Impact of Dynamical Charm Quark and Mixed Action Effect on Light Hadron Masses and Decay Constants
CLQCD Collaboration, Tong-Wei Lin, Zun-Xian Zhang, Mengchu Cai, Hai-Yang Du, Bolun Hu, Xiangyu Jiang, Xiao-Lan Meng, Ji-Hao Wang, Peng Sun, Yi-Bo Yang, Dian-Jun Zhao · 2026
Read Impact of Dynamical Charm Quark and Mixed Action Effect on Light Hadron Masses and Decay Constants by CLQCD Collaboration, Tong-Wei Lin, Zun-Xian Zhang, Mengchu Cai, Hai-Yang Du, Bolun Hu, Xiangyu Jiang, Xiao-Lan Meng, Ji-Hao Wang, Peng Sun, Yi-Bo Yang, Dian-Jun Zhao (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-04230.txt.
Introduction
Lin and colleagues study the impact of dynamical charm quark and mixed action effects on light hadron masses and decay constants. For light, strange, and charm flavor observables, they use the same tadpole-improved clover fermion action. Numerical results cover pion and kaon decay constants, light and strange quark masses, and Omega and Omega-ccc baryon masses. After continuum, chiral, and infinite-volume extrapolations, the values agree within uncertainties.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | CLQCD Collaboration, Tong-Wei Lin, Zun-Xian Zhang, Mengchu Cai, Hai-Yang Du, Bolun Hu, Xiangyu Jiang, Xiao-Lan Meng, Ji-Hao Wang, Peng Sun, Yi-Bo Yang, Dian-Jun Zhao |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36158 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.04230
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Impact of Dynamical Charm Quark and Mixed Action Effect on Light Hadron Masses and Decay Constants CLQCD Collaboration, Tong-Wei Lin, Zun-Xian Zhang, Mengchu Cai, Hai-Yang Du, Bolun Hu, Xiangyu Jiang, Xiao-Lan Meng, Ji-Hao Wang, Peng Sun, Yi-Bo Yang, Dian-Jun Zhao Abstract We investigate the impact of including a dynamical charm quark on the properties of light hadrons. Our study uses gauge ensembles generated with the tadpole-improved Symanzik gauge action, comparing 2+1+1 flavor (HISQ fermion) ensembles at four lattice spacings to 2+1 flavor (clover fermion) ensembles at six lattice spacings. For the light and strange flavor observables, we employ the same tadpole-improved clover fermion action. From numerical results for light and strange quark masses, pion and kaon decay constants, and Ω \Omega baryon masses, we find that the values obtained after continuum, chiral, and infinite-volume extrapolations are consistent within uncertainties. Even though the mixed action setup can introduce additional discretization effects, our calculation shows evidences that those effects can cancel with the discretization error in the unitary setup, resulting in better convergence in the continuum extrapolation. I Introduction The Standard Model of particle physics includes six flavors of quarks. Three of these—charm, bottom, and top—are heavier than the intrinsic scale of the strong interaction, \Lambda_{\rm QCD}\sim 300\ \mathrm{MeV} . The other three—up, down, and strange—are lighter than \Lambda_{\rm QCD} at a typical renormalization scale of 2 GeV in the \overline{\mathrm{MS}} scheme. The three light flavors exhibit an approximate \mathrm{SU}(3) flavor symmetry, with symmetry-breaking effects on the order of 10\% for various observables. In contrast, the three heavy flavors are largely decoupled from light-hadron physics, a result supported by current lattice QCD averages in flavor