Allowable complex metrics and the gravitational index of AdS 5 black holes
Pietro Benetti Genolini, 1 Oliver Janssen 2 and Sameer Murthy 3 · 2026
Read Allowable complex metrics and the gravitational index of AdS 5 black holes by Pietro Benetti Genolini, 1 Oliver Janssen 2 and Sameer Murthy 3 (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-23197.txt.
Introduction
Pietro Benetti Genolini, Oliver Janssen, and Sameer Murthy examine which complex metrics are allowed in a gravitational path integral. The integral in question computes the supersymmetric index, a protected count in quantum gravity. A criterion by Kontsevich, Segal, and Witten decides when a complex metric is allowable.
The authors focus on saddle points that capture supersymmetric black holes in five-dimensional anti-de Sitter space. Checking allowability there tests whether those black hole contributions are legitimate. The work sharpens the math behind black hole entropy counts. Saddle points for supersymmetric black holes in anti-de Sitter space are the concrete case the allowability discussion examines.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Pietro Benetti Genolini, 1 Oliver Janssen 2 and Sameer Murthy 3 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 72 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-23197
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Allowable complex metrics and the gravitational index of AdS 5 black holes Pietro Benetti Genolini, 1 Oliver Janssen 2 and Sameer Murthy 3 Abstract We discuss the Kontsevich–Segal–Witten criterion for the allowability of complex metrics, in the context of the gravitational path integral that calculates the supersymmetric index. We focus on the saddle points that capture the contribution of supersymmetric black holes in AdS 5 space. We show that, for such black holes with two independent angular momenta, the conditions imposed on the corresponding saddle point by the KSW criterion are equivalent to the ones arising from the convergence of the microscopic trace form of the supersymmetric index. This result adds to previous results establishing such an equivalence in other, simpler examples of the gravitational index in AdS space and flat space. Along the way, we give a practical algorithm for implementing the KSW criterion in terms of eigenvalues of certain matrices. 1 Introduction In classical General Relativity, the metric on a manifold is a symmetric second-rank tensor that takes real values at every point. However, there are many situations in physics where complex-valued metrics naturally arise, especially in the context of the Gravitational Path Integral (GPI) as discussed by Gibbons and Hawking 52 . A simple example is the analytic continuation to Euclidean signature (the “Wick rotation”) of a rotating black hole solution, which solves the saddle point equations of the GPI. It is clear that not all complex metrics are physical, and extending the space of integration of the GPI to all complex metrics is not sensible. This prompts the question of which complex metrics are allowed as saddle points of the GPI. A criterion to answer this question was proposed by Witten 98 , based on the work of Kontsevich and Segal 78 (henceforth referred to as the KSW criterion). In order to check the validity of such a criterion, it is useful to consider situations in which we have independent knowledge and control over the GPI. One such context is the gravitational supersymmetric index (see 33 for a review of the concept). 1 1 1 This is by no means the only context where the KSW criterion has been deployed, see e.g. 80 ; 95 ; 91 ; 43 ; 89 ; 82 ; 90 ; 74 ; 25 ; 92 ; 81 ; 94 ; 20 ; 8 ; 9 ; 39 ; 61 ; 38 ; 42 ; 41 ; 40 ; 87 ; 55 ; 72 ; 96 ; 36 ; 62 ; 50 ; 71 ; 93 ; 88 ; 63 ; 37 ; 65 ; 4 ; 69 ; 49 ; 84 ; 75 ; 3 for a sample of the ever-growing list of applications. The index is protected against changes of coupling constant, and therefore it can be directly compared with a corresponding calculation of the index in microscopic string theory. In cases that allow for such a calculation, independent ideas and constraints from the microscopic theory, such as modular symmetry and saddle point solutions of matrix models, predict a series of complex saddles of the GPI. In 13 ; 48 , an exploration of whether complex saddles of the gravitational index are allowed by the KSW criterion was initiated. Different types of complex black-hole-like saddles were considered for the validity of the KSW criterion as well as the microscopic constraints. The result was that—by and large—complex black-hole-like saddles of the gravitational index are allowed by the KSW criterion exactly when they are allowed by the microscopic constraints. However, the case of supersymmetric black holes in AdS 5 space carrying two unequal angular momenta was puzzling, and was not satisfactorily treated. As it turns out, this puzzle stems from an error in the implementation of the criterion (which only affects the case of different angular momenta) in a first version of 13 . As we explain in the present paper, the proper implementation of the KSW criterion shows that the KSW criterion agrees precisely with the microscopic constraints for the asymptotically AdS 5 black hole. 2 2 2 We have also updated 13 with a new version. The discussion of the 5d GPI dual to the superconformal index in that paper is superseded by the present paper and hence has been removed from there. Upon combining this with the other results of 13 , we reach the statement that in the variety of saddles of the gravitational index that we have checked, namely 4d asymptotically flat, 4d asymptotically AdS with twisted and untwisted supersymmetry-preserving boundary conditions, and also 5d asymptotically AdS gravity, there is a complete agreement of the microscopic constraints with the KSW criterion. Given the indications that such an agreement may not hold in more generality for the GPI (see e.g. 86 ; 85 ; 8 ; 41 ), it would be interesting to explain why the KSW criterion works so well for the index. If it is true as a fact, then it may be explainable using the existence of a Killing spinor in such geometries, but we do not have such an explanation so far. Since a sizable set of examples of gravitational indices have been found in recent years in AdS space 66 ; 67 ; 27 ; 44 ; 34 ; 76 ; 17 ; 16 ; 79 ; 31 ; 10 ; 14 ; 19 ; 11 ; 18 as well as in flat space 70 ; 68 ; 57 ; 23 ; 35 ; 22 ; 24 ; 21 , one could try to find patterns in these examples in order to probe this idea. In the process of implementing the KSW criterion for the AdS 5 black hole, we also gain a better understanding of the criterion in holographic situations, i.e. when we have asymptotically AdS boundary conditions on the metric. The summary of the picture that we develop, as explained in Section 3 , is the following. Recall that the KSW criterion is a point-wise criterion that must be satisfied at all points in the space. Applied to the asymptotic region, it is essentially the same as the original criterion of 78 for coupling the boundary CFT to gravity. For the supersymmetric index that we consider in this paper, this condition is equivalent to the convergence of the microscopic trace on BPS states. Once we have established the equivalence at the boundary, we want to “pull it into the bulk.” Using the Fefferman–Graham expansion we can do so analytically in perturbation theory, but this does not really shed light on the interior. What we do instead is to analyze the deep interior, close to the horizon, by imposing reality conditions justified by the physical picture. In the space between the asymptotic boundary and the horizon, we do not have an analytical understanding and we resort to numerical calculations, which show that there is a weakening of the KSW condition as one moves into the interior from the boundary, i.e., the area in parameter space ruled out by the KSW criterion becomes smaller as we move into the interior. Unfortunately, we were not able to capture this area as a simple analytic function of the metric. It would be nice to