Ribbon concordance and fibered predecessors, II: the general case

John A. Baldwin, Jonathan Hanselman, Steven Sivek · 2026

Read Ribbon concordance and fibered predecessors, II: the general case by John A. Baldwin, Jonathan Hanselman, Steven Sivek (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2602-21109.txt.

Introduction

A knot can have many ribbon-concordant predecessors, but how many can be fibered? John Baldwin, Jonathan Hanselman, and Steven Sivek answer in this 2026 arXiv paper, removing the hyperbolic restriction from earlier work. They prove every knot in three-space has only finitely many fibered predecessors under ribbon concordance.

The key step is an inequality relating the knot Floer homology of a generalized satellite knot to that of its companion, proved through immersed curves in bordered Heegaard Floer homology. Combined with results of Kojima and McShane, the work also bounds the Gromov norm of any fibered predecessor's complement in terms of the arc index and genus of the original knot.

Catalog record

CREATORJohn A. Baldwin, Jonathan Hanselman, Steven Sivek
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE102 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2602-21109

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Ribbon concordance and fibered predecessors, II: the general case John A. Baldwin, Jonathan Hanselman, Steven Sivek Abstract . The first and third authors recently proved that for each knot K ⊂ S 3 K\subset S^{3} there are only finitely many hyperbolic fibered knots which are ribbon concordant to K K . In this paper, we remove the hyperbolic constraint, proving that every knot in S 3 S^{3} has only finitely many fibered predecessors under ribbon concordance. The key new input is an inequality relating the knot Floer homology of a generalized satellite knot with that of its companion, proved via the immersed curves formulation of bordered Heegaard Floer homology, which should be of independent interest. Our work, together with results of Kojima–McShane, also leads to an explicit upper bound on the Gromov norm of the complement of any fibered predecessor of a knot K ⊂ S 3 K\subset S^{3} , in terms of the arc index and genus of K K . 1. Introduction Agol proved in [ Ago22 ] that ribbon concordance defines a partial order on the set of knots in S^{3} , affirming a conjecture of Gordon from [ Gor81 ] ; we therefore write J\leq K to mean that a knot J is ribbon concordant to the knot K . In the same paper, Gordon made the still-open conjecture that there is no infinite descending chain of distinct ribbon concordant knots, \dots\leq K_{3}\leq K_{2}\leq K_{1} . In [ BS25b ] , the first and third authors proposed the a priori stronger conjecture that each knot in S^{3} has only finitely many predecessors under ribbon concordance: Conjecture 1.1 . For each knot K\subset S^{3} , there are only finitely many knots J\leq K . In support of this conjecture, they proved that each knot in S^{3} has only finitely many hyperbolic fibered predecessors [ BS25b , Theorem 1.2] . The main goal of this paper is to remove the hyperbolic constraint, and prove this finiteness result for all fibered predecessors: Theorem 1.2 . For each knot K\subset S^{3} , there are only finitely many fibered knots J\leq K . Since ribbon predecessors of fibered knots are fibered [ Sil92 , Koc06 ] , this proves Conjecture 1.1 for all fibered knots: Corollary 1.3 . For each fibered knot K\subset S^{3} , there are only finitely many knots J\leq K .∎ The proof of [ BS25b , Theorem 1.2] first used Floer homology to bound the dilatation of the pseudo-Anosov monodromy of any hyperbolic fibered J\leq K , as well as the genus of J , and then appealed to the fact that there are only finitely many conjugacy classes of pseudo-Anosov homeomorphisms of a given surface with dilatation less than a fixed constant. If J is not hyperbolic then its monodromy is either periodic or reducible. The periodic case is easy to deal with. The bulk of this paper deals with the reducible case. At heart, our strategy once again involves bounding the dilatations of the pseudo-Anosov components of the reducible