On the fair abatement of riparian pollution
Ricardo Martínez Juan D. Moreno-Ternero · 2026
Read On the fair abatement of riparian pollution by Ricardo Martínez Juan D. Moreno-Ternero (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-04345.txt.
Introduction
Martinez and Moreno-Ternero share river cleanup fairly among agents along a river. Claims rest on population, past emissions, and business as usual output, split from a budget below total claims. Upstream emissions harm more than downstream ones, so location must shape the split. Geometric rules adjust proportional shares to balance fairness with environmental harm. The class rivals a recent Yang proposal, compared by axioms and by a Tuojiang Basin case in China.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ricardo Martínez Juan D. Moreno-Ternero |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 63247 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.04345
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the fair abatement of riparian pollution Thanks: We thank Erik Ansink and Jens Gudmundsson for helpful comments and suggestions. Financial support from grants PID2023-147391NB-I00 and PID2023-146364NB-I00, funded by MCIU/AEI/10.13039/501100011033 and FSE+, is gratefully acknowledged. Ricardo Martínez Juan D. Moreno-Ternero Abstract We study the design of fair allocation rules for the abatement of riparian pollution. To do so, we consider the so-called river pollution claims model, recently introduced by 38 to distribute a budget of emissions permits among agents (cities, provinces, or countries) located along a river. In such a model, each agent has a claim reflecting population, emission history, and business-as-usual emissions, and the issue is to allocate among them a budget that is lower (or equal) than the aggregate claim. For environmental reasons, the specific location along the river where pollutants are emitted is an important concern (the more upstream the location is the higher the damage of polluting the river). We characterize a class of geometric rules that adjust proportional allocations to compromise between fairness and environmental concerns. Our class is an alternative to the one proposed by 38 . We compare both alternatives through an axiomatic study, as well as an illustration for the case study of the Tuojiang Basin in China. JEL numbers : D23, D63, Q25. Keywords : river pollution, allocation rules, fairness, environmental concerns, axioms. 1 Introduction Water pollution is becoming a serious environmental problem worldwide, for which effective control measures are urgent ( 9 ; 37 , e.g.,) . The US Environmental Protection Agency launched in 2024 regulations for effluent limitations guidelines and standards for the steam electric power generating category, aimed at reducing pollutants discharged through wastewater from coal-fired power plants by approximately 660 million to 672 million pounds per year. 1 1 1 https://www.epa.gov/eg/steam-electric-power-generating-effluent-guidelines-2024-final-rule . This was nevertheless partially reversed a year later: https://www.epa.gov/eg/steam-electric-power-generating-effluent-guidelines-deadline-extensions-rule . Around the same time, the EU strengthened treatment rules for more thorough and cost-effective urban wastewater management. 2 2 2 https://environment.ec.europa.eu/news/new-rules-urban-wastewater-management-set-enter-force-2024-12-20_en In China, where water pollution has become a more serious environmental problem than water scarcity ( 22 , e.g.,) , the Water Pollution Prevention and Control Law was last amended in 2017. 3 3 3 https://english.mee.gov.cn/Resources/laws/environmental_laws/202012/t20201211_812662.shtml . As our theoretical analysis will partially be motivated by a case study for the Tuojiang Basin in China, it seems relevant to provide some context about current policies in China. That is why we bring some excerpts of this law to Appendix B. In this paper, we are concerned with the abatement of riparian pollution. As many rivers flow through different provinces, regions, and even countries, a goal is to formalize allocation rules (for the distribution of water pollution among them) that are based on solid normative grounds and determine the amount each agent is allowed to pollute. 4 is the seminal contribution to analyze the allocation of water that flows along a river among the agents located therein. 4 4 4 See also 35 ; 8 ; 15 ; 28 and 36 , among others. 5 ; 6 extend this stylized model to account for agents’ claims on the river water too. See also 13 . 27 studied the somewhat dual problem of cleaning a polluted river, in which the input is the cost associated with each agent located along the river. 5 5 5 See also 12 and 2 ; 3 among others. Now, more recently, 38 have introduced another stylized model to analyze the problem of distributing a budget of pollution permits among agents located along a river, which will be our focus in this paper. This river pollution claims problem extends the so-called claims problem to the case where claimants are located along a line, from upstream to downstream, reflecting the direction of river flow. 6 6 6 The claims problem, first formalized by 29 , refers to one of the oldest problems in the history of economic thought. 33 is an excellent survey of the sizable related literature. Note that the specific location along the river where pollutants are emitted is an important concern, as the higher the location upstream, the greater the damage caused by polluting the river. 38 characterize a family of allocation rules for river pollution claims problems (dubbed externality-adjusted proportional rules ) that convey a balance between fairness and environmental concerns. More precisely, the family ranges from the proportional rule, which assigns each agent a proportional amount of the budget to the agent’s claim, thus ignoring agents’ locations along the river, to the full transfer rule, which assigns the whole budget to the most downstream agent, thus ignoring agents’ claims. The family of rules is actually defined via averaging between these two extreme rules. The higher the weight for the proportional rule (in the averaging process), the greater the concern for fairness of the resulting rule. The higher the weight for the full transfer rule (in the averaging process), the higher the environmental concern of the resulting rule. In this paper, we provide a different family of allocation rules that also offer compromises between fairness and environmental concerns. In our case, this compromise is obtained by imposing concatenated transfers of residual claims downstream. More precisely, we assume that the most upstream agent retains a portion ( \gamma\in[0,1] ) of its proportional right to the bundle. The residual amount (from this agent’s claim) is transferred down to the immediate successor along the river (the second most upstream agent). This agent then increases its claim, adding this transfer to its original claim, and retains the same portion ( \gamma\in[0,1] ) of its (subsequently augmented) proportional right to the bundle. The process continues downstream, bubbling down claims until the most downstream agent gets the residual from the budget. 7 7 7 This process is inspired by the bubbling up transfer rules for revenue sharing in hierarchies introduced by 17 . See also 20 and 14 . When the portion is null ( \gamma=0 ), we obtain the full transfer rule. When the portion is full ( \gamma=1 ), we obtain the proportional rule. When the portion is between those values ( \gamma\in(0,1) ) we obtain rules that compromise among the extreme rules in a systematically different way than the family of externality-adjusted proportional rules introduced by 38 . The parameter describing the family ( \gamma ) does not represent some abstract compromise, but the actual transfer of some share of pollution quota to the next downstream agent. For each country/region, the parameter \gamma\in[0,1] would signal how much it would gain from upstream and how much it would have to give up to benefit downstream. We characterize the family of geometric rules described above combining several axioms, which are all formally introduced (as well as properly discussed) later in the text. We also characterize the (more general) family of rules arising from the resulting set of axioms after dismissing one of them. Going in the opposite direction, we characterize the two extreme (and somewhat polar) members of the family (the proportional and full-transfer rules) adding two extra axioms, respectively. We also provide an illustration of how our rules work for a case study of the Tuojiang Basin in China. This, together with the axiomatic study, allows us to properly compare our family