Extensions to the Wealth Tax Neutrality Framework

Anders G Frøseth · 2026

Read Extensions to the Wealth Tax Neutrality Framework by Anders G Frøseth (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-05277.txt.

Introduction

Anders G Frøseth stretches his wealth-tax neutrality method along two dimensions. First, portfolio neutrality survives stochastic volatility and Epstein-Zin utility but breaks under HARA. Second, four channels break neutrality for implemented taxes even under CRRA. They are non-uniform test, inelastic-market price effects, progressive thresholds, and endogenous labour supply. Each channel is formalized, calibrated to the Norwegian tax where possible. The progressive threshold's tax shield lifts risk-taking near the exemption boundary. The method tests Saez-Zucman and French minimum taxes, the latter above EUR 100 million.

Catalog record

CREATORAnders G Frøseth
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE121603
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.05277

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Extensions to the Wealth Tax Neutrality Framework Anders G Frøseth Abstract Froeseth 2026 shows that a proportional wealth tax on market values is neutral with respect to portfolio choice, Sharpe ratios, and equilibrium prices under CRRA preferences and geometric Brownian motion. This paper investigates the robustness of that result along two dimensions. First, we extend the neutrality frontier: portfolio neutrality—including all intertemporal hedging demands—is preserved under stochastic volatility (Heston and general Markov diffusions) and Epstein–Zin recursive utility, but breaks under non-homothetic preferences such as HARA. Second, we identify four channels through which implemented wealth taxes depart from neutrality even under CRRA: non-uniform assessment across asset classes, general equilibrium price effects in inelastic markets, progressive threshold structures, and endogenous labour supply. Each channel is formalised and, where possible, calibrated to the Norwegian wealth tax system. The progressive threshold introduces a tax shield that increases risk-taking near the exemption boundary—an effect opposite in sign to the HARA distortion—and, at the extreme, generates a participation margin at which investors exit the tax jurisdiction entirely. We formalise this tax-induced migration as the extreme response at the progressive threshold and examine the Norwegian post-2022 experience as a case study. The full framework is applied to evaluate the Saez–Zucman proposal for a global minimum wealth tax on billionaires and the related French proposal for a national minimum tax above €100 million. JEL Classification: G11, G12, H21, H24, H26, H73. Keywords: Wealth tax, portfolio choice, tax neutrality, stochastic volatility, HARA preferences, progressive taxation, inelastic markets, tax-induced migration, Saez–Zucman proposal, Norway. 1 Introduction This paper builds on the wealth tax neutrality framework developed in Froeseth 2026 , which established that a proportional wealth tax on market values is neutral with respect to portfolio choice, Sharpe ratios, and equilibrium prices. That analysis proceeds under geometric Brownian motion and then extends to the location-scale family of return distributions. Here we investigate whether the neutrality results survive under more general conditions, and systematically identify the channels through which real-world wealth taxes depart from neutrality. The paper has three parts. The first (Sections 2 – 3 ) extends the neutrality frontier: we show that portfolio neutrality survives under stochastic volatility, general Markov diffusion dynamics, and Epstein–Zin recursive utility, while it breaks under non-homothetic preferences such as HARA utility. The second (Sections 4 – 7 ) analyses the channels through which implemented wealth taxes depart from neutrality, even when investors have CRRA preferences: non-uniform assessment across asset classes, general equilibrium price effects in inelastic markets, progressive threshold structures, and endogenous labour supply. The third part applies and extends the framework. Section 8 synthesises all channels to evaluate two recent proposals: the Saez–Zucman global minimum wealth tax on billionaires and the French national minimum tax above €100 million. Section 9 formalises tax-induced migration as the extreme participation response at the progressive threshold, using the Norwegian post-2022 experience as a case study. Section 2 considers stochastic volatility models, where the variance of returns is itself a random process. Using the Heston model as the leading example, we show that portfolio neutrality—including the intertemporal hedging demand identified by Merton 1973 —is preserved under CRRA preferences. The result generalises to any Markov