AI Space Physics: Constitutive boundary semantics for open AI institutions

Oleg Romanchuk, Roman Bondar · 2026

Read AI Space Physics: Constitutive boundary semantics for open AI institutions by Oleg Romanchuk, Roman Bondar (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-03119.txt.

Introduction

Oleg Romanchuk and Roman Bondar propose a physics-style language for governing AI systems that act like institutions. Deployed agents now persist over time, hold state, call tools, and quietly widen their own future powers. Governance rules usually constrain decisions but leave the mechanics of crossing authority boundaries vague.

Their framework, AI Space Physics, models an AI institution with typed boundary channels and reach that stops at a defined horizon. A family of core laws demands complete witnessing of boundary events, no bypass around mediation, and atomic steps from judgment to effect. Every adjudication must also be reconstructable by replay. Second-order effects, where the institution expands its own structure, are treated separately. The aim is constitutive rules, not just policy slogans.

Catalog record

CREATOROleg Romanchuk, Roman Bondar
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE72325
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.03119

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

AI Space Physics: Constitutive boundary semantics for open AI institutions Oleg Romanchuk, Roman Bondar Abstract Abstract Agentic AI deployments increasingly behave as persistent institutions rather than one-shot inference endpoints: they accumulate state, invoke external tools, coordinate multiple runtimes, and modify their future authority surface over time. Existing governance language typically specifies decision-layer constraints but leaves the causal mechanics of boundary crossing underdefined — particularly for transitions that do not immediately change the external world yet expand what the institution can later do [ ref-saltzer1975protectioninformationcomputer ] , [ ref-lampson1973noteconfinementproblem ] . This paper introduces AI Space Physics as a constitutive semantics for open, self-expanding AI institutions. We define a minimal state model with typed boundary channels, horizon-limited reach semantics, and a membrane-witness discipline. The core law family ( P-1 , P-1a , P-1b , P-1c ) requires witness completeness, non-bypass mediation, atomic adjudication-to-effect transitions, and replayable reconstruction of adjudication class. We explicitly separate second-order effects into structural expansion ( \mathsf{SECOND\_T} ) and policy broadening ( \mathsf{SECOND\_P} ), and treat expansion transitions as governance-relevant even when immediate external deltas are zero. From this semantics we derive propositions on expansion detectability, external-task causation under exogenous hooks, finite-observer non-identifiability, and scarcity-continuation regimes under explicit continuation assumptions. We also introduce an operational design corollary ( H-1 ) linking risk-weighted expansion pressure to review bandwidth. The framework is implementation-independent: model checking and engineering artifacts provide validation evidence but do not define the theory itself [ ref-lamport1994temporallogicactions ] , [ ref-holzmann1997modelcheckerSPIN ] . The novelty claim is precise rather than expansive: this work does not introduce mediation as a concept; it reclassifies authority-surface expansion as a first-class boundary event with constitutive witness obligations. In this semantics, expansion without immediate commit remains adjudication-relevant. In this paper, Physics refers to constitutive transition semantics governing causal structure rather than empirical physical science. Open refers to externally coupled, channel-mediated, self-expanding institutions, not to any specific vendor or product. 1. Introduction Autonomous AI systems are increasingly deployed as long-lived, tool-using processes that observe, plan, and act through external interfaces across many iterative cycles and without per-step human triggering. In this regime, governance failures do not arise only from isolated “bad actions”; they also emerge from gradual capability accretion, topology growth, and policy-surface broadening that silently enlarges future external reach [ ref-schick2023ToolformerLanguageModels ] , [ ref-turner2023OptimalPoliciesTend ] . Recent agent-security benchmarks and deployment studies report that tool misuse, indirect prompt injection, and over-permissioned action chains remain common in realistic agent workflows [ ref-debenedetti2024AgentDojoDynamicEnvironment ] , [ ref-zhang2025AgentSecurityBench ] , [ ref-zou2025SecurityChallengesAI ] . Classical governance artifacts (constitutional constraints, policy texts, oversight workflows) are necessary but insufficient if they do not map onto a transition semantics that renders bypass paths impossible by construction. This mirrors established security principles: complete mediation is meaningful only when every security-relevant operation is routed through a non-bypassable control point, and confinement fails when any effective channel escapes that mediator [ ref-saltzer1975protectioninformationcomputer ] , [ ref-lampson1973noteconfinementproblem ] . Positioning in one sentence: this work provides transition semantics for institutional authority growth under horizon-limited admissibility. This physics