Integrating LTL Constraints into PPO for Safe Reinforcement Learning

Maifang Zhang, Hang Yu, Qian Zuo, Cheng Wang, Vaishak Belle, Fengxiang He · 2026

Read Integrating LTL Constraints into PPO for Safe Reinforcement Learning by Maifang Zhang, Hang Yu, Qian Zuo, Cheng Wang, Vaishak Belle, Fengxiang He (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-01292.txt.

Introduction

Zhang and five colleagues propose PPO-LTL, a framework adding safety constraints written in linear temporal logic to PPO for safe RL. Büchi automata watch for breaks of the logic constraints, and a logic-to-cost step turns them into penalty signals that guide policy learning through the Lagrangian scheme. Tests on the Zones and CARLA worlds show PPO-LTL always cuts safety breaks while keeping strong scores against state-of-the-art methods.

Catalog record

CREATORMaifang Zhang, Hang Yu, Qian Zuo, Cheng Wang, Vaishak Belle, Fengxiang He
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45625
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.01292

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Integrating LTL Constraints into PPO for Safe Reinforcement Learning Maifang Zhang, Hang Yu, Qian Zuo, Cheng Wang, Vaishak Belle, Fengxiang He Abstract This paper proposes Proximal Policy Optimization with Linear Temporal Logic Constraints (PPO-LTL), a framework that integrates safety constraints written in LTL into PPO for safe reinforcement learning. LTL constraints offer rigorous representations of complex safety requirements, such as regulations that broadly exist in robotics, enabling systematic monitoring of safety requirements. Violations against LTL constraints are monitored by limit-deterministic Büchi automata, and then translated by a logic-to-cost mechanism into penalty signals. The signals are further employed for guiding the policy optimization via the Lagrangian scheme. Extensive experiments on the Zones and CARLA environments show that our PPO-LTL can consistently reduce safety violations, while maintaining competitive performance, against the state-of-the-art methods. The code is at https://github.com/EVIEHub/PPO-LTL . I Introduction Reinforcement Learning (RL) has achieved remarkable success across diverse domains, including robotics [ 24 ] . In RL, Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) is a widely adopted on-policy method, which constrains policy updates with a clipped surrogate objective, striking a balance between exploration and stability [ 22 ] . Deploying RL in safety-critical environments remains highly challenging, where violations against safety constraints can lead to catastrophic outcomes. Safe RL has been comprehensively reviewed and addresses this challenge in the framework of constrained optimization, where the agent seeks to maximize reward whilst bounding cumulative safety costs [ 11 ] . Within this family, constrained PPO via the Lagrangian scheme (PPO-Lagrangian) has emerged as a major approach [ 21 ] . Despite these advances, a critical limitation remains: the constraints need to be written in analytic inequalities of the agent’s state and action. This is not compatible with a large family of abstract safety constraints, such as regulations that broadly exist in robotics. For example, the British Highway Code regulates driving behavior [ 26 ] , which is difficult to translate to the aforementioned inequalities. This calls for machine-computable and principled safety specifications within the RL training process. To address this issue, we propose Proximal Policy Optimization with Linear Temporal Logic Constraints (PPO-LTL), a novel method that represents abstract constraints in LTL [ 18 , 4 ] , and embeds these constraints into PPO agents. LTL provides a rigorous and machine-verifiable tool to encode temporal properties, such as “always avoid unsafe states,” “eventually reach a goal,”, and regulatory rules, like “stop at a red light until it turns green,” as logic specifications. We design a logic-to-cost mechanism that systematically translates violations of temporal logic constraints into cost signals that guide policy learning. This mechanism can be instantiated in a wide range of environments, serving as a plug-and-play solution. Each LTL specification is first compiled into an \omega -automaton, typically a limit-deterministic Büchi automaton (LDBA) [ 28 , 23 ] . The automaton encodes the satisfaction conditions of the temporal property by defining a finite set of states and labeled transitions based on atomic propositions. During execution, it evolves synchronously with the agent-environment interaction, effectively acting as a runtime monitor that checks whether the agent’s trajectory satisfies the specification. When a violation occurs, the monitor emits a cost signal to reflect the severity of the violation, determined by a set of pre-defined weights associated