Flavor in Ninths and a Discrete Gauge Origin of the QCD Axion

Vernon Barger · 2026

Read Flavor in Ninths and a Discrete Gauge Origin of the QCD Axion by Vernon Barger (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-03631.txt.

Introduction

Vernon Barger finds the pattern of particle masses written in ninths, and traces it to a gauge symmetry that also creates the axion. Quark and lepton mass hierarchies follow rational powers of one small parameter, counted in units of one ninth. His 2026 paper argues this flavor-in-ninths structure points to a discrete eighteen-fold gauge symmetry behind the Froggatt-Nielsen mechanism, with a nine-fold subgroup running the flavor pattern.

Identifying the flavon field with the Peccei-Quinn field makes the same symmetry do double duty. It stabilizes the QCD axion, forces the safe domain-wall number, and predicts the axion's coupling to photons. Harmful Planck-suppressed corrections are pushed to very high dimension, solving the axion quality problem naturally. For a decay constant in the favored range, the axion accounts for dark matter and sits within reach of near-term haloscope searches.

Catalog record

CREATORVernon Barger
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE57997
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.03631

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Flavor in Ninths and a Discrete Gauge Origin of the QCD Axion Vernon Barger Abstract Quark and lepton hierarchies are organized by rational powers of a single parameter in units of one ninth. We show that this “flavor in ninths” structure points to a discrete ℤ 18 \mathbb{Z}_{18} gauge origin of Froggatt–Nielsen symmetry, whose ℤ 9 \mathbb{Z}_{9} subgroup controls the flavor lattice. Identifying the flavon with the Peccei–Quinn field, the same symmetry stabilizes the QCD axion, enforces domain-wall number N DW = 1 N_{\rm DW}=1 , and predicts the axion–photon coupling through the anomaly ratio E / N = 8 / 3 E/N=8/3 (or 2 2 with light higgsinos). The lowest Planck-suppressed operator appears at dimension eighteen, naturally solving the axion quality problem. For f a ∼ ( 5 CLOSE f_{a}\sim(5 – OPEN 8 ) × 10 11 8)\times 10^{11} GeV the axion accounts for dark matter and lies within near-term haloscope reach. I Introduction The Peccei–Quinn (PQ) mechanism dynamically solves the strong CP problem by promoting \theta to an axion field whose vacuum expectation value relaxes \bar{\theta}\to 0 PQ ; WeinbergAxion ; WilczekAxion ; for reviews see Refs. KimCarosi ; DiLuzioReview . In any realistic theory, however, PQ must be an extremely good symmetry: Planck-suppressed PQ-violating operators can shift the axion minimum and reintroduce \bar{\theta} KamionkowskiMarchRussell ; Holman ; BarrSeckel . A compelling cure is to realize PQ as an accidental symmetry emerging from a discrete gauge symmetry, which is expected to be respected by quantum gravity KraussWilczek ; BabuGogoladzeWang and is constrained by discrete anomaly conditions IbanezRoss ; BanksDine . Independently, fermion masses span many orders of magnitude yet exhibit structured hierarchies. In Froggatt–Nielsen (FN) theories FN , Yukawa couplings arise from higher-dimensional operators suppressed by a flavon vacuum expectation value (vev), schematically y_{ij}\left(\frac{\Phi}{\Lambda}\right)^{p_{ij}}\bar{\psi}_{i}\psi_{j}H\,, (1) with exponents fixed by charges. Standard implementations of the FN mechanism assign integer charges and produce integer exponents Leurer1992 ; Leurer1993 . We observe, however, that quark and lepton hierarchies are accurately organized by rational exponents quantized in units of 1/9 , as established in a series of companion papers PaperI ; TwoOverTwo ; Companion ; LeptonLattice . We argue that “flavor in ninths” is a low-energy imprint of a gauged \mathbb{Z}_{18} selection rule whose \mathbb{Z}_{9} subgroup governs the flavor sector. Remarkably, if the FN flavon \Phi is identified with the PQ field, the same \mathbb{Z}_{18} structure both generates the ninths flavor lattice and automatically solves the axion quality and domain-wall problems Sikivie1982 . A related unification of the FN and PQ mechanisms via a continuous gauged U(1)_{F} flavor symmetry has been developed independently in Ref. BabuChandraseTavart . A key distinction is that our discrete \mathbb{Z}_{18} fixes the leading PQ-violating operator dimension exactly (dimension 18), whereas in continuous U(1)_{F} constructions the quality argument depends on the pattern of symmetry breaking and the resulting residual discrete subgroup. Integer-charge FN models have also been studied systematically by Cornella, Curtin, Neil, and Thompson Cornella2023 ; Cornella2025 . Those constructions map all solutions to the quark flavor problem within the standard integer-charge FN framework, providing a useful benchmark: the ninths lattice is excluded by construction in that search because it requires rational charges with denominator nine. We comment further on this comparison in Sec. VIII . The rest of this paper is organized as follows. Section II establishes the phenomenological basis for the ninths lattice, derives the expansion parameter B=75/14 , and