Echoes of Norms: Investigating Counterspeech Bots’ Influence on Bystanders in Online Communities CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in collaborative and social computing
Mengyao Wang, Shuai Ma, Nuo Li, Peng Zhang, Chenxin Li, Ning Gu, Tun Lu · 2026
Read Echoes of Norms: Investigating Counterspeech Bots’ Influence on Bystanders in Online Communities CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in collaborative and social computing by Mengyao Wang, Shuai Ma, Nuo Li, Peng Zhang, Chenxin Li, Ning Gu, Tun Lu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-03687.txt.
Introduction
Mengyao Wang and six colleagues study the silent audience of online hate speech: the bystanders. Counterspeech, replying to hate rather than deleting it, is known to restrain speakers and support targets, but its effect on watchers was unmapped. Their 2026 team built a strategy framework and a bot, Civilbot, then ran a mixed-method study where bystanders watched it work.
Bystanders generally found the bot credible and norm-setting, though its shallow reasoning limited how persuasive it felt. Effects were subtle and double-edged. A strong performance could guide participation or let bystanders relax while the bot stood in. A weak one could discourage them, or provoke them to intervene themselves. Strategy decided much: reason-appealing cognitive strategies in a positive tone worked best, while mismatched strategies in the wrong context weakened the impact.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Mengyao Wang, Shuai Ma, Nuo Li, Peng Zhang, Chenxin Li, Ning Gu, Tun Lu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 107671 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.03687
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Echoes of Norms: Investigating Counterspeech Bots’ Influence on Bystanders in Online Communities CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in collaborative and social computing Mengyao Wang, Shuai Ma, Nuo Li, Peng Zhang, Chenxin Li, Ning Gu, Tun Lu Abstract . Counterspeech offers a non-repressive approach to moderate hate speech in online communities. Research has examined how counterspeech chatbots restrain hate speakers and support targets, but their impact on bystanders remains unclear. Therefore, we developed a counterspeech strategy framework and built Civilbot for a mixed-method within-subjects study. Bystanders generally viewed Civilbot as credible and normative, though its shallow reasoning limited persuasiveness. Its behavioural effects were subtle: when performing well, it could guide participation or act as a stand-in; when performing poorly, it could discourage bystanders or motivate them to step in. Strategy proved critical: cognitive strategies that appeal to reason, especially when paired with a positive tone, were relatively effective, while mismatch of contexts and strategies could weaken impact. Based on these findings, we offer design insights for mobilizing bystanders and shaping online discourse, highlighting when to intervene and how to do so through reasoning-driven and context-aware strategies. 1. Introduction Online communities aspire to foster a diverse, open, and vibrant space for public, yet this ideal is increasingly undermined by the spread of hate speech. Hate speech is commonly defined as targeted, harmful, and weaponized forms of expression against specific groups ( 80 ) . It inflicts profound emotional and psychological harm on its victims, ranging from anxiety and self-blame to suicidal ideation, and can even trigger real-world violence ( 2 ; 3 ; 12 ) . A particularly troubling aspect is how easily hate speech spreads: when people are exposed to malicious or antisocial comments, they become more likely to produce similar negativity ( 3 ; 15 ) , even if they are usually not highly aggressive ( 70 ) . Within communities, hate speech propagates imitation, perpetuates prejudice, and reinforces stereotypes ( 80 ) , ultimately fuelling stigmatization ( 51 ) and structural injustice ( 14 ) , which can further divide society. Traditional content moderation relies on restrictive interventions imposed by platforms to counteract hate speech. However, such methods often risk the over-removal of empowering discourse, forcing platforms to adopt cautious and conservative classification thresholds, which in turn further overlook implicit forms of hate speech ( 36 ) . Moreover, users can easily migrate to platforms with looser moderation policies, limiting the effectiveness of isolated interventions ( 80 ) . In light of the limitations of heavy-handed moderation, counterspeech has emerged as a widely recognized alternative—non-repressive, socially grounded, and scalable—that seeks not to suppress but to enrich online discourse. Counterspeech is typically defined as a direct reply to hateful content ( 80 ; 7 ; 71 ) , which can take forms such as challenging