The BAO scale – how standard is the standard ruler?
Licia Verde · 2026
Read The BAO scale – how standard is the standard ruler? by Licia Verde (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-03443.txt.
Introduction
Licia Verde questions how standard cosmology's standard ruler really is. Baryon acoustic oscillations leave a characteristic scale in how galaxies cluster, set by the sound horizon of the early universe. Analyses fit templates to extract that scale and convert it into distances. Her 2026 paper flags a subtle mismatch: the textbook sound horizon, computed from sound speed, differs slightly from the scale actually imprinted in clustered matter.
Extended to a broader family of cosmological models, that mismatch biases inferred parameters. For surveys with DESI-like precision, and even more for a forecast fifth-year dataset, the bias becomes a significant fraction of the statistical uncertainty once the true cosmos strays from the assumed one. Verde proposes several corrections suited to different uses. Analysts working in those regimes should apply them or budget the effect as a systematic error.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Licia Verde |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 96057 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.03443
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The BAO scale – how standard is the standard ruler? Licia Verde Abstract Analyses of baryon acoustic oscillations (BAO) commonly employ template-based methods to extract compressed parameters from the clustering of dark-matter tracers, which are then interpreted in terms of ratios of the sound-horizon scale and cosmological distances relative to a fiducial cosmology. A small mismatch between the sound-horizon scale derived from the standard analytic formulation (integral over the sound speed) and the effective scale imprinted in clustered matter can, however, introduce a systematic bias in cosmological inference. We extend previous work to a broader class of cosmological models, quantify this bias for surveys with DESI-like precision, and propose strategies to correct for the effect. We find that the induced bias becomes a significant fraction of the statistical uncertainty for deviations from the fiducial cosmology, at the level of | Δ Ω m | = 0.03 |\Delta\Omega_{m}|=0.03 and | Δ N eff | = 0.3 |\Delta N_{\mathrm{eff}}|=0.3 , and for very precise data corresponding to a forecasted Year-5 DESI survey (or other stage IV dark energy galaxy surveys). We present several ways to correct for this effect, suitable for a variety of applications. We therefore recommend that analyses exploring such parameter regimes either apply the proposed corrections or include an appropriate systematic error budget. 1 Introduction The sound horizon scale ( r_{d} ) is a fundamental quantity relevant both for the interpretation of cosmic microwave background (CMB) observations and the analysis of baryonic acoustic oscillations (BAO). In the early Universe, the photons and baryons were coupled and behaved as a forced damped harmonic oscillator with gravitational forces attempting to cluster the baryons, the photon pressure keeping structures from collapsing [ 6 , 10 , 39 ] . After the drag epoch, redshift z_{d}\sim 1060 , the baryons can start clustering under the effect of gravity, leaving the imprint of these oscillations, whose fundamental mode is set by r_{d} (the sound horizon at z_{d} ) in the dark matter and, in turn, in the large-scale structure (LSS) of the Universe [ 7 , 33 ] . Therefore, although a biased tracer of the dark matter, the distribution of galaxies in the late-time Universe is related to the distribution of baryons in the early Universe (see e.g., [ 20 , Chapter 5] ) and carries information about r_{d} . The sound horizon acts as a standard ruler [ 29 ] both in the CMB (sound horizon at decoupling) and the LSS (sound horizon at radiation drag), allowing us to measure cosmological distances, constrain cosmological parameters, and anchor the inverse distance ladder [ 9 , 24 ] . The BAO scale encodes the standard ruler information, manifested as a peak in the galaxy two-point correlation function (hereafter “BAO peak” ) and a series of oscillations in the power spectrum (hereafter “BAO oscillations” ). The way galaxies are distributed both radially (in redshift) and angularly in the sky (right ascension and declination) is accessed through galaxy spectroscopic surveys. Overall, such surveys have been covering increasingly larger cosmological volumes at increasing