A new order for ideal sequential compactness
Adam Kwela, Dorota Lesner · 2026
Read A new order for ideal sequential compactness by Adam Kwela, Dorota Lesner (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-01114.txt.
Introduction
Kwela and Lesner introduce a new preorder for ideal sequential compactness, comparing ideals by whether Bolzano-Weierstrass-type spaces transfer between them. Their main result shows that under the continuum hypothesis, the transfer reverses for F-sigma ideals, and they compare the new order with the Katětov order across well-known ideals including van der Waerden's. As a consequence, they settle two open questions about that ideal's spaces versus sequentially compact spaces.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Adam Kwela, Dorota Lesner |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 58964 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.01114
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A new order for ideal sequential compactness Adam Kwela, Dorota Lesner Abstract . Let ℐ \mathcal{I} be an ideal on ω \omega and X X be a topological space. A sequence ( x n ) n ∈ ω (x_{n})_{n\in\omega} in X X is ℐ \mathcal{I} -convergent if there is x ∈ X x\in X such that { n ∈ ω : x n ∉ U } ∈ ℐ \{n\in\omega:x_{n}\notin U\}\in\mathcal{I} for every open neighborhood U U of x x . We examine the following variant of sequential compactness associated with ℐ \mathcal{I} : X X is BW ( ℐ ) \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) if for every sequence ( x n ) n ∈ ω (x_{n})_{n\in\omega} in X X there is A ∉ ℐ A\notin\mathcal{I} such that ( x n ) n ∈ A (x_{n})_{n\in A} is ℐ \mathcal{I} -convergent. We introduce a new preorder on ideals, denoted ≤ B W \leq_{BW} , such that ℐ ≤ B W 𝒥 \mathcal{I}\leq_{BW}\mathcal{J} implies that every BW ( 𝒥 ) \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{J}) space is BW ( ℐ ) \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) . Our main result states that under CH the above implication can be reversed in the case of 𝐅 σ \mathbf{F_{\sigma}} ideals ℐ \mathcal{I} and 𝒥 \mathcal{J} . We compare ≤ B W \leq_{BW} with the Katětov order and study the relation ≤ B W \leq_{BW} among some well-known ideals (e.g. the van der Waerden ideal 𝒲 \mathcal{W} consisting of all subsets of ω \omega that do not contain arbitrary long finite arithmetic progressions). As a consequence, we answer two open questions posed by Filipów and Tryba in [Top. App. 178 (2014), 438–452] concerning comparison of BW ( 𝒲 ) \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{W}) with the class of sequentially compact spaces. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary: 03E05. Secondary: 03E35, 03E15. 1. Introduction For the necessary definitions and notations, see Section 2 . Let \mathcal{I} be an ideal on \omega and A\in\mathcal{I}^{+} . A sequence (x_{n})_{n\in A} in a topological space X is said to be \mathcal{I} -convergent, if there is x\in X such that \{n\in A:x_{n}\notin U\}\in\mathcal{I} for every open neighborhood U of x . Definition 1.1 . Let \mathcal{I} be an ideal on \omega . A topological space X has the \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) property if for every sequence (x_{n})_{n\in\omega} in X there is A\in\mathcal{I}^{+} such that (x_{n})_{n\in A} is \mathcal{I} -convergent. In this case we briefly write X\in\mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) (however, formally \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) is a class of topological spaces, not a set). Obviously, \mathrm{BW}(\mathrm{Fin}) is the class of sequentially compact spaces ( \mathrm{Fin} denotes the ideal consisting of all finite subsets of \omega ). For this reason, the classes \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) can be viewed as generalizations of sequential compactness. The aim of this paper is to study inclusions between the classes \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) . The case of [0,1] is of particular interest, since the famous Bolzano-Weierstrass theorem states that the space [0,1] is sequentially compact, i.e., that [0,1]\in\mathrm{BW}(\mathrm{Fin}) . Deep studies of ideals satisfying [0,1]\in\mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) have been performed by Filipów, Mrożek, Recław and Szuca in [ 6 ] , where it is shown, among others, that [0,1]\in\mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) for every \mathbf{F_{\sigma}} ideal \mathcal{I} . However, there are \mathbf{F_{\sigma\delta}} ideals \mathcal{I} with [0,1]\notin\mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) (see [ 15 ] ). The classes \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) have been studied previously. Below we present a short overview of the known results. Bernstein showed in [ 1 , Theorem 3.3] that every compact space has the \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) property for every maximal ideal \mathcal{I} . In particular, for maximal ideals \mathcal{I} it is possible to find a space with the \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) property that is not sequentially compact. If \mathcal{I} is an \mathbf{F_{\sigma}} ideal then the class \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) includes all compact metric spaces, all compact linearly ordered topological spaces and every limit ordinal of uncountable cofinality considered with the order topology ( [ 11 , Corollary 5.7] ; see also [ 12 , theorem 1.1] ). There is also another way of generalizing sequential compactness with the aid of ideals on \omega . Definition 1.2 . Let \mathcal{I} be an ideal on \omega . A topological space X has the \mathrm{FinBW}(\mathcal{I}) property if for every sequence (x_{n})_{n\in\omega} of elements of X there is A\in\mathcal{I}^{+} such that (x_{n})_{n\in A} is convergent (in the usual sense). In contrast to \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) , each \mathrm{FinBW}(\mathcal{I}) is a subclass of sequentially compact spaces. Studies of such spaces have been initiated by Kojman in [ 20 ] , where he considered the class \mathrm{FinBW}(\mathcal{W}) given by the van der Waerden ideal \mathcal{W} consisting all subsets of \omega that do not contain arbitrary long finite arithmetic progressions. Later Kojman and Shelah in [ 19 ] performed under CH the first construction of a Mrówka space with the \mathrm{FinBW}(\mathcal{W}) property. This construction inspired a long list of papers devoted to studies of the classes \mathrm{FinBW}(\mathcal{I}) – see for instance [ 13 , 7 , 12 , 14 , 17 , 22 , 24 ] . It is known that in general \mathcal{I}\leq_{K}\mathcal{J} implies \mathrm{FinBW}(\mathcal{J})\subseteq\mathrm{FinBW}(\mathcal{I}) , where \leq_{K} denotes the Katětov order on ideals (see [ 24 , Corollary 10.2] ; for the definition of \leq_{K} see Section 2 ). Recently, the article [ 24 ] established a deeper connection of the classes \mathrm{FinBW}(\mathcal{I}) with the Katětov order. Namely, under CH the following holds for all \mathbf{G_{\delta\sigma\delta}} ideals \mathcal{I} and \mathcal{J} : \mathcal{I}\leq_{K}\mathcal{J}\ \iff\ \mathrm{FinBW}(\mathcal{J})\subseteq\mathrm{FinBW}(\mathcal{I}). The space constructed in the proof (in order to show the implication \mathcal{I}\not\leq_{K}\mathcal{J}\ \implies\ \mathrm{FinBW}(\mathcal{J})\not\subseteq\mathrm{FinBW}(\mathcal{I}) ) is based on ideas developed by Kojman and Shelah in [ 19 ] . Inspired by the above result, in this paper we introduce a new order on ideals, denoted \leq_{BW} , show that in general \mathcal{I}\leq_{BW}\mathcal{J} implies \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{J})\subseteq\mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) (see Theorem 3.3 ), while in the realm of \mathbf{F_{\sigma}} ideals \mathcal{I} and \mathcal{J} the following holds under CH: \mathcal{I}\leq_{BW}\mathcal{J}\ \iff\ \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{J})\subseteq\mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) (see Corollary 5.3 ). It is worth mentioning that the space constructed in our proof (showing that \mathcal{I}\not\leq_{BW}\mathcal{J}\ \implies\ \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{J})\not\subseteq\mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{I}) ) is completely different from the ones based on Kojman’s and Shelah’s proof from [ 19 ] . Additionally, we examine basic properties of \leq_{BW} (cf. Section 3 ), compare it with the Katětov order (Proposition 3.2 (d) and Remark 4.6 ) and study the relation \leq_{BW} among some well-known ideals (Section 4 ). In particular, we answer two open questions posed by Filipów and Tryba in [ 12 , Questions 2 and 3] by proving that \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{W}) is a subclass of sequentially compact spaces, while under CH there is a sequentially compact space without the \mathrm{BW}(\mathcal{W}) property (see Corollaries 4.2 (a) and 5.4 (a)). 2. Preliminaries 2.1. Basics about ideals A family \mathcal{I} of subsets of a set M is called an ideal on M if it is closed under taking subsets and finite unions of its elements. Additionally, we assume that ideals are proper ( \neq\mathcal{P}(M) ) and that all finite subsets of M belong to \mathcal{I} . Note that M=\bigcup\mathcal{I} . In this paper we only consider ideals on countable sets. For an ideal \mathcal{I} we denote by \mathcal{I}^{+}=\{A\subseteq\bigcup\mathcal{I}:A\notin\mathcal{I}\} the family of all \mathcal{I} -positive sets. If A\in\mathcal{I}^{+} , then the restriction of \mathcal{I} to A is given by \mathcal{I}|A=\mathcal{I}\cap\mathcal{P}(A) . It is an ideal on A . An ideal on a set M is called Borel ( \mathbf{F_{\sigma}} , etc.)