The kinematic cosmic dipole beyond Ellis and Baldwin

Albert Bonnefous , · 2026

Read The kinematic cosmic dipole beyond Ellis and Baldwin by Albert Bonnefous , (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2602-05700.txt.

Introduction

Counts of distant light sources in the sky show a dipole pattern stronger than standard cosmology expects, an anomaly now seen in several surveys. Albert Bonnefous revisits the Ellis and Baldwin formula, which links that pattern to our velocity relative to the cosmic rest frame. The classic formula assumes source brightness and spectra follow power laws, a restriction real surveys do not obey.

Bonnefous shows the relation generalizes to arbitrary luminosity distributions and spectral profiles, and derives the matching expression for the effective spectral index. Applied to a sample of quasars from the CatWISE survey, the anomalous dipole persists beyond the power law assumption. The result gives a more general and robust frame for reading dipole measurements in future large surveys. The single author paper has been accepted by a leading astronomy journal. It strengthens the case that the anomaly is not an artifact of a simplifying assumption.

Catalog record

CREATORAlbert Bonnefous ,
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2602-05700

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The kinematic cosmic dipole beyond Ellis and Baldwin Albert Bonnefous , Abstract The cosmic dipole anomaly—currently detected at a significance exceeding 5 σ \sigma in several independent survey poses a significant challenge to the standard model of cosmology. The Ellis & Baldwin formula provides a theoretical link between the intrinsic dipole anisotropy in the sky distribution of extragalactic light sources and the observer’s velocity relative to the cosmic rest frame, under the assumptions that the sources follow a power-law luminosity function and exhibit power-law spectral energy distributions. Even though in the case of a monochromatic survey fitting a power law on the spectra at the flux limit is always sufficient, it fails for the case of sources with more complicated spectra in photometric surveys, such as galaxies in the visible and near-infrared which can feature emission lines or breaks. In this work, we demonstrate that the Ellis and Baldwin formula can be generalized to arbitrary luminosity distributions and spectral profiles in particular for photometric surveys. We derive the corresponding expression for the effective spectral index and apply it to a sample of quasars observed in the W1 band of the CatWISE survey. We show that the anomalous cosmic dipole persists beyond the power-law assumption in this sample. These results provide a more general and robust framework to interpret measurements of the cosmic dipole in future photometric large-scale surveys. 1 Introduction In their 1984 article ( 7 ) , Ellis & Baldwin pointed out that our motion with respect to the Cosmological Rest Frame (CRF) induces an intrinsic anisotropy in the observed sky distribution of any class of objects in the Universe. In other words, the Universe does not appear perfectly homogeneous and isotropic to us. In the specific case of radio sources, whose spectra and flux distributions can be well approximated by power laws, they proposed a method to infer our velocity in the CRF by measuring this anisotropy, more precisely the dipole in the number of sources per unit solid angle. They derived what we will hereafter refer to as the EB formula: \bm{\mathcal{D}}_{\rm kin}=(2+x(1+\alpha))\bm{\beta}\,, (1) where x and \alpha denote the power-law indices of the flux distribution and source spectra, respectively, and \bm{\beta} is our velocity relative to the CRF, normalized by the speed of light. Ellis & Baldwin argued that estimating \bm{\beta} in this way should yield the same result as the velocity measured from the dipole of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB), provided the sources are sufficiently distant that intrinsic clustering anisotropies can be neglected, and lie entirely beyond our local bulk flow, in a Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) Universe. At the time, however, applying this test to observational data was not feasible, due to the absence of sufficiently large catalogs to obtain a robust signal-to-noise ratio in the dipole measurement. The first detection of a kinematic dipole with this test dates back to 2002, with the NRAO VLA Sky Survey (NVSS), using about 1.8 million source ( 1 ) , and found a dipole amplitude slightly higher than the CMB expectations, although with significance low enough that it could still be compatible. Since then, other test aligned with this result, showing a correct alignment but a higher than expected amplitude (see for example ( 19 ; 9 ; 15 ; 2 ) ). In 2021, robust result of about 5\sigma in statistical significance, was obtained using CatWISE quasar data ( 16 ) , and in 2022 it was shown that NVSS radio galaxies yield a similar result ( 17 ) . Despite being uncorrelated and affected by distinct systematics, both datasets yielded inferred velocities significantly larger than the CMB expectation. Within the \Lambda CDM framework, no explanation has yet been found. These findings have renewed interest in the EB formalism and motivated efforts to extend its application to upcoming surveys such as Euclid ( 8 ) , LSST (Rubin Observatory) ( 10 ) , and SPHEREx ( 4 ) . In particular, the expression for the kinematic dipole in number counts has been generalized to a tomographic dipole that incorporates redshift evolution in the source description ( 11 ) , with alternative expression involving the time evolution of sources ( 5 ) . It has also been shown that the original EB formula remains correct in the presence of source evolution, and that in the case of monochromatic surveys it is necessary to evaluate the parameters x and \alpha at the flux limit ( 20 ) . A more detailed review on this test and its use through the year is available in ( 18 ) . However, the case of sources that do not exhibit power law spectra in photometric survey , has not been treated yet. For example, the spectra of galaxies in the visible and near infrared can feature emission line, bumps, or even more complicated features such as Lyman- \alpha forest, see Fig. 1 . Solving this issue is crucial to apply this test to upcoming large scale surveys such as LSST ( 10 ) or Euclid ( 8 ) . In this letter, we first briefly review the formalism underlying the EB formula in Section 2 . We then extend it in Section 3 to the general case of a source population without assuming any specific spectral profile or luminosity distribution, considering two distinct survey types: monochromatic (measuring the flux density, as is typical of radio surveys) and photometric (the flux is integrated with a pass-band filter). Finally, in Section 4 , we apply the resulting effective spectral index in photometric surveys to quasars and compare it to the value obtained using the approach of ( 16 ) . Figure 1 : Sketch of an integral number count (left) with a power law fit in dashed red at an arbitrary flux or luminosity limit, and an arbitrary spectra (right) of a source at the flux or luminosity limit, where the red part correspond to the part of the spectra integrated in a given band X . In the most general case survey, it is always possible to fit a power law at the flux or luminosity limit. However here the spectra is not a power law, so in the case of a photometric survey the spectral index \alpha cannot be defined as S_{\nu}\propto\nu^{-\alpha} over the band. 2 The Ellis & Baldwin formula Consider a moving observer with respect to a rest frame, such as presented in Fig. 2 . Any quantity a measured in the frame of the observer will be written a_{\rm o} , whereas the same quantity in the rest frame will be a_{\rm r} . Two different effects impact the observations, the relativistic aberrations, and the Doppler boosting. Figure 2 : (a) The frame moving with the observer, (b) the rest frame, in which the observer has a velocity \mathbf{v} . For the sake of simplicity, we assume that the z axis is parallel to the movement of this observer. 2.1 Relativistic aberration The relativistic aberration of light is the deformation of the field of view of an observer moving with respect to what it observes; the apparent position of a body is shifted toward the direction of its movement. Suppose that we are looking at an object at

Read the complete text