A Universal Convolution-Based Pre-processor to Correct the Prevalence-Incidence Gap in SIR, SEIR, and SIRS Modeling

José de Jesús Bernal-Alvarado, David Delepine · 2026

Read A Universal Convolution-Based Pre-processor to Correct the Prevalence-Incidence Gap in SIR, SEIR, and SIRS Modeling by José de Jesús Bernal-Alvarado, David Delepine (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-23077.txt.

Introduction

José de Jesús Bernal-Alvarado and David Delepine fix a mismatch at the heart of epidemic forecasting. Standard models like SIR, SEIR, and SIRS track how many people are ill at once. But real reports count new cases per day, a flow, and fitting stock models to flow data goes wrong.

That mismatch can shrink predicted peaks by as much as half. Their universal pre-processor converts the data properly before fitting, across all three model types. Cleaner inputs mean forecasts that health officials can trust more. Peak underestimation is the costly symptom named in the study, the error that leaves hospitals unprepared at the worst moment.

Catalog record

CREATORJosé de Jesús Bernal-Alvarado, David Delepine
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE17 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-23077

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Universal Convolution-Based Pre-processor to Correct the Prevalence-Incidence Gap in SIR, SEIR, and SIRS Modeling José de Jesús Bernal-Alvarado, David Delepine Abstract Background: Traditional compartmental models, including SIR, SEIR, and SIRS frameworks, remain the analytical standard for epidemic forecasting. However, real-world data validation consistently reveals significant predictive failures, such as peak underestimations of up to 50%. Methods: This research identifies a persistent ”fundamental methodological error”: the calibration of prevalence-based (stock) models using raw daily incidence (flow) data without proper transformation. We propose an integrated protocol utilizing an exponentially weighted convolution to reconstruct active cases from reported incidence: I ⁡ ( t ) ≃ 1 p ​ ∫ 0 t N ​ D ​ C ​ ( τ ) ​ e − γ ⁡ ( t − τ ) ​ 𝑑 τ I(t)\simeq\frac{1}{p}\int_{0}^{t}NDC(\tau)e^{-\gamma(t-\tau)}d\tau (1) This transformation accounts for the recovery rate ( γ \gamma ) and the ascertainment rate ( p p ). Results: We demonstrate that increasing structural complexity, such as adding latency (SEIR) or waning immunity (SIRS), fails to resolve the incidence-prevalence gap. Simulation results show that without the proposed universal pre-processor, these advanced models inherit the systematic biases of misaligned data types. This leads to significant errors in estimating latent periods and the ”heavy tail” of endemicity. Conclusions: The proposed convolution transformation must serve as a universal prerequisite for any compartmental framework. This formal protocol bridges the gap between clinical reporting and mechanistic modeling. Keywords: SIR Model ⋅ \cdot SEIR/SIRS ⋅ \cdot Prevalence-Incidence Gap ⋅ \cdot Convolution Transformation ⋅ \cdot Epidemiological Forecasting ⋅ \cdot Universal Pre-processor. I Introduction Despite its widespread use in public health policy since 2019, the SIR model and its derivatives , such as the SEIR (Exposed) and SIRS (Waning Immunity) frameworks, Kermack and McKendrick 1927 ; Diekmann and Heesterbeek 2000 consistently fails to capture real-world data trends due to their inherently rigid mathematical assumptions Kermack and McKendrick 1927 ; Diekmann and Heesterbeek 2000 ; Thompson et al. 2019 ; Moein et al. 2021 ; T et al. 2023 ; Murph et al. 2025 . In Real-world, their data validation consistently reveals significant predictive failures as most notably peak underestimations of up to 50% Murph et al. 2025 . A detailed revision of SIR model application allows to identify a persistent ”fundamental methodological error” in the calibration of these models: the use of raw daily incidence (flow) data to represent the infectious compartment, which is mathematically formulated as a prevalence (stock) variable. Usually, it is believed that adding compartments and increasing the structural complexity of the models could compensate for data misalignment. But increasing structural complexity without proper data transformation merely propagates the incidence-prevalence gap into the transition rates of the new compartments (see Table 1 ). In this work, we propose a universal pre-processor data transformation that correct this data misalignment. A convolution formula is proposed to relate the New Daily Case (NDC) with the Infected I(t) which appears in SIR -like model. While the mathematical relationship between prevalence and incidence—modeled as a convolution—is well known (see for instance ref. Diekmann and Heesterbeek 2000 ), a significant gap remains in its practical application. Existing literature often presents the convolution as a standalone proof rather than a universal requirement for compartmental calibration. In section II, a review on SIR model is briefly presented and in section III, the proposal to correct the prevalence-incidence methodological error is explained, applying it to simulated SIR data. In this section, we propose two correction: the first one is enough to improve the precision on the peak position ( \mu )of I(t) and the second one is more general, it correct both the peak and also its amplitude, through a convolution product. In section IV, we explain that if the original data misalignment is not corrected, the generated error will propagate in SIR extensions models as SEIR or SIRS models, generating errors in prediction on the behavior of the epidemic. In section V, the conclusion is presented. Table 1: Persistence of Methodological Risks across Compartmental Models Model Persistent Methodological Risk SIR Equating raw Incidence ( NDC ) with Prevalence induced errors in the peak localization of I(t) and its amplitude (up to 50% in some case). SEIR Generating errors in the estimate of the transition rate S\to E and E\to I by using raw daily reports. SIRS Underestimating the “heavy tail” and misinterpreting reinfection rates. II SIR model Let be the healthy people, susceptible to be infected (S), individuals with contagion capacity (I), and R representing the number of people recovered from the disease (or removed people because of death), dynamics of such populations, as a function of time, can now be described in the well known SIR model which constitutes the foundational framework for mechanistic epidemiological modeling. It describes the flow of individuals between three mutually exclusive compartments governed by the following system of non-linear ordinary differential equations Kermack and McKendrick 1927 : \displaystyle\frac{dS}{dt} \displaystyle=-\beta\frac{SI}{N}, (2) \displaystyle\frac{dI}{dt} \displaystyle=\beta\frac{SI}{N}-\gamma I, \displaystyle\frac{dR}{dt} \displaystyle=\gamma I, where N=S+I+R is the total population, \beta represents the effective transmission rate, and \gamma is the removal or recovery rate. It is important to note that in SIR model, I(t) also represents the active cases. The fundamental epidemiological parameter, the Basic Reproduction Number ( R_{0} ), is derived from the stability analysis of the disease-free equilibrium and is defined as: R_{0}=\frac{\beta}{\gamma}. (3) The dynamic evolution of the reproduction number as the susceptible compartment S(t) is depleted is known as the effective reproduction number, expressed as: R_{t}=R_{0}\frac{S(t)}{N} (4) While the SIR model successfully captures the initial exponential growth phase (where S\approx N ), its deterministic structure imposes a strong symmetry on the incidence curve I(t) around the peak. Specifically, the rate of decline is coupled to the depletion of the susceptible compartment. In modern pandemics modulated by social behavior, this symmetry is rarely observed; instead, the decline phase is often prolonged, resulting in a “heavy tail” that the standard SIR model systematically underestimates. We must remark that I(t) describes the active population that is based on the daily incidence minus the recovered people. III The Prevalence-Incidence Methodological Error A fundamental methodological error occurs when practitioners attempt to calibrate model parameters using daily incidence data (new cases), provided by organizations such as the WHO. The model is structurally formulated to utilize active cases (prevalence), a variable for which reliable statistics are rarely available. In the traditional SIR model, New Daily Cases (NDC)—also referred to as Incidence—is expressed as the rate of flow of individuals from the Susceptible ( S ) compartment to the Infectious ( I ) compartment. Mathematically, the NDC represents the negative rate of change of the susceptible population. In the continuous-time model, it is defined by the following term: NDC(t)=-\frac{dS}{dt}=\beta\frac{S(t)I(t)}{N} (5) • \beta (Transmission Rate): Represents the probability of infection per contact multiplied by the number of contacts per unit of time. • S(t) : The number of individuals susceptible to the disease at time t . • I(t) : The number of infectious individuals currently in the population (prevalence). • N : The total population. In real-world epidemiology, organizations like the WHO report data in discrete intervals (e.g., daily or every 5 days). To match this “generated” clinical data, the NDC over a discrete time

Read the complete text