Evaluation of the performance of an analytical-numerical coupled method for droplet impacts on soft material surfaces Journal: arXiv
Hao Hao, Antonis Sergis, Alex M. K. P. Taylor, Yannis Hardalupas, Maria N. Charalambides · 2026
Read Evaluation of the performance of an analytical-numerical coupled method for droplet impacts on soft material surfaces Journal: arXiv by Hao Hao, Antonis Sergis, Alex M. K. P. Taylor, Yannis Hardalupas, Maria N. Charalambides (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-04131.txt.
Introduction
Hao and colleagues evaluate a coupled method for droplet impact on soft materials. Droplet impacts erode aircraft surfaces and turbine blades. A coupled model exists in the literature, but its pressure solution assumed a rigid surface. The study tests the model on urethane gel phantoms against experiments and particle hydrodynamics simulations. Parametric studies explore the limit for soft materials. For materials at 47,400 Pa or stiffer, the model performs as expected. Softer materials show mitigated intensity, and below 10,000 Pa the model overshoots force and deformation, forming steep wall craters.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hao Hao, Antonis Sergis, Alex M. K. P. Taylor, Yannis Hardalupas, Maria N. Charalambides |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 44774 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.04131
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Evaluation of the performance of an analytical-numerical coupled method for droplet impacts on soft material surfaces Journal: arXiv Hao Hao, Antonis Sergis, Alex M. K. P. Taylor, Yannis Hardalupas, Maria N. Charalambides Abstract Impacts between droplets and solid surfaces can commonly cause erosion problem in Engineering applications, including aircraft surface erosion, wind blade leading-edge erosion and steam turbine blade erosion. In practice, the impacted solid surfaces have varied material softness, ranging from stiff metallic coatings to soft materials. An analytical-numerical coupled model (ANCM) for simulating droplet impacts on surfaces, and corresponding material analysis, has been developed in the literature. However, the analytical impact pressure solution of the ANCM model has been derived assuming rigid solid surface. In the current study, we investigate the performance of the ANCM model for droplet impacts on soft materials made of urethane gel phantom, by comparing the ANCM computations to lab-based experiments and numerical simulations based on Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH). Parametric studies explore the applicability limit of the ANCM model for droplet impacts on very soft materials at low Young’s modulus. It was found that for materials at Young’s modulus of 47,400 47,400 Pa \mathrm{Pa} or stiffer, which covers most engineering applications, the developed ANCM model performs as expected for an assumed rigid surface. For softer solid materials, the SPH-modeled liquid interacts with the evolving surface geometry and mitigates impact intensity as deformation occurs. The analytical impact loads estimated by ANCM are independent of surface geometry, and hence provide conserved impact impulse in a non-physical way. Results show a critical value of Young’s modulus at E = 10,000 E=10,000 Pa \mathrm{Pa} for the ANCM model, below which the model exhibits overshoot in total contact force and surface deformation, leading to the formation of steep wall craters. 1 Introduction Impact of liquid droplets on solid surfaces has been a research topic for decades due to its ubiquity in the environment. Developed technologies have produced a wide range of applications including aqueous jet-cleaning [ 1 ] , 3 D printing [ 2 ] , combustion [ 3 ] , deposition in pharmacology and agriculture [ 4 ] . In some engineering applications, understanding the material stress field induced by liquid impacts is important for erosion damage. This includes liquid impacts onto stiff materials, such as erosion problems on aircraft [ 5 ] and wind turbine blades [ 6 , 7 ] , and soft materials, such as skin-injection [ 8 ] and soft matter rupture [ 9 ] in biomedical fields. Early experimental work on single droplet impact to solid materials noticed the relation between the dynamic loadings of liquid impacts and stress waves in the solids [ 10 ] . Particularly, a ring-shape erosion pattern has been widely observed in experiments [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] and regarded as the main characteristic of damage on the impact surface. However, erosion studies of stiff materials are typically focused on the material surface, while stress distributions