presents quark and lepton exponent matrices. Section III connects the ninths quantization to a gauged \mathbb{Z}_{18} symmetry and presents a complete set of charge assignments satisfying discrete anomaly cancellation. Section IV shows that identifying the flavon with the PQ field yields automatic axion quality and N_{\rm DW}=1 . Section V works out the axion phenomenology, including E/N , the axion–photon and axion–electron couplings, and the cosmological relic density. Section VI discusses the extension to the neutrino sector and the Pontecorvo–Maki–Nakagawa–Sakata (PMNS) matrix. Section VII describes the vectorlike messenger sector that provides the UV completion of the rational exponents. Section VIII compares the ninths framework with integer-charge FN models. Section IX summarizes the unified picture. Five appendices collect the anomaly verification, the E/N calculation, details of the messenger chain construction, a terminology guide, and worked examples of mass ratios and CKM elements in the hop framework. II Ninths Structure and Textures II.1 Determination of the expansion parameter The central claim is that a single expansion parameter \epsilon\equiv\langle\Phi\rangle/\Lambda=1/B controls all quark and lepton hierarchies. The value of B is determined by the two best-measured Cabibbo–Kobayashi–Maskawa (CKM) Cabibbo ; KobayashiMaskawa magnitudes together with their ninths exponents: \displaystyle|V_{us}| \displaystyle=\epsilon^{8/9}, \displaystyle|V_{cb}| \displaystyle=\epsilon^{17/9}. (2) Taking the Particle Data Group (PDG) central values |V_{us}|=0.2250 and |V_{cb}|=0.04182 PDG2024 , Eq. ( 2 ) gives B=|V_{us}|^{-9/8}=5.357,\qquad B=|V_{cb}|^{-9/17}=5.358, (3) in remarkable agreement. The ratio 75/14\simeq 5.357 provides a convenient exact rational representation; the corresponding expansion parameter is \epsilon=14/75\approx 0.1867 . The system is overdetermined: once B is fixed by |V_{us}| and |V_{cb}| , the remaining CKM element |V_{ub}| and the quark and lepton mass ratios become predictions. Their numerical quality is summarized in Table 1 . II.2 CKM scalings With \epsilon\approx 0.187 , the three independent CKM magnitudes are well described by \displaystyle|V_{us}| \displaystyle\sim\epsilon^{8/9}, \displaystyle|V_{cb}| \displaystyle\sim\epsilon^{17/9}, \displaystyle|V_{ub}| \displaystyle\sim\epsilon^{10/3}. (4) In the FN language of Eq. ( 1 ), such relations reflect additive charge relations among generations and are naturally reproduced when the charge differences themselves are quantized in ninths. The Jarlskog invariant Jarlskog scales as J\sim\epsilon^{8/9+17/9+10/3}\sin\delta=\epsilon^{55/9}\sin\delta , giving J\approx 3.5\times 10^{-5}\sin\delta , consistent with the measured value J=(3.08\pm 0.13)\times 10^{-5} PDG2024 for \sin\delta\approx 0.88 . II.3 Mass ratio scalings Table 1: Ninths scalings versus data. Predicted values use \epsilon=14/75\approx 0.187 . Quark mass ratios are evaluated at \mu\sim 10^{2} GeV using the running masses of Ref. HuangZhou . Observable Exponent \epsilon^{p} Data |V_{us}| 8/9 0.225 0.225 |V_{cb}| 17/9 0.042 0.042 |V_{ub}| 10/3 0.0037 0.0038 m_{s}/m_{b} 7/3 0.020 0.019 m_{c}/m_{t} 10/3 0.0037 0.0036 m_{\mu}/m_{\tau} 5/3 0.061 0.060 m_{e}/m_{\mu} 29/9 0.0045 0.0048 Quark mass ratios align with the same expansion parameter: \displaystyle\frac{m_{s}}{m_{b}} \displaystyle\sim\epsilon^{7/3}, \displaystyle\frac{m_{c}}{m_{t}} \displaystyle\sim\epsilon^{10/3}, (5) suggesting that both mixings and masses are controlled by exponents in \frac{1}{9}\mathbb{Z} rather than integers. The first-generation quark mass ratios m_{d}/m_{s} and m_{u}/m_{c} involve the lightest quarks, whose running masses carry larger uncertainties and whose textures are most sensitive to \mathcal{O}(1) coefficients. In the companion papers TwoOverTwo ; Companion , the down-quark mass ratio m_{d}/m_{s}\sim\epsilon^{10/9} is reproduced with an \mathcal{O}(1) coefficient c_{d} of order unity, while the extreme smallness of m_{u} requires either m_{u}/m_{c}\sim\epsilon^{34/9} (purely from the texture) or a partial cancellation among \mathcal{O}(1) prefactors. The ninths lattice determines the parametric scaling but does not fully fix these first-generation ratios; we defer their detailed treatment to Refs. TwoOverTwo ; Companion . II.4 Quark exponent matrices A representative set of exponent matrices illustrating the ninths quantization is \displaystyle p^{u}_{ij} \displaystyle={\frac{1}{9}\begin{pmatrix}64&39&27\\ 55&30&18\\ 37&12&0\end{pmatrix}}, (6) \displaystyle p^{d}_{ij} \displaystyle={\frac{1}{9}\begin{pmatrix}37&30&27\\ 28&21&18\\ 10&3&0\end{pmatrix}}. These follow from the additive rule p_{ij}=Q(q_{i})+Q(q^{c}_{j}) with the charge assignments in Table 2 : left-handed charges Q(Q_{i})=(3,2,0) , right-handed up-type charges Q(u^{c}_{j})=(37/9,4/3,0) , and right-handed down-type charges Q(d^{c}_{j})=(10/9,1/3,0) . The unsuppressed (3,3) entries follow from Q(Q_{3})=Q(u^{c}_{3})=Q(d^{c}_{3})=0 ; the stepwise suppressions in ninths capture the observed hierarchies and are stable under diagonalization (not a basis artifact). Concrete charge assignments and full texture fits are

Read the complete text