physics 9 . A direct assessment of heavy flavors’ impact on light-hadron physics is highly non-trivial. Introducing an additional flavor significantly alters the bare strong coupling constant, which in turn modifies the bare quark masses that determine physical hadron masses. Furthermore, for widely used Wilson-like fermion formulations—such as Clover and twisted-mass fermions—these bare masses require additional parameter tuning due to additive mass renormalization from explicit chiral symmetry breaking. In contrast, mass tuning for staggered fermions is much simpler. However, calculations of hadronic observables with staggered fermions are complicated by ambiguities arising from taste-breaking effects. This paradox can be resolved using a mixed-action approach: gauge ensembles are generated with dynamical staggered fermions across various flavor numbers, while hadronic observables are calculated using fermion actions without taste degree of freedom such as Clover. Although the leading-order low-energy constant for mixed-action effects has been shown to scale as roughly \mathcal{O}(a^{4}) across a wide range of lattice spacings 78 ; 77 , a systematic study of their impact on hadronic observables remains absent from the literature. In this work, we compute light hadronic observables using clover valence fermions on dynamical 2+1+1-flavor HISQ fermion and Symanzik gauge ensembles spanning four lattice spacings, three pion masses, and several spatial volumes. Compared to results obtained using the 2+1 flavor ensembles using the same clover fermion and Symanzik gauge actions, we find that the discretization errors from this mixed-action setup are significantly reduced, with potential \mathcal{O}(a^{4}) contributions remaining negligible within our statistical uncertainties. Finally, we update the predictions for low-energy constants from a previous 2+1 flavor CLQCD study 63 , now with improved control over systematic uncertainties using the ensembles at three more lattice spacings. II Simulation setup In this work, we use the 1-step stout link smeared (with smear size \rho=0.125 ) clover valence fermion action 63 ; 48 , \displaystyle S_{q}(\tilde{m})=\sum_{x}\big\{\bar{\psi}(x+\eta\hat{\mu}a)\sum_{\mu=1,...,4,\eta=\pm}\frac{1-\eta\gamma_{\mu}}{2}V_{\eta\mu}(x) \displaystyle\quad+\psi(x)\big[-(4+\tilde{m})\delta_{y,x})+\frac{c_{\rm sw}}{2}\sigma^{\mu\nu}g_{0}\sum_{\mu<\nu}F^{V}_{\mu\nu}\big]\}\psi(x), (1) where c_{\rm sw}=\frac{1}{v^{3}_{0}} with v_{0} being the tadpole improved factor of the smeared gauge link V , and we use \tilde{O} for the dimensionless value of any quantity O . The calculation are performed on two sets of the gauge ensembles: one set is the 2+1-flavor ensembles using the tadpole improved Symanzik gauge action and the same sea fermion action, and the other is the 2+1+1-flavor ones using using the same gauge action but the HISQ fermion action. The first set has been used in the previous CLQCD works (e.g., those for the basic parameter calibrations 63 ; 48 ), and second set is generated recently and has been used for the determination of the mixed action effect in the valence-sea mixed pion mass 77 . Table 1: Summary table on the lattice spacing, m_{\pi}L , \tilde{L}^{3}\times\tilde{T} and m_{\pi,\eta_{s}} (In units of MeV) of the CLQCD ensembles with Clover fermion. The ensembles with superscript {*} are newly