Nature abhors macroscopic superpositions

Filippus S. Roux · 2026

Read Nature abhors macroscopic superpositions by Filippus S. Roux (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-01811.txt.

Introduction

Filippus Roux argues that nature resists placing large masses in two places at once in this 2026 work. Quantum theory allows superpositions, where an object sits in a blend of two states at once. For heavy masses, such a blend could entangle with the geometry of spacetime itself.

Roux models the split mass as a Schrodinger cat state, the famed blend of two distinct states. Total energy of that state dips as a function of the gap between the two mass positions. That dip acts like a force that pushes back against forming the split in the first place. A broader form of the effect is then discussed in connection with the measurement problem. If the effect holds, gravity itself may help explain why big objects never show quantum splits.

Catalog record

CREATORFilippus S. Roux
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE21743
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.01811

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Nature abhors macroscopic superpositions Filippus S. Roux Abstract Superpositions of mass distributions can potentially lead to entanglement with the geometry of spacetime. Here we show that there exists a natural reluctance for macroscopic mass distributions to form such superpositions. The macroscopic superposition is modelled as a Schrödinger cat state. The reluctance manifests as a dip in the total energy of the Schrödinger cat state as a function of the separation distance between the terms in the superposition. The dip in the energy provides an opposing force preventing the formation of the superposition. A generalization of this phenomenon addressing the measurement problem is also discussed. Among physical scenarios involving both gravity and quantum physics, we are confronted with the question of how a superposition of massive objects, as shown in Fig. 1 , would affect the geometry of spacetime. Would such a superposition cause entanglement between its terms and the geometry of spacetime if these terms are heavy enough and spread far enough apart to affect the geometry differently via gravity? We never see such situations. Why not? The answer to these questions may significantly contribute to a fundamental understanding of the coexistence of gravity and quantum physics. Figure 1: The fiducial state of a mass distribution evolves by separating into a superposition of mass distributions located at two different positions. A different question that is somehow related to the previous questions is the so-called measurement problem Schlosshauer 2003 . According to our current understanding, a measurement device with two possible measurement outcomes evolves into a superposition of the two states associated with these outcomes Walls and Milburn 1994 . How does such a superposition lead to the single measurement outcome that we expect? To address these questions, some people presented proposals calling for the introduction of novel principles in physics that would prevent such superpositions. For example, it was proposed that there may be an instability mechanism Karolyhazy 1966 ; Diósi 1987 ; Diósi 1989 ; Penrose 1996 ; Penrose 2014 in which some of the terms of the superposition shown in Fig. 1 would decay at a time scale governed by the amount of action given by Planck’s constant. This idea was proposed in part to address the measurement problem. Here, we first focus on the issue of a superposition of mass distributions that can potentially become entangled with the geometry of spacetime. We also consider a possible mechanism that can prevent such superpositions from becoming entangled with the spacetime geometry, but instead of an instability mechanism (which would only kick in once the superposition has been produced), we consider a variational principle that would prevent superpositions from being formed in the first place. Such a variational principle can limit the spread of superpositions in a quantum state. The term “spread” represents a measure of the separation among the different terms in such a superposition of mass distributions. In the context of a possible entanglement with spacetime geometry, the spread represents the distances among the physical spacetime locations of the terms in the superposition of mass distributions. A variational principle is enforced by a quantity (an observable) that produces a varying landscape over the parameter space of the quantum state associated with a given object. The idea is that minima in the landscape of such a quantity would introduce a mechanism that limits the spread of a superposition. How would such a variational principle be incorporated into existing theories? One may expect that the quantity associated with such a variational principle would have to be included as an additional term in the theory if it is not already included. So, if a new term is required to implement the variational principle, it may lead to modifications of the theory’s predictions that may contradict previous observations. If such a variational principle does exist, there must be a reason why we have not seen such deviations yet. This issue would not occur if the quantity that is associated with such a variational principle already exists in the theory. As it turns out, the required variational mechanism is indeed manifested by the total energy of the superposition, which does not require any modification to the existing dynamics of any theory. The calculation of the energy in a quantum state is not too complicated. The only complication that we need to introduce in our calculations is the use of a functional approach that allows the required freedom in the parameterization of quantum states. To investigate such a variational principle, one also needs to provide a model for the superposition on which this variational principle should take effect. For the possible entanglement with spacetime, we expect to see this mechanism for a superposition of translated mass distributions. To model it, we consider a Schrödinger cat state Nielsen and Chuang 2000 where the terms represent oppositely translated mass distributions, each represented by the thermal state of a massive scalar field. Our calculation demonstrates that the total energy of a Schrödinger cat state has a minimum as a function of the separation distance close to the origin at zero separation. The minimum is located at smaller separation distances for larger numbers of particles in the state. The energy curve serves as a potential function producing a force that opposes any increase in the separation distance. Although this scenario is very simple, it has a profound implication. Macroscopic states have large numbers of particles leading to dips so close to the origin that their locations cannot be distinguished from those without superpositions. Moreover, the force opposing the formation of a superposition is so large that it becomes virtually impossible to produce superpositions with discernable spreads. This observation does not only explain why entanglement between mass distributions and the geometry of spacetime is not observed, but also provides a possible explanation why macroscopic measurements collapse to produce single measurement outcomes. We return to this possibility after we have discussed the calculation of the energy curves. While a Schrödinger cat state is the obvious choice for modeling a superposition of mass distributions, there are different ways to distinguish the different terms in the superposition. Often these terms are distinguished by different displacements as produced by displacement operators. However, displacement operators nominally affect the particle number degree of freedom. To obtain a superposition of mass distributions that can potentially become entangled with spacetime, we need to distinguish the terms by translations , which affect the spatial degrees of freedom. Such translations are accomplished by phase modulations of the parameter function of the state, requiring a phase operator. If a state is parameterized in the Fourier domain by a spectral function \zeta(\mathbf{k}) where \mathbf{k} is the wave vector, a translation is readily implemented by multiplying it with a linear phase factor \zeta(\mathbf{k})\rightarrow\exp(i\mathbf{x}_{0}\cdot\mathbf{k})\zeta(\mathbf{k}). (1) Here \mathbf{x}_{0} is the spatial translation vector. In what follows, we assume translation along the z -direction. We also need to decide what kind of state to employ as the fiducial state on which the translations are applied. A coherent state is often used in the definitions of Schrödinger cat states. However, any kind of state may serve as the fiducial state, depending on the nature of the physical scenario. Here, we consider a single-mode thermal state. It

Read the complete text