Why Johnny Can’t Think: GenAI’s Impacts on Cognitive Engagement CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI

Rudrajit Choudhuri, Christopher A. Sanchez, Margaret Burnett, Anita Sarma · 2026

Read Why Johnny Can’t Think: GenAI’s Impacts on Cognitive Engagement CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI by Rudrajit Choudhuri, Christopher A. Sanchez, Margaret Burnett, Anita Sarma (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-22430.txt.

Introduction

Rudrajit Choudhuri, Christopher Sanchez, Margaret Burnett, and Anita Sarma ask what daily AI use does to how students think. Their 2026 preprint notes that many students now use generative AI in coursework. Past work looked at one-off help-seeking; this work asks about habit-level shifts.

The team study whether routine use ties to weaker cognitive engagement, the deep work of thought itself. The stakes are high: habits formed in school can last for years. Clear evidence can guide teachers, not just ban or bless the tools. The work frames the right questions. It seeks facts over fear.

Catalog record

CREATORRudrajit Choudhuri, Christopher A. Sanchez, Margaret Burnett, Anita Sarma
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE78 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-22430

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Why Johnny Can’t Think: GenAI’s Impacts on Cognitive Engagement CCS: Human-centered computing Empirical studies in HCI Rudrajit Choudhuri, Christopher A. Sanchez, Margaret Burnett, Anita Sarma Abstract . Context: Many students now use generative AI (genAI) in their coursework, yet its effects on their intellectual development remain poorly understood. While prior work has investigated students’ cognitive offloading during episodic interactions, it remains unclear whether using genAI routinely is tied to more fundamental shifts in students’ thinking habits. Objective : To explore this possibility, we investigate (RQ1-How): how students’ trust in and routine use of genAI affect their cognitive engagement—specifically, reflection, the need for understanding, and critical thinking in STEM coursework. Further, we investigate (RQ2-Who): which students are particularly vulnerable to these cognitive disengagement effects. Method : We drew on dual-process theory, cognitive offloading, and the automation bias literature to develop a statistical model explaining how and to what extent students’ trust-driven routine use of genAI affected their cognitive engagement habits in STEM coursework, and how these effects differed across students’ diverse cognitive styles. We empirically evaluated this model using Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling on survey data from 299 STEM students across five North American universities. Results : Students who trusted and routinely used genAI reported significantly lower cognitive engagement. Unexpectedly, students with higher technophilic motivations, risk tolerance, and computer self-efficacy—traits often celebrated in STEM—were more prone to these effects. Interestingly, students’ prior experience with genAI or academia did not protect them from cognitively disengaging. Implications: Our findings suggest a potential cognitive debt cycle in which routine genAI use progressively weakens students’ intellectual habits, potentially driving over-reliance and escalating usage. This poses critical challenges for curricula and genAI system design, requiring interventions that actively support cognitive engagement. 1. Introduction “People are neither fully rational nor completely selfish — and they are often lazy thinkers.” — Daniel Kahneman Human cognition evolved to be lazy and for good reason. Our ancestors who conserved mental energy for genuine threats survived; those who exhaustively analyzed every decision did not. This “law of least effort” pervades human behavior ( Risko and Gilbert 2016 ; Sparrow et al. 2011 ; Kahneman 2011 ) . We outsource memory to shopping lists, arithmetic to calculators, and navigation to GPS, trading internal cognitive work for external support. Generative AI (genAI) tools (e.g., ChatGPT, Claude, Copilot) tend to amplify this tendency by delivering fluent, confident support on demand. As a result, interacting with genAI involves less “thinking by doing” and more “choosing from outputs” ( Lee et al. 2025 ) . In many domains, this reallocation saves time, improves productivity, and creates a compelling sense of progress ( Butler et al. 2025 ) . But what works for productivity can be