Consensus and fragmentation in academic publication preferences
Ian Van Buskirk, Marilena Hohmann, Ekaterina Landgren, Johan Ugander, Aaron Clauset, Daniel B. Larremore · 2026
Read Consensus and fragmentation in academic publication preferences by Ian Van Buskirk, Marilena Hohmann, Ekaterina Landgren, Johan Ugander, Aaron Clauset, Daniel B. Larremore (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2603-00807.txt.
Introduction
Van Buskirk and five colleagues ask whether fields have settled the venue problem in similar ways. A survey of 3,510 US tenure track faculty, with 163,002 pairwise votes across 8,044 venues, finds fields span a wide accord spectrum. Economics, Chemistry, and Physics agree strongly on elite venues, while Computer Science and Engineering split across hundreds of outlets. Within fields, tastes track school rank and gender, and scholars realise own tastes more than field accord.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ian Van Buskirk, Marilena Hohmann, Ekaterina Landgren, Johan Ugander, Aaron Clauset, Daniel B. Larremore |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 91167 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.00807
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Consensus and fragmentation in academic publication preferences Ian Van Buskirk, Marilena Hohmann, Ekaterina Landgren, Johan Ugander, Aaron Clauset, Daniel B. Larremore Abstract Academic publishing requires solving a collective coordination problem: among thousands of possible publication venues, which deserve a community’s attention? A clear consensus helps scholars allocate attention, match submissions to appropriate outlets, and evaluate scholars for hiring and promotion. Yet preferences are not centrally coordinated—they emerge within each field over time. Here we ask whether all fields have arrived at similar solutions to this coordination problem, and whether preferences vary systematically with individual characteristics. Using an adaptive survey of 3,510 US tenure-track faculty yielding 163,002 pairwise comparisons across 8,044 venues, we show that fields occupy a wide spectrum of coordination. Economics, Chemistry, and Physics exhibit strong consensus, with respondents agreeing on elite venues and accurately predicting one another’s choices. Computer Science and Engineering show fragmented preferences distributed across hundreds of outlets with minimal overlap. Within fields, preferences correlate with institutional prestige—faculty at elite institutions prefer higher-ranked venues—and with gender, as men prefer higher-ranked venues than women even after accounting for prestige and career stage. Scholars realize their personal preferences more successfully than their respective fields’ consensus preferences, indicating that heterogeneity, not just selective hierarchy, shapes publishing outcomes. Journal Impact Factors explain only 64% of preference choices, systematically undervaluing what fields actually prefer. These results quantify how publication preferences vary across the structural diversity of academic fields. Introduction Across the academic enterprise, millions of papers are published each year, and authors continuously face questions of where, among thousands of possible venues, they would prefer for their work to appear. Across surveys and disciplines, the two factors most consistently cited as driving these preferences are a venue’s reputation or prominence and its topical scope 28 ; 34 ; 29 , though researchers also weigh review quality, open access options, speed of review, and publication fees 29 ; 44 ; 45 . With sufficient consensus on these dimensions, a community’s aggregated preferences reflect a collective solution to an attention allocation problem. By transforming an intractable individual decision (which of thousands of papers deserve my attention?) into a manageable collective one (which venues does our community hold in high regard?), a clear consensus enables communities to estimate the scope and potential importance of articles from venue alone, to match submissions to appropriate outlets, and—in some fields and at some institutions—to make hiring and promotion decisions based on the venues on a scholar’s curriculum vitae 24 ; 16 ; 4 . On the other hand, deviations from any putative consensus represent fundamental disagreements about attention allocation, with the potential to undermine these coordinating benefits. A rich literature has studied publication preferences, typically one field at a time, using methods including citation analysis 15 ; 2 , expert surveys 31 ; 17 , and analysis of manuscript submission flows 6 ; 13 . This work has produced venue rankings across numerous fields—including economics 16 , marketing 33 , statistics 35 , medicine 30 , and AI 31 —and has shown that preferences correlate with respondents’ own publication records 17 ; 4 , that consensus varies across subfields within a discipline 35 ; 1 , and that citation-based metrics imperfectly capture stated preferences 31 ; 2 ; 30 . Yet because publication preferences are not centrally coordinated—they emerge and evolve independently in each field over time—these field-specific studies leave three important questions unanswered. First, have all fields arrived at similar levels of consensus in their publication preferences? Second, do preferences vary systematically with individual characteristics such as institutional prestige, career stage, or gender? And third, to what extent are scholars effective in realizing their preferences by publishing in preferred venues? To answer these questions, we surveyed 3,510 US tenure-track faculty using a three-stage adaptive survey (Materials and Methods). In the first stage, respondents named a top-tier venue that they would most like to publish in, which we refer to as aspirations . In the second stage, respondents assembled a set of venues they like to, hope to, or want to publish in—a consideration set . In the third stage, we confronted each respondent with a sequence of pairwise comparisons between venues from their consideration set to learn their publication preferences . Combined with professional and demographic information (field, institution, gender, academic title, and institutional prestige 40 ), these three data types—aspirations, consideration sets, and preferences—enable a field-by-field analysis of the structure of publication preferences across 13 academic fields. From these data, we define several key quantities. First, we named each field’s most common aspiration its flagship venue . Second, to measure the strength of consensus across consideration sets, we identified the three most commonly selected venues in each field and then measured the fraction of respondents who selected those venues. Third, we used each respondent’s pairwise venue comparisons to compute their individual rankings , and then computed a set of field-level rankings from the union of comparison data for respondents from each field. In total, our dataset comprises 163,002 pairwise comparisons among 8,044 venues. This study was approved by the University of Colorado IRB, and deidentified data and open-source code are available (Materials and Methods). Respondents to our survey do not constitute a representative sample of academia, yet we have reason to believe that their responses can nevertheless address our research questions. Our sample is restricted to tenure-track faculty at US PhD-granting institutions, and senior faculty, men, and those at more prestigious institutions responded at higher rates (SI Appendix). However, our analyses show no statistical differences in responses by academic title, and our sample contains sufficient representation across institutional prestige and gender to examine differences by these covariates. Results A spectrum of concentration and consensus Figure 1: Fields vary widely in the diversity of their consideration sets and consensus around common venues. (A) Venue accumulation curves show the growing number of unique venues among the combined consideration sets of an increasing number of respondents, sampled uniformly at random without replacement for each field and averaged over 100 realizations. Circles and labels indicate the total number of respondents and unique venues selected for each field. (B) Within-field overlap quantifies the average percentage of respondents in each field that have selected venues chosen by others in their field. (C) For each of the three most commonly selected venues in each field, an annotated heatmap shows the percentage of respondents per field who selected that venue. Annotations are suppressed for values under 10%. Our data show unambiguously that academic fields vary widely in their levels of consensus and preference coordination. At the most basic level, respondents’ consideration sets—the unordered sets of venues in which each respondent would be interested in publishing—reveal a spectrum from more to less consolidated fields. For instance, the union of 100 consideration sets, randomly sampled from Physics respondents, contains just 247 unique venues, similar to Economics ( 266 ), Chemistry ( 275 ), and Business ( 282 ), yet equal-sized samples from Computer Science and Engineering contain 567 and 598 venues, respectively. These differences are preserved across sampling efforts, reflected in venue accumulation curves (Fig. 1 A) which count the average number of unique venues contained in the union of an increasing number of respondents’