or condemning the attack ( 81 ; 37 ) , expressing solidarity and support ( 37 ) , or even attempting to shift perspectives ( 62 ) . Unlike content moderation, counter speech is rooted in a liberal tradition, emphasizing “speech against speech” rather than “power against speech” ( 14 ; 47 ) . Its potential lies not only in addressing individual instances of hate but also in influencing broader social norms that frame hate as unacceptable, thereby altering the overall tone of community dialogue ( 11 ; 9 ) . Within such a mechanism, online spaces need not serve as arenas for the spread of hostility but can evolve into fairer and safer environments for communication ( 80 ; 69 ) . Moreover, counterspeech may generate a “positive contagion effect”: expressions that denounce incivility or encourage respectful dialogue can themselves inspire similar responses, creating cycles of positive imitation and role modelling ( 54 ; 73 ) . In recent years, the rapid advancement of generative AI has provided a technical foundation for the automation of counterspeech. A growing body of work has constructed hate-counterspeech corpora ( 1 ; 33 ; 52 ; 85 ; 89 ) , trained classification and generation models ( 52 ; 32 ; 68 ; 91 ; 17 ; 8 ) , and introduced enhancement strategies such as incorporating background knowledge ( 1 ; 84 ) , contextual information ( 6 ; 18 ; 25 ) , and complex argumentative structures ( 32 ; 68 ; 35 ) , etc. These approaches have enabled counterspeech chatbots to achieve more persuasive argumentation and contextually appropriate responses in online community settings, amplifying potential social impact. However, existing research on counterspeech chatbots has primarily focused on curbing hate speakers ( 11 ; 6 ; 35 ) or providing support for targets of hate ( 61 ; 60 ) , while paying far less attention to bystanders—arguably the most crucial group in terms of both size and influence. Bystanders are not neutral observers: they often lean toward those who oppose hate speech, forming a “silent majority” that substantially shapes the community’s prevailing attitudes and social norms ( 80 ) . They may become potential counterspeakers, yet their silence can also be interpreted as implicit tolerance of hate. Prior research suggests that public counterspeech can disrupt the perception that “most people tolerate hate”, thereby weakening the spiral of silence ( 57 ) , and may also trigger herd effects ( 5 ) that motivate more users to speak out. However, it remains unclear whether counterspeech chatbots can exert comparable social influence, as systematic empirical evidence is still limited. To this end, we focus on the social influence of counterspeech chatbots on bystanders in online communities and how these effects ripple into the broader normative climate. We therefore pose the following research questions: • RQ1: To what extent do bystanders endorse the chatbot’s counterspeech and show changes in their behavioral tendencies (e.g., perceived reason strength, credibility, and confidence in countering)? • RQ2: How do different types of chatbot’ counterspeech shape bystanders’ endorsement of the chatbot’s responses and change of their behavioral tendencies? To establish a structured foundation for studying counterspeech, we developed a unified framework along three dimensions: sentence type (question and non-question), tone (positive and negative), and strategic intent, which includes cognitive strategies (e.g., highlighting truth) and affective strategies (e.g., denouncing hate speakers). The combination of dimensions produced eight distinct counterspeech strategies. Based on this framework, we built Civilbot, a prototype chatbot that generates context-aware counterspeech across these strategies. We then conducted a mixed-methods within-subject experiment with participants recruited from online communities who were interested in sensitive topics, generally silent in public discussions, yet opposed to hate speech. Each participant chose eight topics and, for each, read a hate-speech post, observed a counterspeech reply, and completed pre- and post-exposure attitude measures. Sessions were randomly assigned to the eight strategies, so everyone experienced all strategies. We assessed perceived counterspeech quality (e.g., convincing and strong reasons), subjective acceptance (e.g., credibility, importance, overall agreement), and behavioural tendencies (e.g., confidence in countering, willingness to participate), and complemented these metrics with semi-structured interviews exploring bystanders’ detailed perceptions of chatbot roles, and potential effects on community norms, etc. Our findings show that Civilbot’s counterspeech shapes bystanders’ perceptions of both the counterspeech itself and the bot, and also influences the overall climate of online communities—even affecting subtle behavioural tendencies. Civilbot is generally