Sensitivity of Isotopic Fission Yields in Actinides to the Macroscopic Liquid-Drop Model: LSD vs ISOLDA

\firstname K. \lastname Pomorski, \firstname A. \lastname Augustyn, \firstname T. \lastname Cap, \firstname Y. J. \lastname Chen, \firstname M. \lastname Kowal \fnsep, \firstname B. \lastname Nerlo-Pomorska, \firstname M. \lastname Warda, \firstname Z. G. \lastname Xiao · 2026

Read Sensitivity of Isotopic Fission Yields in Actinides to the Macroscopic Liquid-Drop Model: LSD vs ISOLDA by \firstname K. \lastname Pomorski, \firstname A. \lastname Augustyn, \firstname T. \lastname Cap, \firstname Y. J. \lastname Chen, \firstname M. \lastname Kowal \fnsep, \firstname B. \lastname Nerlo-Pomorska, \firstname M. \lastname Warda, \firstname Z. G. \lastname Xiao (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-01794.txt.

Introduction

K. Pomorski, A. Augustyn, T. Cap, and colleagues test how a modeling choice shifts predicted fission yields. Their 2026 work compares two liquid-drop prescriptions for the bulk energy of atomic nuclei. The drop model treats a nucleus like a charged fluid drop, and small formula changes can move results.

Both prescriptions run on the same yield observables and the same fission reference case. One adds an explicit isospin term, tied to neutron-proton imbalance, in its volume and surface parts. The team tracks peak positions, widths, and tails of isotope yields for each element chain. Light and mid-weight fragments match well under both formulas, with near-identical peaks. Heavy chains diverge most, since their yield ridges feel isospin terms more. One formula fits the evaluated data slightly better on average, and the spread gauges model doubt.

Catalog record

CREATOR\firstname K. \lastname Pomorski, \firstname A. \lastname Augustyn, \firstname T. \lastname Cap, \firstname Y. J. \lastname Chen, \firstname M. \lastname Kowal \fnsep, \firstname B. \lastname Nerlo-Pomorska, \firstname M. \lastname Warda, \firstname Z. G. \lastname Xiao
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34902
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.01794

