Observational Indistinguishability and the Beginning of the Universe
Dan Linford · 2026
Read Observational Indistinguishability and the Beginning of the Universe by Dan Linford (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-04159.txt.
Introduction
Daniel Linford asks whether we can infer that all of real reality began to exist, offering results suggesting a negative verdict. He offers two necessary but not sufficient terms for a cosmic beginning. Three theorems then show observers cannot infer global spacetime structure across a wide range of spacetimes. One theorem makes beginning-satisfying spacetimes indistinguishable from failing ones, while two extensions bar enough data to judge singularity terms or the necessary terms.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dan Linford |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 64781 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.04159
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Observational Indistinguishability and the Beginning of the Universe Dan Linford Abstract Can we infer whether all of physical reality began to exist? Several novel results are offered suggesting a negative verdict. First, a common strategy for defending a cosmic beginning involves showing that individual beginningless cosmological models are implausible. This strategy is shown to make an elementary error in confirmation theory. Second, two necessary (but not necessarily sufficient) conditions are offered for a cosmic beginning. Third, three extensions are offered to the Malament-Manchak theorems. The three extensions show that in almost all classical spacetimes, observers cannot collect sufficient data to determine whether the application conditions for the classic singularity theorems are satisfied or whether their spacetime satisfies the two necessary conditions for a cosmic beginning. Lastly, a reply is offered to the objection that the skeptical consequences of the three extensions can be overcome with induction. Importantly, all past singular dust FLRW spacetimes have observationally indistinguishable counterparts which, while sharing a number of important local properties, either do not include a singularity to the past of every point or else do not have the sort of time ordering intuitively required for a cosmic beginning. 1 Introduction Before the 1960s, most physicists assumed that the singularities appearing in standard cosmological models were mere artifacts of idealizing the universe as perfectly homogeneous and isotropic. According to an oft-told narrative, when Stephen Hawking, Roger Penrose, Robert Geroch, and others subsequently demonstrated that singularities are generic features of relativistic spacetimes, they established that physical reality most likely began with the Big Bang. 1 1 1 For an overview of the history up through the Hawking-Penrose theorem, see ( 8 ) . For a critical discussion, see ( 40 ) . For important work in this development, see ( 20 ; 21 ; 14 ; 19 ; 18 ) . Contrary to the popular narrative, the classic singularity theorems cannot establish a cosmic beginning: they show at most that spacetimes satisfying certain physical conditions must contain incomplete geodesics. 2 2 2 The popular narrative is mistaken in another important respect as well. While the singularity theorems appear to show that merely relaxing isotropy or homogeneity does not regularize spacetime, one can regularize spacetime by introducing a sufficiently strong inhomogeneity ( 36 ; 37 ; 38 ; 39 ; 40 ) . Since a spacetime with incomplete geodesics can also contain complete timelike geodesics, such theorems fall short of establishing that all of physical reality began in the Big Bang. In order to establish a common beginning for all of spacetime, we need to know much more about spacetime’s global structure than singularity theorems, themselves, are capable of establishing. Meanwhile, an important result – first conjectured by David Malament ( 27 ) and later proved by J.B. Manchak ( 28 ) – suggests we will never know the global structure of the spacetime we inhabit. Taking these results together, one may wonder whether a beginning of all of physical reality can be established. Here, several new results are presented concerning the observational indistinguishability of spacetimes satisfying two intuitive conditions for a cosmic beginning. Section 2 argues that a common strategy for defending or denying a cosmic beginning – by rejecting individual cosmological models as implausible – makes an elementary error in confirmation theory. Section 3 