with different safety rules. These violation costs are aggregated over time and integrated into the safe reinforcement learning framework. The resulting signals are then combined with policy optimization via the Lagrangian scheme, allowing the agent to optimize task performance while ensuring that safety requirements are satisfied. Unlike handcrafted penalties, this approach provides a principled, generalizable, and modular way to encode high-level safety requirements into the learning process. We provide a rigorous theoretical analysis of our approach. We formulate PPO-LTL as an inexact projected primal–dual method driven by biased stochastic gradient oracles. Specifically, we view two usual components in PPO, clipped surrogate objective and finite-epoch minibatch updates, as mechanisms that yield biased stochastic approximations to the true Lagrangian gradient. We then prove an ergodic stationarity guarantee for the projected primal-dual dynamics that underpin PPO-LTL. This result shows that despite the biased and noisy gradient estimates, our algorithm consistently converges to a neighborhood of a stationary point. Practically, it means PPO-LTL can stably reduce constraint violations without relying on exact gradient evaluations, highlighting its robustness in challenging settings such as autonomous driving. We conduct comprehensive experiments to evaluate PPO-LTL across diverse benchmark environments, including ZonesEnv (continuous control with logical regions) [ 15 ] and CARLA (autonomous driving simulator) [ 10 ] . Our method is compared against PPO [ 22 ] , as the baseline, and a range of state-of-the-art safe RL methods, including TIRL-PPO, TIRL-SAC [ 12 ] , PPO-Mask, PPO-Shielding [ 2 , 14 ] , and PPO-Lagrangian. The empirical results demonstrate consistent reductions in safety violations while maintaining competitive task performance. Extensive ablation study and sensitivity analysis further verify our contributions. II Related Work Shielding. Shielding approaches enforce safety by preempting unsafe actions online using verified policies or model-checking over abstract models [ 2 , 14 ] . This yields binary-safe behavior with strong formal guarantees but can restrict exploration and lead to non-stationary data distributions. In contrast, soft-integration methods map violations into cost signals through a logic-to-cost mechanism, providing dense feedback that is compatible with gradient-based optimization and constrained MDP solvers [ 21 , 3 ] . Using LTL monitors to emit per-rule costs further enables modular handling of multiple constraints, compositional reasoning across specifications, and straightforward scalability to large rule sets [ 4 , 6 ] . Compared with runtime action filtering strategies, PPO-LTL incorporates temporal logic constraints directly within the policy optimization loop, providing dense feedback signals that support learning under complex temporal requirements. Logic tools in RL. Beyond LTL, other formal logics have also been explored in reinforcement learning. Signal Temporal Logic (STL) [ 17 ] extends temporal reasoning to real-valued signals, while deontic logics [ 7 ] express normative concepts like obligations and permissions. These approaches offer richer expressiveness but often come with higher computational costs and task-specific design complexity, limiting their practicality. Probabilistic Logic Programming (PLP) [ 9 ] has also been introduced to model uncertainty in logical reasoning, allowing agents to encode probabilistic constraints. In contrast, LTL achieves a balance: it is lightweight, easy to compile into automata, and sufficient to capture temporal safety properties [ 8 ] . Recent work [ 19 ] applies LTL in a model-based driving framework via product MDPs and linear programming for policy synthesis, while our method focuses on learning-based constrained optimization rather than model-based synthesis. Fig. 1 : PPO-LTL: environment states are labeled with atomic propositions, monitored by LTL checkers to generate constraint costs, which are integrated with task rewards for policy optimization. III Preliminaries Markov Decision Process (MDP). We consider a discounted constrained MDP \mathcal{M}=(\mathcal{S},\mathcal{A},P,r,c,\mu,\gamma) , where \mathcal{S} and \mathcal{A} denote the state and action spaces, respectively, P(s^{\prime}|s,a) represents the transition probability of moving from state s to state s^{\prime} given action a , r:(s,a)\rightarrow[0,R_{\text{max}}] is the reward function, c:(s,a)\rightarrow[0,C_{\text{max}}] is the aggregated cost c(s,a)=\sum_{i=1}^{K}w_{i}c^{(i)}(s,a) where w_{i} are fixed weights for i\in[K] , \mu is the initial-state distribution, and \gamma\in(0,1) is the discount factor controlling how much the agent values future rewards. A policy \pi:\mathcal{S}\rightarrow\mathcal{P}(\mathcal{A})

Read the complete text