 7 by means of a damped Jaynes-Cummings model. In particular, the fourth order of the TCL QMEs is shown to be a good approximation to the exact solution for a large range of physically relevant parameters 8 . This perturbative treatment is often applied to spin systems interacting with a bath of harmonic oscillators, termed spin-boson models 28 and thus forming an ideal theoretical basis for discussing spin-phonon relaxation in molecular crystals or other solid-state systems such as defects or impurities. In recent years, a similar approach to TCL, has indeed been used to systematically merge open quantum systems theory and first-principles methods with the aim of completing that process initiated almost 100 years ago by Waller, Kronig and Van Vleck 31 ; 32 ; 33 ; 35 . Such formalism, known as T -matrix formalism, corresponds to a simplification of full TCL QMEs 45 in retaining only terms appearing as a generalized Fermi’s golden rule 10 . Once these QMEs are combined with electronic structure methods, all the coefficients required to implement the former for specific molecules can be specified, thereby ensuring a fully non-parametric treatment of all the relevant interactions, including spin and phonon spectra as well as the spin-phonon coupling coefficients. Both one- and two-phonon processes following second- and fourth-order perturbative treatment are now well-characterized 31 ; 32 ; 33 ; 35 . In this work, we adopt the T -matrix formalism,