sensitivity to faint galaxies (see analyses of surveys like the Anglo Australian Two- and Six-Degrees-Field surveys [2dF, [ 21 ] , 6dF [ 35 ] ], the Sloan Digital Sky Survey [SDSS, [ 29 ] ] or the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument survey [DESI, [ 22 ] ]). This translated into a greater statistical precision of the inferred cosmological quantities (e.g. 2024 DESI Data Release 2 reaching an aggregate precision of 0.28% in BAO scale measurement and peak determination [ 2 ] ). With increasing statistical precision, exquisite control of systematic errors becomes paramount, and small effects once negligible, such as universally adopted approximations at the data analysis level, may become important. An example of such a systematic uncertainty introduced in the analysis is the computation of the sound horizon r_{d} itself. The standard analysis of BAO from galaxy clustering data proceeds in two steps: 1) a model-independent measurement of compressed quantities capturing the apparent size of the sound horizon is performed, yielding the BAO shift parameters (usually denoted by \alpha ), and 2) these BAO shift parameters are translated into cosmological parameters within a given model. While this approach greatly simplifies many aspects of the pipeline, accelerates cosmological parameter inference, and allows for greater interpretability of the results, it also introduces potential avenues for small systematic issues if the analysis is not performed exceedingly carefully. In step 1 above, the extraction of compressed cosmological information from the galaxy survey data (already compressed into summary statistics such as the power spectrum or correlation function) requires fitting a given template model to the data to extract the BAO location while marginalizing over additional information (such as the BAO peak amplitude, the broadband shape, etc.). This compression technique yields the BAO shift parameters (along the line of sight \parallel and across the line of sight \perp ), \alpha_{\parallel}(z)=(D_{H}(z)/r_{d})/(D_{H}(z)/r_{d})^{\mathrm{fid}}~,\qquad\quad\qquad\quad\alpha_{\perp}(z)=(D_{M}(z)/r_{d})/(D_{M}(z)/r_{d})^{\mathrm{fid}}~, (1.1) which are normalized cosmological distances (transverse comoving distance D_{M} and the Hubble distance D_{H} ) relative to a fiducial model, indicated by “fid” . However, the same procedure is not reproduced exactly in the theoretical interpretation of these quantities (step 2). Instead of producing a power spectrum and converting that into a prediction for the scaling quantities, one typically just evaluates the sound horizon in equation 1.1 through a simple integral [ 52 ] , r_{d}^{\rm int} , and combines it with the computed distances. By doing so, one is indirectly assuming that the decoupling is instantaneous and that no other effects are shifting the BAO oscillations. It has been known as early as 2008 that this is inexact: extracting r_{d} from the position of the BAO peak in the correlation function is affected by non-linear effects like Silk damping and velocity overshoot [ 45 ] . The full effect of this approximation, r_{d}\simeq r_{d}^{\rm int} , on cosmological inference is reduced because inference in practice is always done relative to a fiducial model (adopting the approximation both in the numerator and denominator of equation 1.1 ). Works studying the dependence of the cosmological inference results on the choice of the fiducial cosmology (or the fiducial template) include [ 12 ] , who explicitly test the robustness to modifications of the growth of perturbations prior to recombination, and [ 40 ] , who evaluate the impact of the fiducial cosmology assumed in the BAO analysis of DESI data. For previous surveys, the effect was found to be small; for DESI, it is propagated into a systematic error budget. Here, we focus on a specific component of the analysis that is influenced but not caused by the choice of the fiducial cosmology. Adopting the specific approximation r_{d}/r_{d}^{\rm fid}\simeq r_{d}^{\rm int}/r_{d}^{\rm int,fid} can, in principle, still introduce small systematic effects ( shifts or deviations in the recovered cosmological parameters): even in the case where the distances match those of the fiducial model, a shift in r_{d} induces a shift in \alpha , \Delta r_{d}/r_{d}\simeq\Delta\alpha/\alpha which affects equally \alpha_{\parallel} and \alpha{\perp} . This specific shift has been studied already in great detail in the context of previous surveys, see [ 52 , 17 ] . Ref. [ 52 ] found a 0.15% deviation for a standard set of