diffusion model of asset returns. Section 3 identifies CRRA as the operative condition: non-homothetic preferences (HARA, wealth-in-utility) break neutrality, while Epstein–Zin preferences preserve it. Section 4 derives the portfolio distortion from asset-class-specific assessment discounts, calibrated to the Norwegian system. Section 5 analyses general equilibrium price effects through the inelastic markets hypothesis. Section 6 formalises the distortion from progressive taxation (thresholds and brackets), and Section 7 extends the framework to endogenous labour supply and entrepreneurial effort. Section 8 synthesises all channels in a comparative evaluation of the Saez–Zucman global proposal and the French national variant. Section 9 formalises tax-induced migration as the extreme participation response at the progressive threshold and examines the Norwegian post-2022 experience as a case study. Table 1 provides an overview of the main results. Section Result Proposition Sign Part I: Neutrality frontier 2 Stochastic volatility (Heston, Markov) 1 , 2 Neutral 3 Epstein–Zin recursive utility 4 Neutral 3 HARA (non-homothetic) preferences 3 \Delta w^{*}<0 Part II: Non-neutrality channels 4 Non-uniform assessment 5 Asset-dependent 5 Inelastic markets (GE price impact) — \Delta P/P<0 6 Progressive threshold (tax shield) 6 \Delta w^{*}>0 7 Endogenous labour supply 7 Separable † Part III: Applications and extensions 8 Zucman/French proposals — Synthesis 9 Tax-induced migration — Exit at W_{i}^{*} † Separable under proportional taxation; distorted at progressive thresholds. Table 1: Summary of main results. “Sign” indicates the direction of the portfolio or price distortion relative to the no-tax benchmark under CRRA preferences. 2 Stochastic Volatility The neutrality results in Froeseth 2026 are derived first under geometric Brownian motion (constant \mu , \sigma ) and then generalised to the location-scale family of return distributions. A natural question is whether the results extend to stochastic volatility models, where the variance of returns is itself a random process. This is empirically important: asset returns exhibit time-varying volatility, fat tails, and leverage effects that are absent under GBM ( Heston 1993 ; Drăgulescu and Yakovenko 2002 ) . We show that, under CRRA preferences, portfolio neutrality extends to the Heston stochastic volatility model—and, more generally, to any Markov diffusion model of asset returns— without requiring the location-scale property. The mechanism is different from the location-scale argument: it relies on the homogeneity of the CRRA value function in wealth, which makes optimal portfolio weights (including the intertemporal hedging demand identified by Merton 1973 ) independent of the wealth level. 2.1 The Heston model The Heston model specifies the price of a single risky asset and its instantaneous variance as a pair of coupled diffusions: \displaystyle\frac{dS}{S} \displaystyle=\mu\,dt+\sqrt{v_{t}}\,dW_{t}^{(1)}, (1) \displaystyle dv_{t} \displaystyle=\lambda(\theta-v_{t})\,dt+\kappa\sqrt{v_{t}}\,dW_{t}^{(2)}, (2) where v_{t}=\sigma_{t}^{2} is the instantaneous variance, \theta>0 is the long-run mean variance, \lambda>0 is the rate of mean reversion, \kappa>0 is the volatility of variance, and \mathrm{corr}(dW^{(1)},dW^{(2)})=\rho . When \rho<0 , negative returns coincide with rising volatility—the leverage effect. The Feller condition 2\lambda\theta\geq\kappa^{2} ensures the variance remains strictly positive. Remark (Heston returns and the location-scale family) . Drăgulescu and Yakovenko 2002 derive the probability density of log-returns under the Heston model in closed form and show that it involves a modified Bessel function K_{1} of a scaled argument. The distribution exhibits exponential (rather than Gaussian) tails for large returns, and asymmetry when \rho\neq 0 . These features place Heston returns outside the location-scale family. The generalised Propositions 2 ′ and 3 ′ in Froeseth 2026 , which require the location-scale property, therefore do not apply directly. 2.2 Wealth dynamics with a wealth tax An investor allocates a fraction w of wealth to the risky asset and the remainder 1-w to a risk-free asset earning a continuous rate r_{f} . Following the continuous-time formulation in Froeseth 2026 , the proportional wealth tax \tau_{w} enters as an additional drain on the drift of wealth. The investor’s wealth evolves as dW=\bigl\{W[r_{f}+w(\mu-r_{f})-\tau_{w}]-C\bigr\}\,dt+wW\sqrt{v_{t}}\,dW_{t}^{(1)}, (3) where C\geq 0 is the consumption flow rate. As in the GBM case, the tax reduces the drift of wealth by \tau_{w}W but leaves the diffusion coefficient—and hence the per-share return dS/S —unchanged. The variance state variable v_{t} evolves according to ( 2 ), independently of the tax. 2.3 The Merton problem

Read the complete text