Nonstandard free groups
Alexei Miasnikov, Andrey Nikolaev · 2026
Read Nonstandard free groups by Alexei Miasnikov, Andrey Nikolaev (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2602-02933.txt.
Introduction
Alexei Miasnikov and 1 co-author develop a nonstandard version of free groups in a 2026 mathematics paper. Free groups are basic objects in group theory, built from generators with no extra relations. Interpretation, a logic tool, lets one form be coded inside another to produce new, equivalent models.
Interpreting the free group inside the natural numbers yields what the authors call nonstandard free groups. They extend the idea to a wide class of groups. Ultrapowers of a group, a standard construction, can then be viewed as such nonstandard models. The paper also introduces nonstandard subgroups, normal subgroups, and presentations. The method helps answer a longstanding question raised by Malcev.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alexei Miasnikov, Andrey Nikolaev |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 90 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2602-02933
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Nonstandard free groups Alexei Miasnikov, Andrey Nikolaev Abstract . Interpretation of a structure 𝔸 \mathbb{A} in 𝔹 \mathbb{B} allows to produce structures elementarily equivalent to 𝔸 \mathbb{A} given those elementarily equivalent to 𝔹 \mathbb{B} . In particular, interpretation of the free group in ℕ \mathbb{N} enables us to introduce and study a family of elementary free groups, which we call nonstandard free groups. More generally, for a wide class of groups we introduce nonstandard models arising from interpretation in ℕ \mathbb{N} . We exploit interpretation to show that under mild assumptions, ultrapowers of a group can be viewed as nonstandard models of that group. This leads us to describe the structure of the ultrapowers in terms of structure of nonstandard models of natural numbers, offering insight into a longstanding question of Malcev. We also introduce fundamentals of nonstandard combinatorial group theory such as the notions of nonstandard subgroups, nonstandard normal subgroups, and nonstandard group presentations. 1. Motivation and main ideas Let G be a countable group where the multiplication is not absolutely bizarre, say, there is a generating set for which the word problem is decidable, or recursively enumerable, or just arithmetic, i.e., it is defined by a formula of arithmetic (definable in arithmetic). Then G is interpretable in {\mathbb{Z}} via some interpretation \Gamma , symbolically G\cong\Gamma({\mathbb{Z}}) (see Section 2.1 for relevant definitions). If \widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}\equiv{\mathbb{Z}} then \Gamma interprets a group \widetilde{G}=\Gamma(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}) in \widetilde{\mathbb{Z}} , which we call a nonstandard model of G . If G is finitely generated, then the group \Gamma(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}) does not depend on the particular interpretation \Gamma , so if G\cong\Gamma({\mathbb{Z}}) and G\cong\Delta({\mathbb{Z}}) then \Gamma(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}})\cong\Delta(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}) for any ring \widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}\equiv{\mathbb{Z}} (Theorem 2.2 ). In this case, the nonstandard versions of G are completely determined by G and \widetilde{\mathbb{Z}} , so this is ultimately about groups, not interpretations. With this in mind, we denote \Gamma(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}) by G(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}) or \widetilde{G} . If G is not finitely generated, we still denote \Gamma(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}) by G(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}) or \widetilde{G} if the interpretation \Gamma is irrelevant or clear from the context. The central idea is that the nonstandard groups G(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}) are the closest versions of G which, on the one hand, preserve the principal properties of G that we want to investigate, but on the other hand, are general enough so many non-essential features of G disappear in them. Furthermore, since G(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}})=\Gamma(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}) one can see and recover from \Gamma and \widetilde{\mathbb{Z}} the general constructions and frames on which these essential properties depend. This leads to a better understanding of G through the variety of its nonstandard models and gives a general method of approaching various open problems on G . Some of these problems can be solved using nonstandard groups directly, while for others, nonstandard groups show where to look for solutions and what kind of tools to use. In the present paper, we restrict our attention to the former, as we explain below in Sections 1.1 and 1.2 . When G is a free group G=F , we call the corresponding nonstandard model F(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}) the nonstandard free group, and denote it by \widetilde{F} . In many regards, it behaves like the standard free group F , with the key difference that \widetilde{F} “natively” admits certain infinite products. For that, the principal instrument is so-called nonstandard list superstructure (see Section 3.4 ). This feature propagates to numerous other usual notions of group theory, leading us to introduce nonstandard subgroups, nonstandard group presentations, and the first isomorphism theorem, which are explored in Sections 5 and 6 . 