Evidence for Vortex Rings with Multiquantum Circulation in He II
Yiming Xing, Yousef Alihosseini, Sosuke Inui, Wei Guo · 2026
Read Evidence for Vortex Rings with Multiquantum Circulation in He II by Yiming Xing, Yousef Alihosseini, Sosuke Inui, Wei Guo (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-05387.txt.
Introduction
Yiming Xing and colleagues uncover rare vortex-bound events in helium-4. Circulation is quantized in kappa units; multi-quantum vortices split, and rings shrink. Deuterium-tracer velocimetry finds events irreconcilable with single rings. Instead, circulation n kappa with n greater than 1 follows. A bundle of closely spaced single rings could generate similar motion, but simulations show rapid dispersion. Persistent trapping at high speeds suggests a deeper core potential, consistent only with multiquantum cores. These results point to multiquantum rings with anomalously long lives.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yiming Xing, Yousef Alihosseini, Sosuke Inui, Wei Guo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 19616 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC0 |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.05387
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Evidence for Vortex Rings with Multiquantum Circulation in He II Yiming Xing, Yousef Alihosseini, Sosuke Inui, Wei Guo Abstract Quantized vortex dynamics in superfluid 4 He (He II) are widely regarded as well established: circulation is quantized in units of κ = h / m 4 \kappa=h/m_{4} , vortices carrying more than one quantum are expected to split into singly quantized filaments, and vortex rings shrink while accelerating due to dissipation from thermal-quasiparticle scattering. Using particle tracking velocimetry with frozen deuterium tracers, we uncover rare vortex-bound particle events that disrupt this canonical picture. In a class of events exhibiting the acceleration characteristic of shrinkage driven vortex ring motion, the measured kinematics cannot be reconciled with a singly quantized ring. Instead, they require an effective circulation n κ n\kappa with n > 1 n>1 , directly challenging the standard expectation that multiquantum vortices are short lived. A more prosaic possibility is that the inferred n κ n\kappa arises from a bundle of closely spaced singly quantized rings, which could generate similar large-scale motion. However, this scenario is disfavored by vortex-filament simulations that show rapid bundle dispersion. Furthermore, the persistence of particle trapping at the observed high speeds suggests a much deeper core trapping potential, consistent only with a truly multiquantum core. Together, these results point to anomalously long-lived multiquantum rings, a striking puzzle that calls for dedicated scrutiny beyond the prevailing paradigm. Quantized vortices govern dynamics and dissipation in a wide range of systems, from atomic Bose–Einstein condensates (BECs) to type-II superconductors, from rotating superfluid neutron stars to topological defects in cosmological settings Tsubota-2013-book ; RevModPhys.66.1125 ; Greenstein-1970-Nature ; pines1985superfluidity ; zurek1985cosmological . Despite this diversity, the same vortex-level mechanisms recur: circulation is quantized, vortices drift and exchange topology via reconnections, and finite-temperature dissipation is mediated by thermal quasiparticles scattering from vortex cores tilley2019superfluidity . A laboratory platform that exposes these mechanisms through quantitative measurements of vortex trajectories can therefore deliver insight with broad reach. Superfluid 4 He (He II) has long been regarded as such a platform. In Landau’s two fluid framework Landau1941PR , an inviscid superfluid component coexists with a viscous normal component composed of thermal quasiparticles. Any superfluid vorticity is confined to quantized vortex lines with a core radius a_{0}\simeq 1 Å and a fixed circulation \kappa=h/m_{4} , where h is Planck’s constant and m_{4} is the mass of a 4 He atom tilley2019superfluidity ; Landau1941PR . This separation of scales, i.e., angstrom core and macroscopic flow field, makes vortex structures in He II exceptionally well defined and amenable to controlled modeling vinen2002quantum . At finite temperature, quasiparticle scattering off vortex cores produces mutual friction vinen1957mutual ; Barenghi1983 , whose established formulation allows quantitative prediction of the vortex motion Schwartz1985 . In parallel, tracer particle visualization has opened a direct window onto vortex dynamics in real space, revealing key features of both individual vortices and vortex tangles Bewley-2006-Nature ; Guo-2014-PNAS ; Mantia-PRB-2014 ; Mastracci-2019-PRF ; Fonda-2019-PNAS ; Tang-2023-NatCommun ; Peretti2023SciAdv ; Minowa2025NatPhys . Together, these advances have created an unusually coherent picture in which quantitative measurements and established theory often align, reinforcing the common view that the essential vortex physics in He II is largely settled for most experimental conditions. In particular, it is widely accepted that stable circulation in He II must be singly quantized. This expectation follows directly from an energetic scaling argument. For instance, for a singly quantized vortex ring of radius R , the kinetic energy of the associated flow field is E\simeq\frac{\rho_{\rm s}\kappa^{2}R}{2}\left[\ln(8R/a_{0})-\frac{3}{2}\right] Donnelly-1991-B . A ring of the same radius but carrying n quanta of circulation therefore has an energy approximately given by n^{2}E . On the other hand, n well separated singly quantized rings have a total energy of nE . The resulting excess energy, (n^{2}-n)E>0 for n>1 , makes multiquantum circulation energetically unfavorable and leads to the standard expectation that it should rapidly split into singly quantized vortices under generic perturbations. Fig. 1: Vortex-bound particle events suggesting multiquantum vortex-ring kinematics. a Schematic of the experimental setup. b,c Superimposed image sequences for two representative events recorded at heater-surface voltages V_{\mathrm{H}}=0 V and +10 V, respectively; red arrows indicate the direction of motion. d,e Measured particle speed v_{p}(t) along the trajectories in b and c . Solid curves show the predicted ring propagation speed v_{\parallel,n}(t) for various circulations n\kappa , with each curve initialized by matching the starting speed v_{p}(0) . Shaded bands represent the resulting spread in v_{\parallel,n}(t) due to the uncertainty in v_{p}(0) . Here we report rare vortex-bound particle events observed in our particle-tracking velocimetry (PTV) experiments using micron-sized frozen deuterium (D 2 ) tracers that force a re-examination of this prevailing picture. The particle trajectories display the rapid acceleration expected for a shrinking vortex ring Donnelly-1991-B . However, quantitative analysis of the measured kinematics rules out a singly quantized ring and instead requires an effective circulation n\kappa , with n in the range 3 to 20. We further disfavor an interpretation in terms of a compact bundle of singly quantized rings, since such bundles disperse rapidly under mutual friction and are incompatible with sustained particle trapping at the observed high speeds. In what follows, we present our observations and discuss the analysis that leads to this intriguing conclusion. The experimental setup is shown in Fig. 1 a. A D 2 / 4 He gas mixture is injected through a stainless steel tube into an experimental cell connected to the He II bath Mastracci-2018-RSI ; Tang-2021-PNAS ; the bath temperature is controlled via vapor-pressure regulation and monitored by a Cernox sensor. Following injection, the D 2 solidifies into ice particles with a mean radius a_{p}\simeq 1.1 \mu m Tang-2023-NatCommun , inferred from their settling velocities in quiescent He II (see Methods). As particles approach vortex cores, they can become trapped by the Bernoulli pressure associated with the circulating superfluid flow Donnelly-1991-B , thereby directly revealing vortex structures. In some runs, a chip-resistor heater (area: 1.6\times 0.5 mm 2 ) in the cell is pulsed on for a few milliseconds to promote vortex generation. We illuminate the tracer particles with a thin laser sheet ( \sim 150 \mu m thickness) and record their motion at 200 Hz with a camera placed perpendicular to the sheet. When a vortex event passes through the laser plane, the coordinates of the trapped particles are extracted using a feature-point tracking algorithm Sbalzarini-2005-JSB , enabling quantitative kinematic analysis. In our experiments, the tracers most often outline relatively smooth vortex filaments that drift slowly through the laser sheet and occasionally undergo reconnections as they cross Stasiak-2025-PNAS . We also observe regular vortex rings decorated by a few tracers propagating through otherwise quiescent He II Tang-2023-NatCommun . Beyond these understood structures, a distinct class of rare events were captured over a broad temperature range, typically involving a single tracer moving through He II at high speed and, most strikingly, accelerating with time (see Supplementary Movie 1 for a collection of example events). Two representative trajectories are shown in Fig. 1 b and 1 c (see also Supplementary Movies 2 and 3), and the corresponding particle speed v_{p}(t) measured along the trajectory direction is shown in Fig. 1 d and 1 e. The rapid growth of