Cross-feeding yields high-dimensional chaos and coexistence of species beyond exclusion principle
Takashi Shimada, Kunihiko Kaneko · 2026
Read Cross-feeding yields high-dimensional chaos and coexistence of species beyond exclusion principle by Takashi Shimada, Kunihiko Kaneko (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-22564.txt.
Introduction
Takashi Shimada and Kunihiko Kaneko show that microbes feeding on each other's leaks can coexist in wild, chaotic swarms. Species trade chemicals: each leaks metabolites that others take up. Their 2026 preprint studies a simple model of that cross-feeding web.
In the model, many species persist past what the exclusion rule would allow. The system can even fall into high-dimensional chaos, with counts swinging in complex ways. The result helps explain the rich mix seen in real microbial worlds. It ties food-web shape to diversity itself. The model is simple, which makes the result striking.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Takashi Shimada, Kunihiko Kaneko |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-22564
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Cross-feeding yields high-dimensional chaos and coexistence of species beyond exclusion principle Takashi Shimada, Kunihiko Kaneko Abstract Species interactions through cross-feeding via leakage and uptake of chemicals are important in microbial communities, and play an essential role in the coexistence of diverse species. Here, we study a simple dynamical model of a microbial community in which species interact by competing for the uptake of common metabolites that are leaked by other species. The model includes coupled dynamics of species populations and chemical concentrations in the medium, allowing for a variety of uptake and leakage networks among species. Depending on the structure of these networks, the system exhibits different attractors, including fixed points, limit cycles, low-dimensional chaos, and high-dimensional chaos. In the fixed-point and limit-cycle cases, the number of coexisting species is bounded by the number of exchangeable chemicals, consistent with the well-known competitive exclusion principle. In contrast, in the low-dimensional chaotic regime, the number of coexisting species exhibits noticeable but limited excess over this limit. Remarkably, in the high-dimensional chaotic regime, a much larger number of species beyond this limit coexist persistently over time. In this case, the rank-abundance distribution is broader than exponential, as often observed in real ecosystems. The population dynamics displays intermittent switching among quasi-stationary states, while the chemical dynamics explore most of the high dimensions. We find that such high-dimensional chaos is ubiquitous when the number of uptake chemicals is moderately larger than the number of leaked chemicals. Our results identify high-dimensional chaos with intermittent switching as a generic dynamical mechanism that stabilizes coexistence in interacting systems. We discuss its relevance to sustaining diverse microbial communities with leak-uptake cross-feeding. I Introduction Coexistence of diverse species under complex dynamics is a key topic in ecological systems. Traditionally, ecological dynamics have often been investigated by using population dynamics of species with direct species-species interactions. Microbial ecosystems that have gathered much attention recently, however, are not in such situation. The interaction among each species is mediated by chemical resources, and the combined dynamics between chemical concentrations and populations of species is required. How does such interplay between chemical and population dynamics increase the complexity in dynamics with diverse species? In fact, competition for chemical resources among species has been analyzed by classic MacArthur model Macarthur and Levins 1967 . Limit of the number of coexisting species competing for resources has been investigated both experimentally and theoretically Cui et al. 2020 ; Moran and Tikhonov 2022 ; Blumenthal et al. 2024 . In such systems, there is an established relationship between the number of possible coexisting species and the number of resources, as known as the competitive exclusion principle or also as Gause’s law, which states that the former is bounded by the latter Gause 1932 ; Hardin 1960 ; Macarthur and Levins 1967 . Coexistence of diverse species under limited resources, which is sometimes observed, therefore, has been discussed as “paradox of the plankton” Hutchinson 1961 . In addition to resource competitions, microbes often leak chemicals which can be taken up and used by others. The interaction through the uptake and leakage of metabolites (cross-feeding) has recently gained increasing attention. In microbial communities, diverse species or strains coexist while secreting and exchanging hundreds of metabolites Datta et al. 2016 ; Zelezniak et al. 2015 . Even when the supply of resources is limited to single or few chemical components, exchange of chemical secreted by microbes can create new niches with each other, and thereby, diverse species can coexist Goyal and Maslov 2018 ; Goldford et al. 2018 ; D’Souza et al. 2018 ; Rosenzweig et al. 1994 . Such exchange of chemicals can shape mutually symbiotic relationships, rather than parasitism among the microbial species Ponomarova et al. 2017 ; Hillesland and Stahl 2010 ; Wintermute and Silver 2010 . For instance, a possible merit of cross-feeding has been theoretically investigated in a system with a detailed cell dynamics model Yamagishi et al. 2021 . The model includes intracellular dynamics, which is less coarse-grained but is numerically costly for studying the effect of cross-feeding on larger systems. Generally, the diversity of species can increase with the number of exchanged chemical species, as studied theoretically Goyal and Maslov 2018 . Importantly, a network-based approach to the bipartite topology of cross-feeding has shown the emergence of bistability in diversity Clegg and Gross 2025 . However, this further simplified framework so far has taken neither the competition for the leaked metabolites nor dynamical states into account. It has not yet been explored how competition for the leaked chemicals may lead to complex chemical and population dynamics and how such dynamics can shed novel light on the competitive exclusion principle. In the cross-feeding systems, leaked metabolites can be resources of other species, and thus the bound on the coexisting species will generally include the number of exchangeable chemicals by species. The question to be addressed, then, is whether the complex dynamics may further enhance the number of coexisting species. Here we introduce a minimal model of population dynamics to discuss communities with cross-feeding interactions with chemical dynamics. With this model, we demonstrate that cross-feeding can lead to complex dynamics both in population of species and chemical compositions, which may allow for successive alternating species. We will then show that such complex dynamics may allow for diversification of coexisting species, beyond the total number of exchangeable chemical components. II Results II.1 Dynamical leak-uptake model To model systems with both leakage and uptake of exchangeable chemicals, we start from the standard MacAuthor model Moran and Tikhonov 2022 in which N microbial species are competitively using C chemical species (substrates, metabolites, etc.): \dot{x}_{\mu}=\left(-\chi_{\mu}+\sum_{i=1}^{C}\frac{\tau_{\mu i}b_{i}}{1+T_{i}/K_{i}}\right)x_{\mu},\quad T_{i}=\sum_{\nu=1}^{N}x_{\nu}\tau_{\nu i} (1) where \tau_{\mu i} is the matrix that represents the capacity of species \mu to uptake chemical i , and \chi_{\mu}=\chi_{0}+\sum_{i}\chi_{i}\tau_{\mu i} is the base living cost of species \mu which includes the cost of having the uptake capacities. Through the competition, the benefit of the chemical i is reduced from its ideal benefit b_{i} as the total uptake of that chemical over its carrying capacity K_{i} increases. Figure 1: The schematic of the model ecosystem interacting through leak and uptake of chemicals, defined by Eqs. [ 3 ]. The filled symbols represent the chemicals those are leaked and taken by at least one of the species, and the open symbols are for the chemicals those are involved in the metabolic network inside the cells but only taken or leaked by them (i.e. common resource and waste, respectively). When cells cross-feed through the leak and uptake of C exchangeable chemical components which are a subset of the entire set of chemicals needed in their metabolic processes (Fig. 1 ), we need to consider the dynamics of the concentrations of chemicals. Assuming that both the leakage and uptake of the chemicals by the cells are passive (diffusive) and the relaxation dynamics of chemical concentrations is much faster than the growth rates of each population, we can obtain a population dynamics model similar to Eq. 1 , with modified benefit function (see Appendix A1 for the details of the derivation). For simplicity, we assume that cells gain no benefit from leakage itself and that the exchange of chemicals with environment is slower than the