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Sensitivity of Isotopic Fission Yields in Actinides to the Macroscopic Liquid-Drop Model: LSD vs ISOLDA \firstname K. \lastname Pomorski, \firstname A. \lastname Augustyn, \firstname T. \lastname Cap, \firstname Y. J. \lastname Chen, \firstname M. \lastname Kowal \fnsep, \firstname B. \lastname Nerlo-Pomorska, \firstname M. \lastname Warda, \firstname Z. G. \lastname Xiao Abstract The impact of the macroscopic liquid-drop prescription on isotope-resolved fission-fragment yields in the actinide region is assessed by comparing two alternative parameterizations: the Lublin–Strasbourg Drop (LSD) model and the ISOscalar Liquid Drop Approximation (ISOLDA). The two prescriptions differ primarily in the treatment of isospin dependence in the volume and surface terms; in ISOLDA, an explicit dependence on the isospin square T ⁡ ( T + 1 ) T(T+1) , where T = | N − Z | / 2 T=|N-Z|/2 , is introduced in both coefficients. Using an identical set of fragment-yield observables and the same experimental reference (fission of 250 Cf ∗ at low and high energies), the propagation of the macroscopic-energy choice into the predicted yields is quantified in terms of (i) the location of the most probable post-neutron isotopes along elemental chains, (ii) the widths and asymmetries of the isotopic distributions, and (iii) the population of neighboring nuclides on the distribution tails. A comparable description of the gross properties of the isotopic yield pattern is obtained with both prescriptions, particularly for light and intermediate fragments, where peak positions and near-maximum curvatures are reproduced similarly. The most discriminating differences are found for heavy-fragment chains, for which the ridge location and isotopic centroids are rendered more sensitive to macroscopic isospin terms. Overall, a closer average agreement with the evaluated data is obtained with LSD, while the LSD–ISOLDA spread is shown to provide a practical estimate of the macroscopic-model uncertainty in isotope-resolved yields. 1 Introduction High-resolution isotopic fission-fragment yields, Y(Z,N) , are among the most challenging fission observables to measure experimentally. Their measurement requires an unambiguous, event-by-event determination of both the atomic number Z and neutron number N for fast-moving fragments, which severely limits the number of available datasets. As a result, only a small set of dedicated experiments has provided isotope-resolved yields with sufficient precision to constrain theory. In particular, inverse-kinematics measurements combined with high-resolution magnetic spectrometry at advanced facilities such as SOFIA Pellereau2017 and VAMOS Ramos2018 ; Ramos2019PRL239U have opened the possibility of mapping detailed isotopic distributions over broad regions of the fission-fragment chart. From the theoretical standpoint, reproducing isotope-resolved yields is equally demanding. A quantitative description is required to account simultaneously for the dissipative collective descent from saddle to scission and for the subsequent statistical de-excitation of the nascent fragments, while maintaining internal consistency among correlated observables such as mass and charge yields, total kinetic energy (TKE), and prompt-neutron multiplicity. In practice, the isotopic landscape provides one of the most stringent benchmarks for fission modeling because it probes not only the gross mass partition but also the fine balance between charge polarization, neutron sharing at scission, and post-scission evaporation. To address these challenges, a wide spectrum of theoretical approaches has been developed, ranging from semi-empirical systematics to fully microscopic time-dependent frameworks. For instance, the GEF model Schmidt2016 has been shown to reproduce a broad range of global fission observables relevant to applications, whereas microscopic descriptions such as the Time-Dependent Generator Coordinate Method (TDGCM) Regnier2016 ; Verriere2021 provide a formally rigorous treatment rooted in effective nucleon–nucleon interactions, albeit at the price of substantial computational cost. In this context, stochastic transport models based on Langevin equations Aritomo2014 ; Usang2019 have emerged as a practical compromise, offering a physically motivated description of dissipative saddle-to-scission dynamics and a computational efficiency that makes systematic isotope-resolved studies feasible. In the present work, isotope-resolved yields are calculated within a four-dimensional Langevin-plus-Master-Equation (4D LM) framework Pomorski2024LM , in which the dissipative collective evolution is propagated in a multidimensional deformation space and the correlated post-scission de-excitation of primary fragments is treated statistically. The focus is placed on the sensitivity of the calculated isotopic patterns to the macroscopic sector of the underlying macroscopic–microscopic energy functional. Specifically, two alternative macroscopic prescriptions are considered: the Lublin–Strasbourg Drop (LSD) model PomorskiDudek2003LSD and the iso-scalar liquid-drop approximation (ISOLDA) PomorskiXiao2025ISOLDA . The results obtained with the LSD-based implementation are highly encouraging: across a broad set of actinide cases, including spontaneous fission as well as neutron-induced fission at thermal and 14-MeV energies, the calculated isotope-resolved post-neutron yields reproduce the dominant ridge centroids and the near-maximum “core” shapes of the Ba and Xe chains with good fidelity Pomorski2024LM ; Pomorski2023PRC107 . This level of agreement provides strong validation of the present 4D LM framework and motivates a more stringent, systematic benchmark against evaluated experimental reference data compiled in the National Nuclear Data Center (NNDC) database at Brookhaven National Laboratory NNDC . At the same time, the comparison reveals a notable challenge Pomorski2024LM : for the highly excited 250 Cf system ( E^{*}=46 MeV, L=20\hbar ) the agreement for isotopic yields deteriorates markedly, even though the corresponding mass distributions remain described reasonably well. This contrast suggests that the discrepancy is not simply a failure of the gross mass partition but rather reflects more subtle deficiencies in the isotope-forming stage. To help isolate the origin of these deviations, we therefore repeat the isotope-resolved calculations using the newly developed isoscalar liquid-drop model ISOLDA PomorskiXiao2025ISOLDA and perform a dedicated LSD–ISOLDA comparison, with the specific aim of quantifying the sensitivity to the macroscopic part and identifying the regimes where both macroscopic prescriptions converge versus those where the remaining shortcomings must originate elsewhere (e.g., in the fluctuation strength and its coupling to de-excitation). 2 Methodology The fission process is governed by a strongly dissipative large-amplitude collective motion in which the collective descent from saddle to scission is coupled to intrinsic degrees of freedom and accompanied by stochastic fluctuations. Within this physical picture, fragment observables emerge from an ensemble of trajectories whose drift is controlled by the thermodynamic driving potential, while their dispersion reflects the fluctuation–dissipation balance. In the present work, this dissipative dynamics is described within the four-dimensional Langevin-plus-Master-Equation framework, which enables a unified treatment of collective transport, pre-scission energy dissipation, and correlated post-scission de-excitation in actinide fission, including multi-chance fission following successive pre-fission neutron emissions Pomorski2024LM . Accordingly, the collective evolution is propagated by the multidimensional Langevin equations written for generalized collective coordinates \vec{q}=\{q_{i}\} and conjugate momenta \vec{p}=\{p_{i}\} as \dot{q}_{i}=\sum_{j}\big[{\cal M}^{-1}(\vec{q}\,)\big]_{ij}\,p_{j}, (1) \displaystyle\dot{p}_{i}={} \displaystyle-\frac{1}{2}\sum_{j,k}\frac{\partial\big[{\cal M}^{-1}(\vec{q}\,)\big]_{jk}}{\partial q_{i}}\,p_{j}p_{k}-\frac{\partial V(\vec{q}\,)}{\partial q_{i}} (2) \displaystyle-\sum_{j,k}\gamma_{ij}(\vec{q}\,)\big[{\cal M}^{-1}(\vec{q}\,)\big]_{jk}\,p_{k}+{\cal F}_{i}(t)\,, where {\cal M}(\vec{q}\,) denotes the collective inertia tensor, \gamma(\vec{q}\,) the friction tensor, V(\vec{q}\,) the thermodynamic driving potential, and {\cal F}_{i}(t) a stochastic force. In the present implementation, {\cal M} and \gamma are evaluated within the irrotational-flow and wall-type approximations, respectively, following Ref. Bartel2019CPC . The fluctuation strength is coupled to dissipation in the standard manner, including the effective-temperature treatment of quantum fluctuations PomorskiHofmann1981 . The resulting set of stochastic differential equations is used to generate an ensemble of saddle-to-scission trajectories whose termination defines a scission-point event sample. The generalized coordinate vector is taken as \vec{q}=(c,a_{3},a_{4},\eta) and is defined within the Fourier-over-Spheroid (FoS) shape family Pomorski2023PRC107 ; PomorskiNerlo2023FoSNonax . Here c controls elongation, a_{3} encodes left–right (mass) asymmetry, a_{4} governs necking, and \eta parametrizes non-axiality through elliptical transverse cross sections, thereby generalizing the role of the classical

Read the complete text