Ultralimits of Sobolev maps and stability of Dehn functions
Toni Ikonen, Stefan Wenger · 2026
Read Ultralimits of Sobolev maps and stability of Dehn functions by Toni Ikonen, Stefan Wenger (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-05246.txt.
Introduction
Toni Ikonen and Stefan Wenger extend the ultralimit of bounded Lipschitz-map sequences in pointed metric spaces to p-bounded Sobolev-map sequences, preserving its desirable properties. They use this to prove Dehn-function stability under ultraconvergence of pointed length spaces, resolving a problem posed by several researchers. As an application, they give a simpler proof of a recent Stadler-Wenger result characterizing spaces of curvature bounded above through an isoperimetric inequality for curves.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Toni Ikonen, Stefan Wenger |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 90196 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.05246
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Ultralimits of Sobolev maps and stability of Dehn functions Thanks: Both authors were supported by Swiss National Science Foundation grant 212867. T.I. was also supported by the Research Council of Finland, project number 332671. Toni Ikonen, Stefan Wenger Abstract . We show that the ultralimit of a bounded sequence of Lipschitz maps into pointed metric spaces extends naturally to p p -bounded sequences of Sobolev maps and that this ultralimit for Sobolev maps enjoys desirable properties. We use this to prove the stability of Dehn functions under ultraconvergence of pointed length spaces, thus resolving a problem posed by several researchers in the field. As an application, we obtain a simpler proof of a recent result of Stadler–Wenger, previously proved in the locally compact case by Lytchak–Wenger, characterizing spaces of curvature bounded above by κ \kappa via an isoperimetric inequality for curves. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 53C23; Secondary 46E35,46E36,49Q05 1. Introduction and main results 1.1. Background Limits of metric spaces and mappings are important in many areas of geometry and analysis. In the case of spaces, the (pointed) Gromov–Hausdorff convergence, introduced by Gromov in [ Gro81 ] , has wide applicability for example in geometric group theory, in the theory of Ricci limit spaces, in the theory of synthetic curvature lower bounds, in Riemannian/subRiemannian and metric geometry and in geometric analysis [ Pan83 , Pet90 , GPW90 , CC97 , CC00a , CC00b , Stu06a , Stu06b , Gro07 , Wen08 , LV09 , BNS22 , Bat22 , BPS25 ] . However, the required assumptions often do not hold in the generality necessary for applications in geometric group theory, for spaces with curvature bounded above in the sense of Alexandrov, and for diameter-volume bounded sequences of closed Riemannian manifolds. A more flexible notion of convergence is given by the ultralimit X_{\omega} of a sequence of pointed metric spaces X_{m}=(X_{m},d_{m},p_{m}) with respect to some non-principal ultrafilter \omega on \mathbb{N} . This notion, first introduced by van den Dries and Wilkie [ vdDW84 ] , has played a key role in geometric group theory and the theory of curvature upper bounds, in particular, in the study of asymptotic cones of groups and spaces [ Gro93 , KL95 , KL97 , KKL98 , Dru02 , KSTT05 , DS05 ] . We refer to Section 2.4 for the definitions of ultralimits. Similar flexibility is desirable in the context of mappings \varphi_{m}\colon(X_{m},d_{m},p_{m})\to(Y_{m},d_{m},q_{m}) . This is achieved as follows in the Lipschitz setting. We say that (\varphi_{m}) is Lipschitz bounded if (1.1) \sup_{m\in\mathbb{N}}\left(d_{m}(q_{m},\varphi_{m}(p_{m}))+\LIP(\varphi_{m})\right)<\infty, where \LIP(\varphi) is the Lipschitz constant. Any such sequence has a pointwise ultralimit \displaystyle\varphi_{\omega}\colon X_{\omega}\to Y_{\omega},\quad\text{where $\varphi_{\omega}(\lim\nolimits_{\omega}x_{m})=\lim\nolimits_{\omega}\varphi_{m}(x_{m})$,} which is again Lipschitz; see Section 2.5 . This flexibility is already useful in the case of a constant sequence X_{m}=X in which case we obtain a pointwise ultralimit X\to Y_{\omega} by precomposing \varphi_{\omega} with the canonical isometric embedding of X into the ultracompletion X_{\omega} . In many problems in calculus of variations and geometric group theory, Lipschitz maps form too rigid of a class. Therefore it is desirable to extend the ultralimit construction to more general classes of mappings such as Sobolev maps. In fact, there exists a robust metric valued Sobolev theory on Euclidean domains or more general metric spaces; see e.g. [ KS93 , Haj96 , Res97 , HKST01 , HKST15 ] . These have become prominent in various fields including analysis in