monodromy, though there are serious obstacles to doing so by the methods in [ BS25b ] , as explained in [ BS25b , §3] and reiterated in § 1.1 below. The key new input which allows us to bypass these difficulties is an inequality relating the knot Floer homology of a generalized satellite knot (see § 3 ) with that of its companion: Theorem 1.4 . Let K\subset Y be a generalized satellite knot with companion C\subset Z , whose pattern P has winding number w\geq 1 . Then \dim\widehat{\mathit{HFK}}(Z,C)\leq\dim\widehat{\mathit{HFK}}(Y,K). Theorem 1.4 is stated in much greater generality than is needed for our application, and should be of independent interest. It yields in particular the corollary below for satellite knots in S^{3} . Even this special case was previously unknown, though Shen proved it for (1,1) -patterns in [ She25 ] : Corollary 1.5 . Let K\subset S^{3} be a satellite knot with companion C , whose pattern P\subset S^{1}\times D^{2} has winding number w\geq 1 . Then \dim\widehat{\mathit{HFK}}(S^{3},C)\leq\dim\widehat{\mathit{HFK}}(S^{3},K). We prove Theorem 1.4 via the immersed curves formulation of bordered Heegaard Floer homology due to the second author, Rasmussen, and Watson in [ HRW24 ] . We will ultimately apply it to lifts of fibered satellite knots in their cyclic branched covers (see Corollary 5.10 ), as indicated in § 1.1 . Finally, the techniques that go into our proof of Theorem 1.2 , together with results of Kojima and McShane relating the entropy of a pseudo-Anosov homeomorphism and the volume of its mapping torus [ KM18 ] , allow us to prove that the arc index and genus of a knot K\subset S^{3} give rise to an upper bound on the Gromov norm \lVert\cdot\rVert of the complement of any fibered predecessor of K . This generalizes a similar result in [ BS25b , Theorem 1.4] bounding volume for hyperbolic fibered predecessors. Let v_{3}=1.014941606... denote the volume of the regular ideal tetrahedron in \mathbb{H}^{3} . Then we have the following: Theorem 1.6 . Suppose that K\subset S^{3} is a knot of genus g and arc index \delta . Then \lVert S^{3}\setminus J\rVert\leq\tfrac{3\pi}{v_{3}}(2g-1)\log(\delta!) for every fibered knot J\leq K . 1.1. On the proof Let K be a knot in S^{3} . As mentioned above, the main challenge in proving Theorem 1.2 is showing that there are finitely many fibered knots J\leq K with reducible monodromy. Any such J is a satellite knot whose pattern has winding number w\geq 1 . Let us assume for example that J is the (1,6) -cable of a hyperbolic (necessarily fibered) knot C , and explain why there are only finitely many such J\leq K , as even this very simple case illustrates some of the key ideas. Let h:\Sigma\to\Sigma be the monodromy of J . The reducing set \Gamma of h cuts \Sigma into seven pieces, \overline{\Sigma\setminus\Gamma}=\Sigma_{0}\cup S_{0}\cup S_{1}\cup\dots\cup S_{5}, where \Sigma_{0} contains \partial\Sigma , and each S_{i} is a copy of the fiber surface of C . Moreover h sends each S_{i} to S_{i+1} , where the subscripts are understood mod 6, and we may assume that the restriction h^{6}|_{S_{0}}:S_{0}\to S_{0} is freely isotopic to the pseudo-Anosov monodromy of C , which we denote by \varphi . Our aim is to prove that there are only finitely many possibilities for C . This would follow as in the proof of [ BS25b , Theorem 1.2] from an a priori upper bound on the dilatation of \varphi , the idea being that (1) C is determined by its complement, which is determined by the conjugacy class of \varphi ; (2) up to conjugation, there are only finitely many pseudo-Anosov maps of a given surface with dilatation less than some fixed constant; and (3) g(C)<g(J)\leq g(K) , the second inequality following for fibered J from a theorem of Gilmer [ Gil84 ] . Let J_{n}\subset\Sigma_{n}(J) denote the lift of J in its n -fold cyclic branched cover. Then J_{n} is a fibered knot with monodromy h^{n} . The knot Floer homology of J_{n} bounds the Nielsen number of its monodromy, N(h^{n})\leq\dim\widehat{\mathit{HFK}}(\Sigma_{n}(J),J_{n}), as shown by Ni [ Ni22 ] and Ghiggini–Spano [ GS22 ] . It follows from this and the discussion

Read the complete text