inside the material upon liquid droplet impacts are better revealed on soft materials, and hence (relatively) large deformation, with digital image correlation (DIC). Sun et al. [ 13 ] embedded tracer particles in polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS) gel and successfully viewed the impact induced stresses using a laser illumination and high-speed stress microscopy. More recently, Yokoyama et al. [ 14 , 15 ] measured a stressed gelatine gel’s photoelastic parameters (phase retardation and azimuthal angle) using a polarization camera and constructed the three-dimensional stress field in the gelatine gel using integrated photoelasticity. Nevertheless, the experimental methods for stress field measurements inside solid materials require transparent materials, which greatly limits applicability. Figure 1 : Initial droplet (and material) configuration in the Cartesian coordinate system (a) and corresponding analytical pressure profiles on the rigid surface upon liquid droplet impact in [ 28 ] , shown at time t=0.05 (b), t=0.1 (c) and t=0.3 (d). r_{0}=1 and u_{0}=1 denote the radius and impact velocity of the droplet, respectively. Subfigures (b-d) have the same axes and pressure limits. All variables in the figure are presented in their dimensionless forms. Also, numerical fluid-structure interaction (FSI) models have been developed to explore liquid-solid impacts, which, in principle, are not limited to material choices. Typical FSI models are based on a Finite Element (FE) approach for the solid phase where material deformations, and hence stresses and strains, are discretized and calculated on Lagrangian nodes [ 16 , 17 ] . The general FE approach of material analysis is applicable to both stiff [ 18 , 19 ] and soft [ 20 , 21 ] materials. For impacted liquids, FE-based approaches, including Coupled Eulerian-Lagrangian (CEL) [ 22 ] and Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH) [ 23 ] , have high computational costs due to large deformations of the liquids [ 24 ] and poor resolutions in capturing the detailed flow features [ 25 ] . This can be improved in coupled approaches [ 26 , 27 ] which involve a separate Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulation for the impacted liquids as the dynamic loading conditions on the contact surface of the FE material analysis. The coupled method benefits from better accuracy on the droplet flow dynamics, but requires an extra consideration on the deliberate design of grids at the interface for data exchange. More recently, Hao et al. [ 28 ] developed an analytical-numerical coupled method (ANCM) which incorporated an analytical solution [ 29 ] of single liquid droplet impact (Figure 1 ) as a spatio-temporal boundary conditions on the material surface of the FE analysis. The analytical solution replaces the need to numerically simulate the droplet and hence simplifies the contact problem to a single phase FE analysis. Consequently, the developed ANCM requires reduced mesh resolution and provides accurate simulations at a remarkably low computational cost. Nevertheless, we note that all the above-mentioned coupled methods, and most literature on FSI simulations [ 30 ] , are one-way coupling algorithms, which assume rigid solid surface geometry with no surface deformation felt by the liquids during impact. In contrast, two-way coupling interchanged information between phases on the contact surface leads to fluid flows that are affected by structural deformation and vice versa [ 31 ] . This process is often very complex and requires iterations within timesteps to achieve convergence and desired accuracy [ 32 ] . Therefore, the literature review shows that the advantages and potential of the one-way coupled FSI model of ANCM that provides accurate and computationally cheap solutions for engineering applications affected by droplet impacts on solid materials. However, since the analytical solution of droplet impact assumes rigid solid surface, the capabilities of the ANCM model remain unknown for soft material surfaces. The capabilities of the ANCM model to surfaces of softer materials, which have surface deformation, must be evaluated. It is important to develop physical understanding on the subtle changes in material deformation behaviour as stiffness decreases, and hence establish the applicability limits of the rigid surface assumption for soft materials. In this way, a prediction shall be provided for the critical value of material stiffness for the applicability limit of the ANCM model to soft materials, which is the purpose of the present study. Section 2 introduces the FE numerical models for liquid droplet impact