problematic for learning. In STEM education, for example, genAI may remove the desirable difficulties students need ( Barcaui 2025 ) : slow, effortful, and often uncomfortable cognitive work that builds intuition and transferable skills ( Chi and Wylie 2014 ) . Students may still produce equal (or even better) quality work yet learn less ( Walker and Vorvoreanu 2025 ) . Recent studies indeed show that genAI assistance reduced depth of inquiry, evidence use, and self-regulatory behaviors in students ( Stadler et al. 2024 ; Fan et al. 2025b ; Kosmyna et al. 2025 ; Barcaui 2025 ; Yan et al. 2025 ; Kreijkes et al. 2025 ) . Moreover, automation bias research shows that when systems appear competent, users trust outputs with limited scrutiny—even when those outputs conflict with their own knowledge or judgment ( Goddard et al. 2012 ; Lyell and Coiera 2017 ) . In human-AI interaction (HAI) contexts, this tendency can manifest as over-reliance ( Choudhuri et al. 2024 ; Hamid et al. 2025 ) , with users incorporating AI suggestions without much critical evaluation ( Buçinca et al. 2021 ; Lee et al. 2025 ) . These effects are amplified in settings that reward immediate efficiency, including professional work ( Butler et al. 2025 ; Lee et al. 2025 ) , and increasingly academic contexts ( Walker and Vorvoreanu 2025 ) , where genAI use is becoming routine. Consider these two scenarios: • Scenario A (episodic) : A student uses genAI to bypass a single difficult problem, showing momentary overreliance and reduced cognitive effort . • Scenario B (routine) : Through trust-driven routine genAI use, that student develops a general unwillingness to engage in reflection, understanding, and critical thinking across coursework —fundamentally recalibrating what cognitive effort investment feels “worth it”. Prior work has largely focused on Scenario A ( Stadler et al. 2024 ; Fan et al. 2025b ; Kosmyna et al. 2025 ; Barcaui 2025 ; Yan et al. 2025 ; Chen et al. 2025 ; Kreijkes et al. 2025 ) . In contrast, this paper focuses on Scenario B—how and to what extent routine use of genAI affects students’ cognitive engagement habits. If such effects exist, does it mean that STEM education is cultivating a generation adept at querying intelligence but unwilling to exercise their own? Will they enter professional work having never developed the cognitive habits that prior generations built through practice? As a first step towards answering these long-term questions, we ask: RQ1-How: To what extent does students’ trust in and routine use of genAI affect their cognitive engagement habits in STEM coursework? Drawing on decades of research in educational psychology and learning sciences ( Dewey 1933 ; Biggs et al. 2001 ; Pintrich and De Groot 1990 ; Kember et al. 2000 ; Bryce and Withers 2003 ; Li et al. 2023 ; Gong et al. 2025 ) , we conceptualize cognitive engagement as three intellectual habits: (1) Reflection (the metacognitive monitoring and evaluation of one’s understanding) ( Dunlosky et al. 2005 ; Kember et al. 2000 ; Silver et al. 2023 ) , (2) Need for understanding (the intrinsic motivation to seek conceptual coherence rather than surface-level correctness) ( Chi 2009 ; Cacioppo and Petty 1982 ; Biggs et al. 2001 ) , and (3) Critical thinking (the analytic evaluation of evidence, assumptions, and alternatives) ( Facione 1990 ; Sosu 2013 ; Facione et al. 2011 ) (detailed in Sec. 3.1 ). Foundational education research shows that these habits foster durable learning and skill development ( Boekaerts et al. 1999 ; Evans et al. 2003 ) ; RQ1-How investigates how/how much all three are simultaneously affected when students trust and routinely offload cognitive work to genAI. However, these effects are unlikely to be the same for all individuals. Prior work shows that differences in individuals’ cognitive styles ( Sternberg and Grigorenko 1997 ; Burnett et al. 2016b ) substantively shape the ways they use technology ( Martínez-Córcoles et al. 2017 ; Anderson et al. 2024 ; Burnett et al. 2016a ; Vorvoreanu et al. 2019 ) . (We expand upon the specific cognitive styles in Sec. 3.2 ). Further, recent HAI studies suggest that these differences, alongside trust, influence how individuals adopt genAI ( Choudhuri et al. 2025d ; Choudhuri et al. 2025a ) . Thus, we ask: RQ2-Who: Who (i.e., students with which cognitive styles) are particularly prone to cognitive disengagement? Our study makes three contributions: (1) a theoretically grounded statistical model explaining (for RQ1-How) how students’

Read the complete text