Sunspot simulations with MURaM
Markus Schmassmann, Nazaret Bello González, Rolf Schlichenmaier, Jan Jurčák · 2026
Read Sunspot simulations with MURaM by Markus Schmassmann, Nazaret Bello González, Rolf Schlichenmaier, Jan Jurčák (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-23189.txt.
Introduction
Markus Schmassmann and three co-authors improve computer models of sunspots. Existing models fail to match the observed magnetic field pattern in sunspots. The mismatch traces to an wrongly boosted sideways field at the model's upper boundary.
Using the MURaM radiative MHD code, they explore other boundary setups. The aim is to reproduce both the magnetic and dynamic behavior of real sunspots. Better sunspot models support forecasts of solar activity that affects Earth. The MURaM code includes radiative transfer, so the models track both magnetic structure and the energy the spots radiate. Matching the observed sideways field pattern is the specific failure the other boundaries are meant to repair.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Markus Schmassmann, Nazaret Bello González, Rolf Schlichenmaier, Jan Jurčák |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-23189
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Sunspot simulations with MURaM Markus Schmassmann, Nazaret Bello González, Rolf Schlichenmaier, Jan Jurčák Abstract Context. Existing sunspot simulations fail to reproduce the observed magnetic field distribution due to an artificially increased horizontal magnetic field component at the upper boundary. Aims. We explore alternative ways to better reproduce the magnetic and dynamic properties of observed sunspots. Methods. We use the MURaM radiative MHD code. As initial conditions, we placed a potential magnetic field into small-scale dynamo simulations and used potential field extrapolation as top boundary conditions. Results. We find that: (1) Simulations with increasing initial magnetic field strengths (20 kG, 40 kG, 80 kG, and 160 kG) show increasing spot, umbral, and penumbral sizes. (2) The penumbral-to-spot sizes are smaller than those measured in the observed sunspots. (3) In none of the runs are pure Evershed (radially outwards) flows. Instead, bi-directional flows with inflows in the inner penumbra and outflows in the outer penumbra were measured similarly to observations of early stages of penumbra formation for runs with 80 kG or more and 96/32 km resolution, whereas runs with 40 kG or less showed pure inflows. (4) Simulations with 160 kG and an increased resolution of 32/16 km contain filaments with bi-directional and Evershed flows. (5) Simulations with fluxes > 10 22 >10^{22} Mx show unrealistically strong fields in the umbra. (6) The best runs with 160 kG and 10 22 10^{22} Mx give realistic profiles of B z B_{\mathrm{z}} and B r B_{\mathrm{r}} with radius, although stronger fields than observed. (7) Increasing the width of the box and reducing the overall flux by subtracting a uniform opposing vertical field have little influence on the internal spot dynamics and fields. Still, it changes the average vertical field outside the spot. Conclusions. Simulations of small (10 22 Mx) sunspots with an initial potential field and intensified magnetic field strength at the bottom of the box seem to best reproduce observations of the initial stages of sunspot formation. Our findings also suggest that increased numerical resolution may be critical for achieving fully developed penumbrae. I. Parameter study using potential field initial conditions 1 Introduction The art of MHD sunspot simulations has developed only recently. In 2007, 12 presented the first slab simulation of a sunspot, followed by similar simulations by 35 and 28 . These simulations provided the first insights into the penumbral fine structure. After initial trials, particularly in ( 27 ) , 29 managed to run MHD simulations of a circular sunspot that qualitatively reproduced the observed properties of penumbral fine structure. In other words, the structure of the penumbral filaments is comparable to the observational analysis of ( 45 ) . However, the formation of an extended penumbra is achieved in these MHD simulations by imposing artificial top boundary conditions that make the magnetic field more horizontal at the photospheric level. As shown by ( 15 ) , the global magnetic properties of the resulting sunspot are not fully realistic. The magnetic field inclination on the umbral/penumbral boundary is around 60 ∘ , which is significantly more