Note on the Hopf-algebra-based formula of Yang-Mills-Scalar amplitudes
Jiexi Liu, Yi-Jian Du · 2026
Read Note on the Hopf-algebra-based formula of Yang-Mills-Scalar amplitudes by Jiexi Liu, Yi-Jian Du (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2602-21621.txt.
Introduction
Jiexi Liu and one co-author study the Hopf-algebra-based formula for Yang-Mills-Scalar amplitudes. That formula expands a Yang-Mills-Scalar amplitude with massive scalars as a mix of propagator matrices joining massless scalars tied to gluons with the original massive scalars.
The note offers a recursive formula that expresses the Hopf-algebra-based formula with ease. In it, gluons turn into massless scalars. So a Yang-Mills-Scalar amplitude with massive scalars is expressed by amplitudes with fewer gluons, massive scalars, and massless scalars. The formula is verified with a soft behavior approach. In the massless limit, it turns into expressions for amplitudes with massless scalars earlier shown to satisfy another recursive expansion. The note shows the two distinct approaches match through explicit calculation on amplitudes with one and two gluons.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jiexi Liu, Yi-Jian Du |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 87 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2602-21621
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Note on the Hopf-algebra-based formula of Yang-Mills-Scalar amplitudes Jiexi Liu, Yi-Jian Du Abstract In this note, we study the Hopf-algebra-based (HAB) formula of Yang-Mills-Scalar (YMS) amplitudes, which expands a YMS amplitude with massive scalars as a combination of propagator matrices that mix massless scalars corresponding to gluons with the original massive scalars. We propose a recursive formula which conveniently expresses the HAB formula. In this formula, gluons are converted into massless scalars. Thus it expresses a YMS amplitude with massive scalars by amplitudes with fewer gluons, massive scalars and massless scalars. We verify this formula by using soft behavior approach. In the massless limit, the HAB formula turns into expressions for YMS amplitudes with massless scalars which was earlier shown to satisfy an alternative recursive expansion formula. In this note, we show the equivalence of these two distinct approaches through explicit calculation on amplitudes with one and two gluons. 1 Introduction The study of scattering amplitudes in Yang-Mills-scalar (YMS) theory plays a crucial role in understanding the perturbative relation between Yang-Mills (YM) theory and general relativity (GR). The reason is demonstrated as follows. Once YMS amplitudes are expanded in terms of bi-adjoint scalar (BS) Cachazo:2013iea amplitudes, one can immediately write down an expression of Yang-Mills amplitude, also written in terms of BS ones expEYM . The coefficients in this formula, have been used to generate all Bern-Carrasco-Johansson (BCJ) BCJBasis ; Bern:2010ue numerators Du:2017kpo , which are the key objects in the double-copy relation between YM and GR. A concrete realization of the expansion of massless-scalar YMS amplitudes into BS ones is the recursive expansion formula expEYM 1 1 1 More on this recursive formula can be found in Chiodaroli:2017ngp ; Teng:2017tbo ; Du:2017gnh ; Hou:2018bwm ; Du:2019vzf which is based on the manifesting of gauge invariance. According to this approach, any tree level single-trace YMS amplitude (with massless scalars) are expressed into a combination of YMS amplitudes with fewer gluons. This formula, when applied iteratively, finally results in a BS expansion of YMS amplitudes. It have been show that the recursive expansion relation are effective for the construction of tree-level Bern-Carrasco-Johansson (BCJ) BCJBasis ; Bern:2010ue numerators. They are also generalized to one-loop integrands by the forward limit strategy He:2016mzd ; He:2017spx ; Geyer:2015jch ; Geyer:2017ela ; Edison:2020uzf ; Porkert:2022efy . An interesting perspective is that the recursive expansion formula can be determined by the universal soft behaviors, see Zhou:2022orv ; Zhou:2023iae ; Hu:2023koy ; Du:2024xva . Hopf-algebra-based (HAB) formula Chen:2022nei is an alternertive approach to the YMS amplitude (but with general massive scalars). This formula originated from the study of heavy-mass effective field theory Brandhuber:2021kpo ; Brandhuber:2021bsf ; HopfHEFT . By the help of HAB formula, YMS amplitudes with massive scalars 2 2 2 In this note, all massive scalars are supposed to have the same mass. are expressed in terms of scalar propagator matrices combining massless scalars corresponding to gluons and the original massive scalars. The expansion coefficients are generated by a systematic rule based on the framework of Hopf algebra. By the help of double-copy statement, the HAB approach has been sucessfully applied in the study of massive particles scattering against gravitons HopfHEFT ; HopfNote ; HopfYMS ; Bjerrum-Bohr:2024fbt ; Chen:2023ekh ; Chen:2024gkj and have been used to calculate classical gravitational process Bjerrum-Bohr:2023jau ; Brandhuber:2023hhy ; Bjerrum-Bohr:2023iey ; Brandhuber:2023hhl ; Chen:2024mmm ; Brandhuber:2024qdn . In this note, we study the HAB formula of YMS amplitudes. We arrange the HAB formula for YMS amplitudes with massive scalars into a convenient recursive relation, through which, a YMS amplitude is written as a combination of amplitudes 3 3 3 These ‘ampltiudes’ are intemediate objects. We call them amplitudes in the sense that (i) the massless limit gives the ususal YMS amplitudes with massless scalars, (ii) they are gauge invariant. mixing massive scalars, massless scalars and fewer gluons. The HAB formula can be regarded as an iterative result of this recursive formula. We verify this formula by the soft limit approach. We further prove that the HAB formula in the massless limit is equivalent to the other approach expEYM , by explicit calculations on amplitudes with one and two gluons. The structure of the paper is organized as follows. In section 2 , we briefly review the recursive expansion formula proposed in expEYM , the HAB formula Chen:2022nei as well as the construction of amplitudes bases on universal soft behaviors Zhou:2022orv ; Zhou:2023iae ; Hu:2023koy ; Du:2024xva . The soft behavior of amplitudes is also introduced specifically for YMS amplitudes with massive scalars. In section 3 , we construct a recursive version of the HAB formula. A verification of this recursive formula is provided in section 4 , based on the soft behavior approach. In section 5 , we instead derive a recursive expansion of YMS amplitudes involving only massless scalars, starting from the known formula expEYM . Through explicit calculation, we demonstrate that this expansion matches the massless limit of the HAB formula for one- and two-gluon cases. Finally, we summarize this work in section 6 . Helpful relations are included in the appedix. 2 A review of recursive expansion, HAB formula and soft behaviors This section provides a review of two distinct approaches to the YMS amplitudes, the recursive expansion expEYM formula and the Hopf-algebra-based approach HopfHEFT ; HopfNote ; HopfYMS ; Bjerrum-Bohr:2024fbt ; Chen:2023ekh ; Chen:2024gkj . Furthermore, we review the soft behavior construction of amplitudes, which plays as a role in this paper. 2.1 The recursive expansion formula of YMS As proposed in expEYM , massless EYM amplitudes satisfy the recursive expansion formula, which also holds for YMS amplitudes. Concretely, for a tree-level doubly color-ordered massless YMS amplitude expEYM involving n scalars ( 1,2,\ldots,n ) and m gluons denoted by \{g_{i}\} , and a given right permutation \bm{\sigma} of all scalars and gluons, we have \displaystyle A_{\text{YMS}}(1,\ldots,n\|\{g_{i}\}\,|\,\bm{\sigma})= \displaystyle\left(\epsilon_{f}\cdot X^{L}_{f}\right)A_{\text{YMS}}(1,\{2,\ldots,n-1\}\shuffle g_{f},n\|\{g_{i}\}\!\setminus\!g_{f}\,|\,\bm{\sigma}) (2.1) \displaystyle+\sum_{\bm{\alpha}}\left(\epsilon_{f}\cdot F_{\bm{\alpha}^{\text{T}}}\cdot X^{L}_{\bm{\alpha}}\right)A_{\text{YMS}}(1,\{2,\ldots,n-1\}\shuffle\{\bm{\alpha},g_{f}\},n\|\{g_{i}\}\!\setminus\!(g_{f}\cup\bm{\alpha})\,|\,\bm{\sigma}), in which, g_{f} is an arbitrarily chosen gluon ( fiducial gluon ), and all non-empty ordered subsets \bm{\alpha}=(\alpha_{1},\ldots,\alpha_{a}) of gluons \{g_{i}\}\!\setminus\!g_{f} on the second line has been summed over. The shuffle symbol \shuffle denotes the sum over all possible permutations of scalars \{2,\ldots,n-1\} and gluons \{\bm{\alpha},g_{f}\} preserving the relative ordering in each ordered set. For example, \{2,3\}\shuffle\{g_{1},g_{f}\} implies that we sum over the following permutations \{2,3\}\shuffle\{g_{1},g_{f}\}:\{g_{1},g_{f},2,3\},\{g_{1},2,g_{f},3\},\{g_{1},2,3,g_{f}\},\{2,g_{1},g_{f},3\},\{2,g_{1},3,g_{f}\},\{2,3,g_{1},g_{f}\}. (2.2) The \big(X^{L}_{f}\big)^{\mu} is the sum of the momenta of scalars on the left-hand side of the fiducial gluon g_{f} in a given permutation of scalars and gluon g_{f} . Similarly, \big(X^{L}_{\bm{\alpha}}\big)^{\mu} is the total momentum of scalars on the left-hand side of gluon \alpha_{1} (the leftmost element in \bm{\alpha} ) in a given ordering of scalars and gluons \{\bm{\alpha},g_{f}\} . The tensor F^{\mu\nu}_{\bm{\alpha}^{\text{T}}} denotes the contraction of strength tensors F^{\mu\nu}=k^{\mu}\epsilon^{\nu}-\epsilon^{\mu}k^{\nu} of gluons in \bm{\alpha} and takes the form as F_{\bm{\alpha}^{\text{T}}}^{\mu\nu}=(F_{\alpha_{a}}\cdot\ldots\cdot F_{\alpha_{1}})^{\mu\nu}, (2.3) where the ordering \bm{\alpha}^{\text{T}}=(\alpha_{a},\ldots,\alpha_{1}) is the inverse of \bm{\alpha}=(\alpha_{1},\ldots,\alpha_{a}) . Applying ( 2.1 ) iteratively, a doubly color-ordered YMS amplitude can be expanded into pure color-ordered BS ones A_{\text{YMS}}(1,\ldots,n\|\{g_{i}\}\,|\,\bm{\sigma})=\sum_{\bm{\bm{\rho}}}C(\bm{\rho})A_{\text{BS}}(1,\bm{\rho},n\,|\,\bm{\sigma}), (2.4) with 1 and n fixed as the two ends. Here we have summed over all possible permutations of the scalars and gluons preserving the scalar ordering \{2,\ldots,n-1\} . Each coefficient C(\bm{\rho}) arises from the corresponding class of expansion routes, which leads to the specific BS