1.1. First-order classification and elementary equivalence Denote by Th(G) the first-order theory of G in the language of group theory L=\{\cdot,^{-1},1\} . One of the initial motivations of this project is in developing a general approach for characterizing algebraically all the groups H that are elementarily equivalent to a given group G . This is the well-known Tarski first-order classification problem for groups. It follows from the properties of interpretations that G(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}})\equiv G (Theorem 2.1 ) for any \widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}\equiv{\mathbb{Z}} . However, in general, not all models of Th(G) are nonstandard versions of G . For example, this is the case for a free non-abelian group F or a non-abelian torsion-free hyperbolic group G (it comes from the solution of the Tarski problem for these groups [ 7 , 20 ] ). Nevertheless, the nonstandard groups G(\widetilde{{\mathbb{Z}}}) are important models of Th(G) ; they are “more equivalent” to G than all other models of Th(G) . In fact, they are equivalent to G in a much stronger logic than the first-order logic in the language of groups. This is a new type of logic, which deserves a study in its own right. We offer a brief introductory glimpse into this in Section 3.6 , in particular, Subsection 3.6.1 . Furthermore, it turns out that the nonstandard models of G give an instrument to understand all other models of Th(G) . Indeed, first, like in the nonstandard arithmetic, the group G embeds into each G(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}) as the standard part of G(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}) and this embedding is elementary (Theorem 6.2 ). Second, every model H of Th(G) is an elementary submodel of some nonstandard model G(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}) of the same cardinality (Theorem 6.3 ). Third, every saturated model of Th(G) (under the generalized continuum hypothesis) is a nonstandard version G(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}) for some saturated model \widetilde{\mathbb{Z}} of arithmetic (Theorem 6.4 ). Observe that a nonstandard free group \widetilde{F}=F(\widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}) is not finitely generated if \widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}\neq\mathbb{Z} . Indeed, a finitely generated group elementarily equivalent to a free group must be hyperbolic, and therefore has cyclic centralizers. However, it is easy to see that in \widetilde{F} , centralizers are isomorphic to the additive group \widetilde{\mathbb{Z}}^{+} (Proposition 5.2 ), which is not cyclic (see Section 3.1 ). Motivated by questions posed in [ 10 ] regarding countable groups elementarily equivalent to a free group F , the paper [ 12 ] describes groups G\equiv F with cyclic centralizers, and also gives the example \mathbb{Z}*(\mathbb{Z}\oplus\mathbb{Q}^{+}) of a group elementarily equivalent to F but with non-cyclic centralizers. All nonstandard free groups \widetilde{F} are new examples of groups with non-cyclic centralizers. In fact, since all centralizers in \widetilde{F} are non-cyclic, it follows that the above group \mathbb{Z}*(\mathbb{Z}+\mathbb{Q}^{+}) is not a nonstandard free group. 1.2. Ultrapowers and nonstandard groups Another piece of motivation is to address an old problem due to Malcev: for a free nonabelian group F , a set I , and a non-principal ultrafilter D on I describe the algebraic structure of the ultrapower F^{I}/D . At the time, the problem was ultimately related to the Tarski problem of whether or not two non-abelian free groups, say F_{2} and F_{3} , are elementarily equivalent to each other, via the Keisler–Shelah theorem (two groups are elementarily equivalent iff their non-trivial ultrapowers are isomorphic). Later, this question was asked for other groups G as well. If G is “finitely dimensional”, say algebraic over a field K (or over a suitable ring R ), then G^{I}/D is again algebraic with the same algebraic scheme, but over K^{I}/D (or R^{I}/D ), so we know the algebraic structure of G^{I}/D . This idea was successfully applied to the classical matrix groups or nilpotent groups, but it does not work for “infinitely dimensional” groups like F