Comparing First Ionisation Potential bias diagnostics in the solar atmosphere
K. D. Spruksta 1, D. M. Long 1,2, A. S. H. To 3 · 2026
Read Comparing First Ionisation Potential bias diagnostics in the solar atmosphere by K. D. Spruksta 1, D. M. Long 1,2, A. S. H. To 3 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-05223.txt.
Introduction
Kristena Spruksta and colleagues compare three FIP bias diagnostics in the atmosphere observed by Hinode/EIS. Photosphere-corona differences produce the FIP effect, a ratio of low to high ionization-potential elements. Values run near 1 for coronal holes, 1.5 to 2 for quiet Sun, 3 for active regions. They compare Fe XVI/S XIII, Ca XIV/Ar XIV, and Si X/S X between quiet Sun and an active region across SNR cutoffs. Higher cutoffs remove high-bias tails while the median stays largely unchanged, favoring nuance in the diagnostic.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | K. D. Spruksta 1, D. M. Long 1,2, A. S. H. To 3 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 31083 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.05223
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Comparing First Ionisation Potential bias diagnostics in the solar atmosphere K. D. Spruksta 1, D. M. Long 1,2, A. S. H. To 3 Abstract Plasma composition in the solar atmosphere differs between the photosphere and corona, producing an observable difference in elemental abundance known as the FIP effect. The FIP effect is characterised by the ratio of low to high FIP elements, giving a number known as the FIP bias. FIP bias values vary between different regions of the solar atmosphere, with typical observed values of ∼ \sim 1 for coronal holes, ∼ \sim 1.5-2 for the quiet Sun, and ∼ \sim 3 for active regions. The Extreme ultraviolet Imaging Spectrometer (EIS) onboard the Hinode spacecraft has enabled the widespread use of the Si X/S X line pair as a FIP bias diagnostic, but EIS observes other line pairs that can be used to estimate FIP bias. We consider three FIP bias diagnostics observed by Hinode /EIS (Si X/S X, Ca XIV/Ar XIV, and Fe XVI/S XIII), comparing the FIP bias between Quiet Sun and an Active region. We also assume a range of signal-to-noise (SNR) cutoff values for each pixel, finding that while the SNR cutoff affects the number of useable pixels, higher (lower) SNR cutoffs remove (retain) a tail of high FIP bias values within the measured distribution. However, the median value of the FIP bias distribution remains largely unchanged. These results show the importance of a more nuanced view of FIP bias when using this vitally important diagnostic rather than a simplistic one-size-fits-all approach. \titlehead Research \subject astrophysics, solar physics \corres David Long keywords Elemental Composition, Solar Coronal Dynamics, Solar Activity 1 Introduction Analysis of spectroscopic observations of the solar atmosphere have revealed a distinct and measureable difference in elemental abundance between the solar photosphere and corona. This difference is particularly identifiable between the abundances of elements of high ( \geq 10 eV) and low ( < 10 eV) first ionisation potential (FIP), and is commonly referred to as the FIP bias [ 1 , 27 ] . Once imprinted in a given region of the solar atmosphere the FIP bias generally remains conserved, although processes such as plasma mixing or gravitational settling can cause changes in plasma composition. Overall, this general conservation makes FIP bias a very useful diagnostic for identifying the origin of e.g., solar wind plasma [ 49 ] , and has enabled the connection science promulgated by the ESA/NASA Solar Orbiter spacecraft [ 29 ] . The process by which plasma is fractionated in the solar atmosphere remains the subject of intense research, with the leading theory suggesting that waves in coronal loops induce a ponderomotive force at the loop footpoints in the interface region between the solar photosphere and corona. This ponderomotive force then acts on ions that are largely low-FIP, transporting them upward into the corona and leaving the largely neutral high-FIP elements behind, thus producing the observed FIP bias [ 25 , cf.] . Previous observations have identified signatures in the photosphere of the waves predicted to induce a ponderomotive associated with coronal signatures of enhanced FIP bias [ 39 , 31 , 6 , 30 , e.g.,] . However, although there have been some indications of chromospheric and transition region signatures of related processes [ 26 , 40 , cf.] , no direct observations have yet been made of the fractionation process. Previous work, particularly using the spatially resolved observations provided by the Extreme ultraviolet Imaging Spectrometer [ 10 , EIS;] onboard the Hinode spacecraft [ 24 ] has shown that different regions of the solar atmosphere have different FIP bias, with some correlation found between increasing magnetic field strength and FIP bias [ 8 , 5 , 3 , 28 , 43 ] . This is also consistent with historical observations using spectroheliograms from Skylab [ 20 ] . The FIP bias of the solar atmosphere is therefore a powerful plasma diagnostic that has been identified as a possible tracer of plasma evolution through the solar atmosphere [ 25 ] . As a result, the Solar Orbiter spacecraft has been designed to include two instruments that can measure FIP bias using remote-sensing (the SPectral Imaging of the Coronal Environment, SPICE, spectrometer [ 38 ] ), and in-situ (the Solar Wind Analyser, SWA, particle detector [ 33 ] ) measurements. However, although all of these instruments measure FIP bias using a combination of high- and low-FIP elements, the combinations of elements are different in each case, sensitive to different temperatures and ionisation fraction in the chromosphere. Previous work has also tended to assume single values for FIP bias measurements of different regions of the solar atmosphere. The cores of active regions are widely assumed to have FIP bias values of \sim 3 [ 14 ] , while the quiet Sun has a typical FIP bias of \sim 1.5-2 [ 23 , 3 ] Ensuring that the widely used FIP bias diagnostics behave in a manner consistent with their temperature sensitivities in different regions of the solar atmosphere [ 8 , 5 , 3 , 28 , 43 ] , and provide interpretable FIP bias values of those different regions, is therefore vital for our understanding of this increasingly important parameter. Here we compare three commonly used FIP bias diagnostics from the Hinode /EIS instrument, namely the Si X/S X, Fe XVI/S XIII, and Ca XIV/Ar XIV line ratios, focussing on how they behave in distinct regions of the solar atmosphere. Using a full-disk mosaic taken between 18-20 October 2015, we identified a region of Quiet Sun and an Active region and compared the distribution of FIP bias values in those regions for each diagnostic studied. The observations and data are presented in Section 2 , with the results outlined in Section 3 , before some conclusions are drawn in Section 4 . 2 Observations Figure 1: Full disk mosaics taken from 18-20 Oct 2015 by Hinode /EIS showing the fitted peak intensity (panel a), Doppler velocity (panel b), and line width (panel c) of the Fe XII 195.119 Å emission line. The red (blue) box shows the Quiet Sun (active region) region of interest further examined in Section 3 . The set of raster scans comprising the full disk observations described here were taken by the Extreme ultraviolet Imaging Spectrometer [ 10 , EIS;] onboard the Hinode spacecraft [ 24 ] from 18-20 October 2015. Hinode /EIS regularly takes full-disk mosaic scans of the solar corona across a range of Extreme UltraViolet (EUV) lines, enabling multiple research opportunities including a comparison to be made between active regions of different ages [ 28 , cf.] , and the first full disk FIP maps [ 8 ] . Figure 1 shows the peak fitted intensity (left panel), Doppler velocity (middle panel) and nonthermal velocity (right panel) of the Fe XII 195.119 Å emission line for this full disk raster mosaic. It is clear from Figure 1 that the solar disk at the time included a number of active regions and a large region of quiet Sun, enabling a direct comparison to be made between the different FIP bias diagnostics measured here in these different regions. The full-disk mosaics used here were