A Small Patch Hypothesis in Cosmology
Meir Shimon · 2026
Read A Small Patch Hypothesis in Cosmology by Meir Shimon (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2602-09420.txt.
Introduction
Meir Shimon's single-author 2026 paper proposes that our observable universe may be only a minute patch of a far larger, older spacetime. On that view, the classic flatness and horizon problems of the hot Big Bang become tricks of selection. We occupy a small causal domain of a much larger connected spacetime that need not be flat. A large positive cosmological constant sets the future horizon scale, capping the accessible region regardless of when it is observed.
The bound is purely about shape, free of inflation, anthropic reasoning, or claims about the hosting spacetime. Inflation then becomes one viable realization of the small-patch picture, not a necessity. A non-inflationary alternative with a slowly growing early spectrum can mimic an inflation-like spectrum over our narrow observable window. Large-scale smoothness, isotropy, and even the arrow of time may follow from restricted access to a larger universe in equilibrium.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Meir Shimon |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 61 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2602-09420
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Small Patch Hypothesis in Cosmology Meir Shimon Abstract If our observable Universe is only a tiny region of a vastly larger and conformally older spacetime, then the usual formulations of the classical flatness and horizon problems of the Hot Big Bang can be reinterpreted as artifacts manifesting an observational selection effect; we occupy a small causal domain of a much larger causally-connected and possibly non-flat spacetime. A sufficiently large positive cosmological constant, Λ \Lambda , sets the future asymptotic horizon scale of the observable Universe, ∼ \sim Λ − 1 / 2 \Lambda^{-1/2} , thereby implying that the observable Universe may simply be a minute patch of a far larger pre-existing one, hereafter a Small Patch Hypothesis. Importantly, this observational bound is purely geometric; regardless of when the Universe is observed, the maximum accessible scale is finite and fixed by Λ \Lambda , independent of inflationary dynamics, anthropic arguments, or assumptions about the global hosting spacetime. The externally possibly frozen past-eternal state implied by a pre-existing, causally connected spacetime motivates, but does not strictly require, viewing the perturbation field as being in (or arbitrarily close to) a coarse-grained maximum-entropy — equilibrium — configuration. Conditionalizing only on fixed mean and variance, a Gaussian distribution uniquely emerges, while the absence of entropy gradients corresponds to adiabaticity. In this work these features are therefore treated as plausible maximum-ignorance priors for super-horizon perturbations, rather than as rigorously derived consequences of a fully developed microscopic notion of gravitational entropy. In this sense, inflation becomes one viable realization of the proposed Small Patch Hypothesis. Here, one particular non-inflationary alternative is considered for illustrative purposes in which a primordial spectrum P ζ ( k ) P_{\zeta}(k) of the gauge-invariant perturbation ζ \zeta that pre-dates the Big Bang grows logarithmically toward large scales, k → 0 k\rightarrow 0 , and in fact diverges at some finite k c k_{c} . If k c ≪ Λ − 1 / 2 k_{c}\ll\Lambda^{-1/2} , then our local cosmic patch probes only the regime where ζ ≪ 1 \zeta\ll 1 and appears exceptionally smooth. Over the comparatively narrow observable window, this P ζ ( k ) P_{\zeta}(k) mimics a slightly red-tilted, inflation-like spectrum. Rather than introducing high-energy new fields, this perspective frames large-scale homogeneity, isotropy, Gaussianity, adiabaticity, and the observed thermodynamic Arrow of Time as possible consequences of restricted observational access to a much larger Universe in equilibrium, rather than signatures of a unique early-Universe mechanism. Current observations cannot distinguish this logarithmically running spectrum from the standard power-law one, but future probes — for example high-resolution 21-cm measurements of the Dark Ages — may be able to falsify it. keywords inflation; primordial power spectrum; logarithmic running; Cosmological Principle; Arrow of Time † † firstpage: 1 † † volume: 1 † † issue: 1 † † articlenumber: 0 † † year: 2026 † † copyright-year: 2026 † † external-editor: Firstname Lastname † † received: 6 December 2025 † † revised: 21 January 2026 † † accepted: 30 January 2026 † † hreflink: https://doi.org/ † † authornames: Meir Shimon † † address: 1 School of Physics and Astronomy, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv 69978, Israel; [email protected] 2 Afeka Tel-Aviv Academic College of Engineering, Tel Aviv 69107, Israel † † reftitle: References 1 Introduction A few puzzling properties of the Universe — that include, among others, the flatness Dicke1970 and horizon Rindler1956 ; Misner1969 problems — are naturally explained in the standard cosmological model by a brief phase of inflationary expansion in the very early Universe, e.g., Guth1981 ; Linde1982 ; Starobinsky1982 . Not only that inflation dynamically explains these features of the model away, but it also provides a quantum origin for the observed slightly red-tilted primordial power spectrum, e.g., MukhanovChibisov1981 ; Sasaki1983 . Inflation allegedly took place at very high energies, \sim 10^{15} GeV or somewhat lower. As will be argued in the present work the flatness and horizon problems, as well as the slightly red-tilted power spectrum, seem to be consistent with an alternative geometrical (rather than dynamical) low-energy (potentially) classical phenomenon. This alternative viewpoint will be referred to in this work as the Small Patch Hypothesis , in which the observable Universe inhabits a tiny fractional volume of a vastly larger spacetime (for definiteness, one may keep in mind a globally Friedmann-Robertson-Walker (FRW) or asymptotically de Sitter parent solution with curvature radius and horizon scale much larger than the present Hubble radius, without attempting here to derive that global solution from more fundamental physics). The discovery of the accelerated expansion of the Universe, Riess1998 ; Perlmutter1999 , came as a surprise since it was clear from the outset that the naive estimate of vacuum energy density \rho_{vac}\sim m_{pl}^{4} Weinberg1989 , where m_{pl} is the Planck mass, is outright rejected by the very existence of a few billion years old Universe, and it was expected that \rho_{vac}=0 precisely by virtue of some yet-to-be-discovered symmetry principle. Since the observationally inferred value of \rho_{vac} is unlikely to come from any sector of the standard model of particle physics, various estimated upper bounds were proposed based on anthropic reasoning, e.g., Weinberg1987 ; Efstathiou1995 ; Martel1998 . From the perspective of the present work, there should also be a lower limit on the cosmological constant, otherwise a ‘typical’ observer might find himself observing a very inhomogeneous Universe on sufficiently large scales, undermining the underlying Cosmological Principle. Put alternatively, for the latter to apply to the observable Universe the cosmological constant, \Lambda , has to be sufficiently large for a given observed tilt of the matter power spectrum as will be argued below. This consideration alone implies that a positive cosmological constant is likely to be in play and at just about the observed level. Similar conclusions, albeit from entirely different perspectives, have been reached at in, e.g., Shimon2024 ; AfshordiMagueijo2022 . In the context of the Small Patch Hypothesis, \Lambda sets the observational boundary that regulates which Fourier modes of the primordial spectrum are accessible within the specific logarithmically running ansatz for P_{\zeta}(k) developed in Section 4 . It should be stressed already at this point that the Small Patch Hypothesis is perfectly consistent with the standard slightly red-tilted power spectrum and the reason that a logarithmically running replacement is even considered in the present work is to demonstrate that even if the hosting Universe becomes wildly inhomogeneous on very large (yet finite) ultra-Hubble scales there is always a sufficiently large value of \Lambda that would guarantee that the observable Universe is smooth to a sufficiently high precision. Another important implication is related to the entropic state of the Universe. This aspect is crucial for understanding the naturality of the initial conditions and evolution of the Universe. A puzzling property of the observed Universe is that, whereas the energetic degrees of freedom (photons, baryons, electrons, and neutrons) were at thermal equilibrium in the very early Universe, i.e., at maximum entropy, gravity appears to be at very low entropy, as evidenced by the shallow potential wells, \zeta_{rms}=\mathcal{O}(10^{-5}) , at least at the recombination era. Such spatial homogeneity level is atypical for systems governed by long-range attractive forces like gravity. The penultimate highest entropy state for such a system — when other non-gravitational interactions can