provides several definitions, including two necessary but insufficient conditions for a spacetime to have a beginning in an intuitive sense. Section 4 discusses the Malament-Manchak theorems, sketches their proofs, and then, in subsection 4.1 , presents a series of corollaries to the Malament–Manchak Theorem. According to the corollaries, spacetimes satisfying various global conditions required by the classic singularity theorems have an observationally indistinguishable counterpart that fails to satisfy it; spacetimes with the sort of time ordering intuitively required for a beginning are observationally indistinguishable from spacetimes that do not; likewise, spacetimes with a singularity to the past of every point are observationally indistinguishable from one without a singularity to the past of every point. Finally, section 5 responds to the objection that the theorems from previous sections may be overcome using induction. I demonstrate that all FLRW spacetimes, with dust stress-energy content, that have a singularity to the past of every point possess observationally indistinguishable counterparts that, while sharing a number of physically interesting properties, do not include a singularity to the past of every point. Moreover, I introduce a set of mathematical techniques frequently employed in astrophysical applications, but which have not previously been discussed in connection with observationally indistinguishable spacetimes. Together, these results support a negative verdict for whether we can know that all of spacetime began. 2 Confirmation Theory In a conference presentation from 2012, physicists Audrey Mithani and Alexander Vilenkin considered three popular cosmological scenarios (eternal inflation, a cyclic universe, and an emergent universe) and asked whether the universe had a beginning. They answered, At this point, it seems that the answer to this question is probably yes. Here we have addressed three scenarios which seemed to offer a way to avoid a beginning, and have found that none of them can actually be eternal in the past ( 34 , 5) . Instead of completely ruling out the possibility that any of these three could involve a past eternal universe, they argue that any of the ways in which the three could be past eternal are so deeply implausible that they can be ruled out for all practical purposes. Hence, they conclude, we should think that the universe most likely had a beginning. Unfortunately, this is not a good reason for thinking that the universe likely had a beginning. To see this, let’s start by supposing that there are l known cosmological models without a beginning and s unknown cosmological models without a beginning. There are, of course, a large number of known cosmological models (we are by no means limited to Mithani and Vilenkin’s three examples) and, quite plausibly, an even greater number of unknown cosmological models. Hence, l and s are large numbers. Denote the disjunction of known beginningless cosmological models as: W^{K}_{\vee}\equiv W^{K}_{1}\vee W^{K}_{2}\vee W^{K}_{3}\vee...\vee W^{K}_{l} (1) Where W^{K}_{i} , i\in\{1,2,...,l\} , is a specific beginningless cosmological model. Likewise, denote the disjunction of unknown beginningless cosmological models as: W^{U}_{\vee}\equiv W^{U}_{1}\vee W^{U}_{2}\vee W^{U}_{3}\vee...\vee W^{U}_{s} (2) Assuming that the models are mutually exclusive and given background knowledge K and evidence e , the posterior epistemic probability of a beginningless universe is: \displaystyle Pr(W_{\vee}|K\&e) \displaystyle=Pr(W_{\vee}^{K}\vee W_{\vee}^{U}|K\&e) (3) \displaystyle=Pr(W_{\vee}^{K}|K\&e)+Pr(W_{\vee}^{U}|K\&e) (4) \displaystyle=\Sigma_{i}Pr(W_{i}^{K}|K\&e)+\Sigma_{j}Pr(W_{j}^{U}|K\&e) (5) To conclude that the universe is more likely to have had a beginning than to not have had a beginning, we need to infer that Pr(W_{\vee}|K\&e)<0.5 . However, even if \Sigma_{i}Pr(W_{i}^{K}|K\&e)\approx 0 , it’s still possible that \Sigma_{j}Pr(W_{j}^{U}|K\&e)\approx 1 , so that Pr(W_{\vee}|K\&e)\approx 1 . That is, while \Sigma_{i}Pr(W_{i}^{K}|K\&e)\approx 0 is a necessary condition for Pr(W_{\vee}|K\&e)<0.5 , it is not a sufficient condition. Furthermore, a sum of sufficiently many small numbers can be large. Hence, supposing that, for all i\in\{1,2,...,l\} , Pr(W_{i}^{K})\approx 0 , it’s still possible that \Sigma_{i}Pr(W_{i}^{K})\approx 1 . There are two ways one could successfully show that, probably, the universe had a beginning. First, one could show that some specific cosmological model with a beginning, B , is more than 50\% probable