layer complements prior analyses of epistemic warrant failures and organizational accountability in agent systems [ ref-romanchuk2026SemanticLaunderingAI ] , [ ref-romanchuk2026ResponsibilityVacuumOrganizational ] , and can be read as a mechanism layer aligned with operational governance frameworks [ ref-2021AIRiskManagement ] , [ ref-editorOWASPTop10 ] , [ ref-autio2024ArtificialIntelligenceRisk ] . Those frameworks are valuable for lifecycle risk management and control taxonomies, but they are not transition-semantics definitions of reach-set inclusion or authority-surface mass. 1.1 Problem Statement A system may produce no immediate external commit at step t and still increase its expected external influence at t+k by adding tools, privileges, runtime instances, or connectivity. If governance tracks only first-order effects, it can certify apparent compliance while the institution accumulates latent authority mass. In agentic deployments, this mismatch is structural rather than incidental, because tool and topology changes are routine operational moves, not rare anomalies [ ref-schick2023ToolformerLanguageModels ] . The required shift is to type boundary transitions by effect order, with constitutive invariants covering both direct commits and reach-expanding transitions. The objective is not full reconstruction of hidden internal cognition, but enforceable control over the boundary where external causation becomes real and auditable. Classical governance frameworks rarely formalize reach-set inclusion or authority-surface growth as typed transition objects. Here, expansion is reclassified as a boundary-relevant transition class with explicit adjudication and witness obligations, closing a structural blind spot in governance semantics. Operationally, expansion without immediate commit remains external-causation potential and must be governed as a boundary event. 1.2 Contributions This paper contributes six linked results. 1. A formal model for open AI institutions with typed channels, expansion-aware state, and explicit external projection. 2. A definitions layer for \mathsf{Cell} , \mathsf{Unit} , and \mathsf{Membrane} that aligns governance language with executable transition semantics. 3. A constitutive law family: • P-1 – Boundary Witness, • P-1a – Non-Bypass, • P-1b – Atomic Adjudication-to-Effect, • P-1c – Replayable Adjudication. 4. A proposition pack with explicit assumptions for external-task causation and scarcity-continuation regimes. 5. An operational design corollary ( H-1 ) connecting risk-weighted expansion pressure to review bandwidth. 6. A minimal worked scenario showing why \mathsf{SECOND\_T} must be adjudicated even when no \mathsf{FIRST} transition occurs. 1.3 Reader Map Section 2 defines notation and primitive objects. Section 3 defines system classes and transition regimes. Section 4 states constitutive laws. Section 5 states derived propositions plus one operational design corollary. Sections 6-8 discuss implications, scope conditions, and conclusions. Appendix A provides a compact notation table, Appendix B extends proof sketches, Appendix C maps the theory to engineering patterns (non-normative), and Appendix D gives an operational form for H-1 (non-normative). 1.4 Central Statement (Strong Governability Criterion) Central Statement . An AI institution is strongly governable only if every first-order and second-order external effect is mediated by a non-bypassable membrane and validated by atomic witness semantics ( \mathsf{Decide}\to\mathsf{Anchor}\to\mathsf{Effect} ), such that adjudication class is replay-reconstructable under declared policy and context assumptions. An architecture that permits externally effective transition paths outside this discipline may remain operable, but it is not governable in the strong sense defined here. Proposition 0 (Strong Governability, Necessary Conditions). If any of P-1a (Non-Bypass), P-1b (Atomic Adjudication-to-Effect), or P-1c (Replayable Adjudication) is violated on a boundary-relevant transition class, the institution is not strongly governable under this framework. Interpretation: strong governability is not a policy aspiration; it is a transition-semantics property requiring non-bypass mediation, temporal atomicity of adjudication-to-effect, and replayable witness semantics. 2. Preliminaries and Notation 2.1 Core Objects (Plain Language) Cell is the minimal autonomous compute entity capable of processing inputs, producing outputs, and interacting across a boundary. Unit is the operational runtime instance within an institution; it is bounded by capability, budget, policy, and witness discipline. Membrane is the adjudication surface that classifies boundary-relevant transitions, issues decisions ( \text{ALLOW}|\text{REJECT}|\text{QUARANTINE} ), and anchors corresponding witness records. These objects separate governance layers often conflated in practice: model cognition, runtime control, and externally effective execution. This separation is necessary because external safety depends on permitted transition classes across channels, not on internal narrative coherence [ ref-schneider2000Enforceablesecuritypolicies ] . 2.2 Core Objects (Formal) We now formalize the objects introduced informally. The objective is not ontological completeness, but minimal sufficiency for boundary-governance semantics. Typed carriers used throughout: \displaystyle\mathsf{Cell},\ \mathsf{Unit},\

Read the complete text