generated after the previous CLQCD work 63 . Ensemble a (fm) m_{\pi}L \tilde{L}^{3}\times\tilde{T} m_{\pi}\,(\mathrm{MeV}) m_{\eta_{s}}\,(\mathrm{MeV}) C24P34 0.10542(17)(62) 4.37 24^{3}\times 64 340.6(1.7) 749.2(0.7) C24P29 3.75 24^{3}\times 72 292.4(1.0) 658.5(0.6) C32P29 5.02 32^{3}\times 64 293.4(0.8) 659.5(0.4) C32P23 3.90 32^{3}\times 64 228.1(1.2) 644.6(0.4) C48P23 5.75 48^{3}\times 96 224.3(1.2) 644.8(0.6) C48P14 3.50 48^{3}\times 96 136.5(1.7) 707.3(0.4) E28P35 ∗ 0.09013(25)(53) 4.42 28^{3}\times 64 345.4(1.1) 710.7(1.0) E32P29 ∗ 4.17 32^{3}\times 64 285.4(1.8) 698.2(0.9) E32P22 ∗ 3.14 32^{3}\times 96 215.1(2.2) 685.8(0.7) F32P30 0.07760(07)(46) 3.79 32^{3}\times 96 301.0(1.2) 677.3(1.0) F48P30 5.73 48^{3}\times 96 303.5(0.7) 676.1(0.5) F32P21 2.65 32^{3}\times 64 210.5(2.2) 660.1(0.9) F48P21 3.93 48^{3}\times 96 207.9(1.1) 663.7(0.6) F64P14 ∗ 3.41 64^{3}\times 128 135.6(1.2) 681.0(0.5) G36P29 ∗ 0.06895(17)(41) 3.72 36^{3}\times 108 295.7(1.1) 692.6(0.5) H48P32 0.05235(11)(31) 4.03 48^{3}\times 144 316.1(1.0) 690.6(0.7) I64P31 ∗ 0.03761(08)(22) 3.81 64^{3}\times 128 312.2(1.6) 671.4(1.3) The updated lattice spacing a 37 , the dimensionless lattice volume \tilde{L}^{3}\times\tilde{T} , and the finite-volume parameter m_{\pi}L for the gauge ensembles generated with the clover fermion action are listed in Table 1 . For the ensembles marked with a superscript “ ∗ ”, we generate new quark propagators and correlation functions; for the remaining ensembles, we reuse the data from previous CLQCD work 63 . Table 2: Summary table on the lattice spacing, \tilde{L}^{3}\times\tilde{T} , m_{\pi}L and m_{\pi,\eta_{s},\eta_{c}} (In unit of MeV) of the CLQCD ensembles with HISQ fermion 77 . Ensemble a (fm) \tilde{L}^{3}\times\tilde{T} m_{\pi}L m_{\pi} m_{\eta_{s}} m_{\eta_{c}} c24P31s 0.1084(4) 24^{3}\times 48 4.13 313(2) 745(3) 2.973(12) c24P31 24^{3}\times 48 4.07 309(2) 687(3) 2.972(12) c32P31 32^{3}\times 48 5.44 310(1) 686(3) 2.972(12) c24P22 24^{3}\times 48 2.94 223(2) 685(3) 2.970(12) c32P22 32^{3}\times 48 3.87 220(1) 684(3) 2.970(12) c48P13 48^{3}\times 48 3.53 134(1) 683(3) 2.970(12) e32P31 0.0867(4) 32^{3}\times 64 4.41 313(2) 694(3) 3.015(13) g32P32 0.0710(3) 32^{3}\times 64 3.65 317(3) 692(3) 2.981(13) g48P31 48^{3}\times 64 5.38 311(2) 691(3) 2.983(13) h48P31 0.0473(3) 48^{3}\times 96 3.60 313(3) 692(5) 2.947(19) x24P31 0.1114(6) 24^{3}\times 48 4.35 321(2) 711(4) – y24P31 0.1116(6) 24^{3}\times 48 4.22 311(2) 688(4) – z24P31 0.1128(7) 24^{3}\times 48 4.35 317(2) 704(4) – Similar information for the newly generated gauge ensembles with the HISQ fermion action is provided in Table 1 . The strange and charm quark masses are tuned to their physical values for most ensembles. The exception is the c24P31s ensemble, for which we deliberately vary the quark masses to investigate mistuning effects. We have also generated three additional 2+1 flavor ensembles to isolate the impacts of the charm sea quark from those of the mixed-action setup, using the tree level Symanzik gauge action (x24P31), tadpole improved Symanzik gauge action (y24P31, the same as the preivous 2+1-flavor CLQCD ensembles), and Iwasaki gauge action (z24P31). Due to the non-zero critical quark mass \tilde{m}_{\rm crit} required to vanish the pion mass in the Clover fermion formulation, a direct definition of the renormalized quark mass m_{q}^{R} from the bare