The Extended Real Line with Reentry: Separating US from KC in the Clontz Hierarchy

Damián Rafael Lattenero · 2026

Read The Extended Real Line with Reentry: Separating US from KC in the Clontz Hierarchy by Damián Rafael Lattenero (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-03228.txt.

Introduction

Damián Rafael Lattenero constructs a new space in general topology, the branch of mathematics that studies shape and nearness in abstract form. His 2026 paper builds the Extended Real Line with Reentry from the closed real line, endpoints included. The goal is a clean test case for fine distinctions between kinds of separation that topologists rank in the Clontz hierarchy.

The new space is compact and path-connected, and it is sober and uniquely sequential, yet its compact sets are not all closed. No compact path-connected space was known before that separates these two properties. Lattenero then generalizes the trick into a framework that builds similar spaces from many starting spaces, and shows the key hierarchy level survives repeated use and products.

Catalog record

CREATORDamián Rafael Lattenero
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE117035
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.03228

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Extended Real Line with Reentry: Separating US from KC in the Clontz Hierarchy Damián Rafael Lattenero Abstract We construct the Extended Real Line with Reentry (ERI), a quotient of ℝ ¯ = [ − ∞ , + ∞ ] \overline{\mathbb{R}}=[-\infty,+\infty] that is compact, path-connected, sober, US (uniquely sequential), and not KC (kompacts closed)—the first compact path-connected space known to separate US from KC (see Remark 1.3 for a systematic verification against the pi-Base database [ 17 ] ). In the Clontz hierarchy [ 2 ] , ERI is k 2 k_{2} -Hausdorff but not weakly Hausdorff. The construction generalizes to a Filter-Modified Quotient (FMQ) framework that produces US-not-KC spaces from any compact Hausdorff base without isolated points. A modifier spectrum identifies an optimal “US zone,” and an extended rigidity analysis shows that the hierarchy level k 2 ​ H k_{2}\mathrm{H} -not- wH \mathrm{wH} is preserved under arbitrary closed nowhere-dense collapse sets, iterated FMQ, and products—with first-countability of the base as the precise frontier for potential new levels. MSC 2020: 54A20, 54B15, 54D10, 54D25, 54D30, 54D55, 54G20. Keywords: US space, KC space, filter-modified quotient, admissible modifier, density condition, Wilansky hierarchy, k_{2} -Hausdorff, tightness, sobriety, infinite collapse set, iterated quotient. 1 Introduction 1.1 The Wilansky hierarchy The study of separation axioms strictly between T_{1} and T_{2} (Hausdorff) was initiated by Wilansky [ 1 ] , who introduced the following properties for a topological space X : Definition 1.1 (Wilansky [ 1 ] ) . (i) X is a US-space (uniquely sequential) if every convergent sequence in X has a unique limit. (ii) X is a KC-space (kompacts closed) if every compact subset of X is closed. The implications T_{2}\;\Longrightarrow\;\mathrm{KC}\;\Longrightarrow\;\mathrm{US}\;\Longrightarrow\;T_{1} (1) are all strict [ 1 ] ; see also [ 16 ] . A refined hierarchy with additional intermediate axioms has been developed by Clontz [ 2 ] : T_{2}\;\Rightarrow\;\mathrm{k_{1}H}\;\Rightarrow\;\mathrm{KC}\;\Rightarrow\;\mathrm{wH}\;\Rightarrow\;\mathrm{k_{2}H}\;\Rightarrow\;\mathrm{US}\;\Rightarrow\;T_{1}, (2) where a space is weakly Hausdorff (wH) if every continuous image of a compact Hausdorff space is closed, and k_{2} -Hausdorff ( k_{2} H) if for every continuous f\colon K\to X with K compact Hausdorff, the kernel \{(a,b)\in K\times K:f(a)=f(b)\} is closed in K\times K [ 12 ] (see Section 7 for the full treatment). The role of first-countability is clarified by the classical equivalence: Fact 1.2 (Folklore; see e.g. [ 5 , p. 60] ) . A first-countable space is Hausdorff if and only if it is US. Thus in first-countable spaces, the four levels of ( 1 ) collapse to two ( T_{1} and T_{2} ), and only in the absence of first-countability can US and T_{2} genuinely separate. 