State-dependent marginal emission factors with autoregressive components

Antonio Panico, Andrew Burlinson, Luigi Grossi · 2026

Read State-dependent marginal emission factors with autoregressive components by Antonio Panico, Andrew Burlinson, Luigi Grossi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-04260.txt.

Introduction

Panico and colleagues ask how much carbon each extra unit of electricity truly avoids. Using hourly United States data from 2019 through 2025, they fit switching models in which the marginal source flips between gas and coal. Linear models overstate abatement, they find, by hiding that gas coal split. After a May 2022 break in gas pricing, the coal regime lasts less long yet swings more wildly, so policy should track grid state, not yearly averages.

Catalog record

CREATORAntonio Panico, Andrew Burlinson, Luigi Grossi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE65493
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.04260

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

State-dependent marginal emission factors with autoregressive components Antonio Panico, Andrew Burlinson, Luigi Grossi Abstract Accurate estimation of Marginal Emission Factors (MEFs) is critical for evaluating the decarbonization potential of low-carbon technologies and demand-side management. However, canonical methodologies, predominantly relying on linear regression and differencing techniques, fail to capture the structural non-linearities inherent in the merit order, i.e. the marginal technology setting electricity prices. Utilizing Markov switching autoregressive models with exogenous regressors (MS-ARX) and hourly US data (2019–2025), we identify distinct, mutually exclusive regimes governed by fuel-price dynamics. We find that linear models overestimate abatement potential by masking the dichotomy between a gas-driven and coal-driven marginal system. Furthermore, using robust structural break detection, we link regime instability to a specific structural shift in natural gas pricing in May 2022. Our results indicate that post-2022, the grid has transitioned into a correction phase where the coal-driven regime is less persistent but highly volatile, necessitating state-dependent policy metrics rather than static annual averages. Keywords: climate policy, electricity, emissions, regime-switching models, structural break JEL codes: C22, C51, Q41, Q53 1 Introduction The United States (U.S.) officially withdrew from the Paris Agreement on January 27, 2026. Marking the second time the nation exited the landmark climate pact under a Trump administration, reaffirming its intent to renege on international legal obligations – including the pledge to halve greenhouse gas emissions by 2030 ( 35 ). Despite the 34 arguing that achieving 100 \% clean electricity by 2035 could reduce energy-related emissions by 2.4 gigatons, the path toward deep decarbonization faces renewed uncertainty. Furthermore, established methods overlook inherent non-linearities in the displacement of fossil-fuels at the margin. This is problematic as recent executive orders actively target the revitalization of coal-based power. Our study addresses this critical gap in the literature by providing a robust econometric framework to capture these evolving marginal dynamics. Policy evaluation often relies on fixed average emission factors (AEF), such as those produced by the 37 . Yet, it has become clear that this approach leads to significant (downward) bias, as renewable generation displaces the marginal generator rather than the average fuel mix. Accurate estimation of Marginal Emission Factors (MEFs) is therefore essential for evaluating the decarbonization potential of renewable energy, electric vehicles, and demand-side management ( 14 ). Indeed, 21 highlighted this tension clearly by showing how MEFs were on the rise in the U.S. despite falling average emissions at least in the short-run. While 12 note the importance of structural change in long-run planning, short-run MEFs remain indispensable for context-dependent near-term operational policies and real-world behavioral responses ( 23 ). The literature has developed several statistical approaches to estimate MEFs. 22 pioneered a linear regression approach using U.S. data, regressing emissions on generation while controlling for temporal and regional fixed effects. This methodology was widely adopted, most notably by 7 , 20 , and 21 . In contrast, 19 utilized differencing to represent inter-temporal changes, and 4 utilized time series methods to model autocorrelation in the data-generating process. Although informative, these approaches share a common limitation: they assume a stable, linear relationship between generation and emissions. Moreover, linear techniques estimate an average marginal effect. We argue that this fails to capture the inherent non-linearities in merit-order dispatch, where the marginal fossil fuel shifts between “clean” (e.g., natural gas) and “dirty” (e.g., coal) technologies depending on system load and prices. We address this gap in the literature by utilizing Markov switching autoregressive models with exogenous regressors (MS-ARX) 1 1 1 Throughout this work, MS-ARX and MSM are used interchangeably to refer to the same model. and hourly data for the lower 48 United States (US48). Our work complements relevant literature in which Markov-switching models (MSMs) have been applied in order to model power price forecasts ( 28 and 25 ) and wholesale price formation ( 39 ). More recently, 20 used MSMs to identify structural breaks in the emissions-gas price relationship following the fracking boom. More closely related to our study is that of 6 who suggest that regime-switching frameworks outperform dynamic linear regressions for MEF estimation in the German market. Their Markov switching dynamic regression (MSDR) model finds three regimes representing i) low-emission periods with renewable dominance, ii) high-emission periods characterized by fossil fuel dispatch, and iii) volatile transition states. However, despite finding the emissions and generation series to be stationary, the authors use first-order differences. This transformation is statistically unnecessary for stationary data and introduces interpretational ambiguity by modeling rates of change rather than level-based physical realizations. Another notable limitation of their approach is the use of total generation (including renewables) as the explanatory variable. Since renewable generation contributes zero direct emissions, their regime-switching mechanism distinguishes between periods of high renewable penetration (low MEF) and periods of fossil fuel dominance (high MEF), rather than capturing the shifting marginal dynamics between gas and coal technologies. Our work overcomes such limitations by simultaneously grounding regime identification in fuel market fundamentals; specifically, we validate that observed regimes correspond to distinct marginal fossil-fuel states 2 2 2 While the emission intensity of oil is comparable to coal, we exclude oil here. Oil-fired units function almost exclusively as super-peakers, meaning they are invariably the marginal fuel when active. The modeling challenge and focus of this study is distinguishing between gas and coal at the margin. and link regime instability to structural breaks in natural gas pricing. Moreover, our study shows that earlier linear models, despite being less rigorous for estimating MEFs, remain useful for analysing other behaviours of marginal units, specifically the marginal fuel probability and generation–load responsiveness . We contribute to the literature in three main ways. First, by rigorous estimation of MEFs for the total US48 region using an MS-ARX framework, allowing us to disentangle distinct, mutually exclusive operating regimes. Second, we demonstrate that standard linear models mask the dichotomy between “clean” (gas-margin) and “dirty” (coal-margin) fossil-fuel states, leading to potential overestimation of abatement potential. Third, we employ a robust structural break detection on natural gas prices to further unpack our regime-switching results. We find that a structural shift in gas pricing in May 2022 fundamentally altered the grid’s stability. Specifically, we observe that after an inflationary phase characterized by energy volatility and rising prices driven by the COVID-19 pandemic and the Ukraine-Russia war, the energy market then entered a correction phase. The rest of the paper is organized as follows. Section 2 reviews existing MEF estimation methods. Section 3 presents the data, while the empirical methodology is described in Section 4 . The results are discussed in Section 5 and Section 6 offers conclusions. 2 Review of existing methods The extant literature on MEF estimation follows three primary methodological frameworks. First, US fixed-effects (US-FE), originating from regression analysis of U.S. inter- and intra-day emissions and generation data while controlling for time and regional fixed effects ( 22 , and 7 ). Second, the 19 approach, which employs first-order differencing, capturing system-level changes between settlement periods i.e. intra-day. Third, ARIMA-FE , introduced by 4 , incorporates autoregressive integrated moving average (ARIMA) components alongside fixed effects within and across days. We will focus on intra-day in what follows, as this underpins our main results, noting that the arguments apply to inter-day, too. The general US-FE

Read the complete text