horizontal than in the observed sunspots, where the largest values of inclination are around 45 ∘ and those are found only in large sunspots with more flux than the simulated sunspot. Furthermore, the vertical magnetic field component, B_{\mathrm{z}} , at the umbral boundary in these simulations is below the value expected from observations, a B_{\mathrm{z}}^{\textrm{stable}} of around 1.8 kG. In 15 , it was also shown that the inclination distribution as a function of the fractional spot radius as well as B_{\mathrm{z}} at the umbral boundary of observed sunspots, is comparable to an MHD simulation of a sunspot with a potential field as an initial condition. The use of a potential field as an initial condition for sunspot simulations was first proposed by 24 , who used slab geometry. Based on this idea, we performed an MHD simulation of a circular sunspot, as described by 15 . To find the best agreement between the simulated and observed sunspots, we conducted a parameter study of sunspot simulations using potential field initial conditions. The sunspot simulations of 25 also use potential top boundary conditions. However, the penumbra of their sunspots is wide only between the nearby opposite polarity spots, and very narrow in the perpendicular direction. Furthermore, their simulations are, by design, strongly affected by fluting instability, which makes them short-lived. The same authors also created simulations of starspots on other main-sequence stars ( 26 ) . Table 1: Simulation parameters. Sunspot run B_{0} B_{\mathrm{opp}} F_{\mathrm{Gauss}} F_{\mathrm{tot}} Box width d_{\mathrm{h}} Run time t_{\mathrm{ref}} [kG] [G] [ 10^{22} Mx] [ 10^{22} Mx] [Mm] [km] [h] [h] 1^{1} 1 20_opp000o 20.0 0 1 1 49.152 96 7.2038 2.8847-4.0839 40_opp000o 40.0 0 1 1 49.152 96 7.1966 2.8815-4.0789 80_opp000o 80.0 0 1 1 49.152 96 7.2167 2.8889-4.0911 160_opp000o 160.0 0 1 1 49.152 96 14.429 2.8886-4.0908 160_opp000ho 160.0 0 1 1 49.152 32 7.7131 7.2163-7.7131 160_opp000h 160.0 0 1 1 49.152 32 7.9997 3.0149-4.0149 160_opp050c 160.0 50 1.120796 1 49.152 96 4.0205 3.0142-4.0205 160_opp100c 160.0 100 1.241592 1 49.152 96 4.0075 3.0075-4.0075 160_opp150c 160.0 150 1.362388 1 49.152 96 4.0076 3.0076-4.0076 160_opp200c 160.0 200 1.483184 1 49.152 96 4.0057 3.0057-4.0057 160_opp300c 160.0 300 1.724776 1 49.152 96 4.0045 3.0045-4.0045 160_opp000 160.0 0 1 1 49.152 96 40.025 3.0111-4.0147 160_opp050 160.0 50 1 0.879204 49.152 96 4.0226 3.0182-4.0226 160_opp100 160.0 100 1 0.758408 49.152 96 4.0367 3.0167-4.0367 160_opp150 160.0 150 1 0.637612 49.152 96 4.0135 3.0123-4.0135 160_opp200 160.0 200 1 0.516816 49.152 96 4.0400 3.0223-4.0400 160_opp300 160.0 300 1 0.275224 49.152 96 4.0313 3.0198-4.0313 160_opp100w 160.0 100 1 0.033632 98.304 96 4.0267 3.0199-4.0267 160_opp150w 160.0 150 1 - 0.449552 98.304 96 4.0156 3.0156-4.0156 160_opp200w 160.0 200 1 - 0.932736 98.304 96 4.0214 3.0138-4.0214 160_opp000b 160.0 0 1 1 49.152 96 6.1536 2.9848-4.0010 1^{1} alpha1.0 6.4 1.198126 49.152 32 6.5096 6.0096-6.5096 alpha1.5 6.4 1.198126 49.152 32 6.4120 5.9120-6.4120 alpha2.0 6.4 1.198126 49.152 32 6.4133 5.9133-6.4133 alpha2.5 6.4 1.198126 49.152 32 6.4222 5.9222-6.4222 1^{1} NOAA AR 11591 362.5 2012.10.18 10:00:00 3 simulates starspots, extending ( 26 ) , but again forcing the magnetic field at the top to be inclined, resulting in too horizontal fields, at least when comparing the G2V starspot to sunspot observations. Hideyuki Hotta investigated the effect of higher resolution on sunspot simulations with a potential-field top boundary condition. Matthias Rempel joined this investigation and also analysed what happens when the resolution is changed during the simulation runs. All simulations in their investigation use potential field top boundary conditions. While presentations of preliminary analysis ( 32 ) are very encouraging, these results have not yet been published in a peer-reviewed journal. Furthermore, the high resolution used in these simulations results in prohibitively high costs. In solar observations, the penumbra forms around existing flux concentrations ( 38 , e.g.) . Various authors have done flux emergence simulations ( 8 ; 6 ; 13 , e.g.) . These simulations show, consistent with solar surface observations, that deeply anchored bundles rise coherently up to around 2 Mm below the surface, to then decay in small parts that rise with individual convective cells, and at the surface re-coalesce to larger structures that end up forming sunspots ( 44 , see tethered-balloon model