1.2 Known examples Several examples illustrate the separation between US and T_{2} : • The cocountable topology on an uncountable set is T_{1} and KC (hence US), but neither T_{2} nor compact (it is Lindelöf; see [ 9 ] , Ex. 20). Its sequential structure is trivial: the only convergent sequences are the eventually constant ones. • Van Douwen’s example [ 3 ] is a countable, compact, Fréchet–Urysohn, US space that is anti-Hausdorff (no two distinct points can be separated by disjoint open sets). By Künzi and van der Zypen [ 4 ] , every Fréchet US-space is KC, so van Douwen’s space is also KC. The construction uses maximal almost disjoint (MAD) families and is highly non-constructive. (The sobriety of Van Douwen’s space appears to be open; see Open Problem 14.2 .) • The line with two origins (LTO) is T_{1} and first-countable but not US: the sequence 1/n converges to both origins. Three compact US-not-KC examples appear in the literature: • The product \mathbb{Q}^{\ast}\times\mathbb{Q}^{\ast} of two copies of the one-point compactification of the rationals; it is weakly Hausdorff but not KC [ 2 ] . • The ordinal space \omega_{1}+1 with doubled endpoint; US but not k_{2} -Hausdorff [ 2 ] . • The one-point compactification of the Arens–Fort space; US but not weakly Hausdorff [ 2 ] . None of these is path-connected. 1.3 Contribution We introduce the Extended Real Line with Reentry (ERI), a compact quotient space arising from an elementary density condition, and prove: (1) The ERI example. ERI is compact, path-connected, sober, US and not KC—the first compact path-connected space known to separate US from KC. It is k_{2} -Hausdorff but not weakly Hausdorff (Theorem 5.1 , Theorems 5.2 , 7.5 , Proposition 8.1 , Theorem 8.5 ), placing it precisely in the Clontz hierarchy [ 2 ] . The failure of first-countability at \ast is the exact mechanism enabling US without T_{2} (Corollary 5.6 ), and the coexistence t(\ast)=\aleph_{0} with \chi(\ast)\geq\aleph_{1} makes ERI a natural example where countable tightness does not imply sequentiality. (2) FMQ framework and modifier spectrum. The construction generalizes to a Filter-Modified Quotient (FMQ) framework producing US-not-KC spaces from any compact Hausdorff base without isolated points (Section 9 ). A modifier spectrum (Section 10 ) organizes five natural modifiers into three qualitative regimes; the density modifier \mathcal{D}_{Y} is optimal (Section 11 ), and all modifiers in the US zone occupy the same Clontz level (Theorem 10.9 ). (3) Abstract US criterion. The US property is characterized by a single absorption condition on complements of closed countable sets (Theorem 11.3 ). (4) Extended rigidity. US and k_{2} H extend to arbitrary closed nowhere-dense collapse sets (Theorem 13.1 ), iterated FMQ absorbs into multi-point collapse (Proposition 13.5 ), and products preserve US and k_{2} H (Proposition 13.7 ). The precise frontier for potential new hierarchy levels is identified at non-first-countable base spaces. While compact US-not-KC spaces are known (see § 1.2 above), ERI is distinguished by the combination of path-connectedness, sobriety, constructive explicitness, a complete convergence criterion (Proposition 4.11 ), and a transparent mechanism: a single density condition on neighborhoods of \ast is responsible for all non-Hausdorff phenomena. Remark 1.3 (Novelty verification) . The claim that ERI is the first compact path-connected US-not-KC space has been verified against the pi-Base database [ 17 ] (as of March 2026) as follows. A search for spaces satisfying “compact + US + \lnot KC” returns three entries: \mathbb{Q}^{\ast}\times\mathbb{Q}^{\ast} (totally disconnected), \omega_{1}{+}1 with doubled endpoint (totally disconnected), and the one-point compactification of the Arens–Fort space (totally disconnected). None of these is path-connected. The three known compact US-not-KC examples in the Clontz hierarchy [ 2 ] (see § 1.2 ) are likewise totally disconnected or zero-dimensional. Sections 2 – 5 develop the ERI example in full detail. Section 6 compares ERI with known examples. Section 7 proves the k_{2} -Hausdorff property. Section 8 locates ERI in the refined hierarchy. Section 9 introduces the FMQ framework and generalizes the construction. Section 10 develops the modifier spectrum; Section 11 establishes optimality and the abstract US criterion. Section 12 presents selected examples. Section 13 develops the extended rigidity analysis: infinite collapse sets, iterated FMQ, products, and the first-countability frontier. Section 14 collects open problems. 2 The ERI Construction 2.1 Definition and notation Definition 2.1 (ERI space) . Let \overline{\mathbb{R}}=[-\infty,+\infty] denote the extended real line with its standard order topology. Define the equivalence relation \sim on \overline{\mathbb{R}} whose sole non-singleton class is \{-\infty,0,+\infty\} , and let X_{0}:=\overline{\mathbb{R}}/{\sim} be the quotient set. Write q:\overline{\mathbb{R}}\to X_{0} for the projection, \ast:=q(-\infty)=q(0)=q(+\infty) for the collapsed point, and \hat{x}:=q(x) for all x\in\overline{\mathbb{R}} . The map

Read the complete text