metric spaces, metric geometry, and geometric group theory [ GS92 , Jos94 , SW01 , DMV11 , LW17a , LW17b , Raj17 , LW18a , LW18b , LW20 , DM21 , NR22 , NR23 , MW25 ] . We focus on W^{1,p} -Sobolev maps (u_{m}\colon\Omega\to X_{m}) , where \Omega\subset\mathbb{R}^{n} is a bounded Lipschitz domain, p\in(1,\infty) , and (X_{m}) is a sequence of complete pointed metric spaces. We say that a sequence of W^{1,p} -Sobolev maps (u_{m}\colon\Omega\to X_{m}) is p -bounded if (1.2) \sup_{m\in\mathbb{N}}\left(\int_{\Omega}d^{p}_{m}(p_{m},u_{m}(z))\,dz+E_{+}^{p}(u_{m})\right)<\infty, where E_{+}^{p}(u) is the energy of u ; we refer to Section 3 for definitions and notation related to Sobolev maps. In the present manuscript, we construct an ultralimit for every p -bounded sequence. We show that it has many natural properties and use it to establish a stability property for the Dehn function under ultralimits. Roughly speaking, Dehn functions measure how difficult it is to fill in closed Lipschitz curves of a given length by discs. They are closely related to the isoperimetric inequality of the ambient space and they have been widely studied in many different settings; see e.g. [ Res68 , Gro93 , GHR03 , You13 , LW18b , Sta21 , SW25 ] . The question on the stability of Dehn functions has only been addressed in special cases in [ Wen11b , Wen19 , LWY20 , SW25 ] . We also provide further applications. 1.2. Ultralimits of Sobolev maps Our first theorem shows that we can extend the ultralimit construction to the Sobolev setting. For the statement, let \Omega\subset\mathbb{R}^{n} be a bounded Lipschitz domain and p\in(1,\infty) . Let \omega be a non-principal ultrafilter on \mathbb{N} . Theorem 1.1 . There is a unique map sending a p -bounded sequence (u_{m}\colon\Omega\to X_{m}) to a Sobolev map u_{\omega}\in W^{1,p}(\Omega,X_{\omega}) with the following properties: (1) If the sequence (u_{m}) is Lipschitz bounded, then u_{\omega} agrees with the pointwise ultralimit of (u_{m}) almost everywhere. (2) If (\phi_{m}\colon X_{m}\to Y_{m}) is Lipschitz bounded and \phi_{\omega}\colon X_{\omega}\to Y_{\omega} the pointwise ultralimit, then the sequence (v_{m}=\phi_{m}\circ u_{m}) is p -bounded and v_{\omega}=\phi_{\omega}\circ u_{\omega} almost everywhere. (3) We have \|d_{\omega}(u_{\omega},v_{\omega})\|_{L^{p}(\Omega)}=\lim\nolimits_{\omega}\|d_{m}(u_{m},v_{m})\|_{L^{p}(\Omega)} for p -bounded (u_{m}\colon\Omega\to X_{m}) and (v_{m}\colon\Omega\to X_{m}) . Uniqueness in Theorem 1.1 is understood in the sense that if another assignment (u_{m})\mapsto\widetilde{u}_{\omega} satisfies axioms ( 1 )-( 3 ), then u_{\omega}=\widetilde{u}_{\omega} almost everywhere for every p -bounded (u_{m}) . This allows us to talk about the ultralimit (with respect to \omega ) , which moreover has the following desirable properties for calculus of variations. Theorem 1.2 . The ultralimit from Theorem 1.1 satisfies the following properties. (4) For every p -bounded (u_{m}) and every lower semicontinuous energy, it holds that \lim\nolimits_{\omega}E^{p}(u_{m})\geq E^{p}(u_{\omega}). (5) For every p -bounded (u_{m}) with p\geq n and every lower semi-continuous volume \lim\nolimits_{\omega}\mathrm{Vol}(u_{m})\geq\mathrm{Vol}(u_{\omega}). (6) The traces of p -bounded sequences (u_{m}\colon\Omega\to X_{m}),(v_{m}\colon\Omega\to X_{m}) satisfy \displaystyle\|d_{\omega}(\trace(u_{\omega}),\trace(v_{\omega}))\|_{L^{p}(\partial\Omega)}=\lim\nolimits_{\omega}\|d_{m}(\trace(u_{m}),\trace(v_{m}))\|_{L^{p}(\partial\Omega)}. (7) If the traces \trace(u_{m})\colon\partial\Omega\to X_{m} have continuous representatives (\gamma_{m}) that are equi-continuous and equi-bounded, then the pointwise ultralimit \gamma_{\omega} is a continuous representative of the trace of u_{\omega} . In the paper [ GW20 ] , Guo and the second author were able to define an ultralimit of a suitable subsequence of a given p -bounded sequence. Passing to a subsequence, however, often poses a problem, since the resulting map takes values in the ultralimit of the subsequence of spaces instead of the ultralimit of the full sequence of spaces. Our main interest in the ultralimit construction arises from the stability of Dehn functions under ultralimits. 1.3. Stability of Dehn functions In order to state our stability results, we define the Sobolev filling area of a Lipschitz curve \gamma\colon\mathbb{S}^{1}\to X by \displaystyle\mathrm{FillArea}_{X}(\gamma)\coloneqq\inf\{\mathrm{Area}(v)\colon v\in W^{1,2}(\mathbb{D},X),\,\trace(v)=\gamma\}, where \mathbb{D}\subset\mathbb{R}^{2} is the Euclidean unit disk and \mathbb{S}^{1} its boundary. See Section 3.5 for the definition of parametrized Hausdorff area \mathrm{Area}(v) . Here we simply mention that if v is injective and Lipschitz, then \mathrm{Area}(v)