Active Learning vs Traditional Lecturing in Introductory Mechanics: A Pooled Pass-Rate Benchmark Under Common Departmental Assessments from a Latin American Institutional Change Initiative

Isaac Pérez Castillo, Lidia Jiménez Lara, Orlando Guzman, Juan Ernesto Chavero Amador, Juan Miguel Carrillo Gil, Luis Alberto González Flores, Miguel Angel Morales Olvera, Oscar Enrique Bonfil Urbalejo, Eric Burkholder · 2026

Read Active Learning vs Traditional Lecturing in Introductory Mechanics: A Pooled Pass-Rate Benchmark Under Common Departmental Assessments from a Latin American Institutional Change Initiative by Isaac Pérez Castillo, Lidia Jiménez Lara, Orlando Guzman, Juan Ernesto Chavero Amador, Juan Miguel Carrillo Gil, Luis Alberto González Flores, Miguel Angel Morales Olvera, Oscar Enrique Bonfil Urbalejo, Eric Burkholder (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-22428.txt.

Introduction

Isaac Pérez Castillo and four co-authors pool pass rates to judge active learning against plain lectures in first physics courses. Their 2026 preprint notes that research-backed teaching has grown for decades, yet student success still lags. They also stress a gap: few reports come from Latin American classes.

The team set a shared bar so pooled classes can be judged fairly. A common-gauge pool gives a cleaner read than lone class tales. The results can guide departments that must choose how to teach. They also lift a region's voice in the debate. The work is careful, shared evidence.

Catalog record

CREATORIsaac Pérez Castillo, Lidia Jiménez Lara, Orlando Guzman, Juan Ernesto Chavero Amador, Juan Miguel Carrillo Gil, Luis Alberto González Flores, Miguel Angel Morales Olvera, Oscar Enrique Bonfil Urbalejo, Eric Burkholder
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-22428

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Active Learning vs Traditional Lecturing in Introductory Mechanics: A Pooled Pass-Rate Benchmark Under Common Departmental Assessments from a Latin American Institutional Change Initiative Isaac Pérez Castillo, Lidia Jiménez Lara, Orlando Guzman, Juan Ernesto Chavero Amador, Juan Miguel Carrillo Gil, Luis Alberto González Flores, Miguel Angel Morales Olvera, Oscar Enrique Bonfil Urbalejo, Eric Burkholder Abstract Improving student success in introductory physics remains a persistent challenge despite the substantial progress made using research-based instructional practices in recent decades. Further, there is a dearth of literature which describes the implementation of these practices in the Latin American context, where resources for instructional change and implementation are often constrained. This study reports a transparent benchmark study of student passing outcomes in Elementary Mechanics I at a large, public university in México between sections using Active Learning (AL) and sections using Traditional Lecturing (TL). The labels AL and TL are operational: they refer to section-level implementations by individual faculty rather than to perfectly standardized protocols, where instructors were given the agency to use a variety of techniques in both AL and TL. Using aggregated counts from group reports prepared by the course’s coordinator and common departmental assessments–i.e., assessments written by a committee independent of the mode of instruction–we estimated pooled student-level pass probabilities for the first midterm exam, the second midterm exam, the global exam, and the final mark. Modality differences are summarized primarily by the risk difference, defined as R ​ D a = p AL , a − p TL , a RD_{a}=p_{\mathrm{AL},a}-p_{\mathrm{TL},a} (given in percentage points), complemented by uncertainty quantification using (i) Wilson confidence intervals for pooled pass rates and (ii) a Bayesian reference analysis with Jeffreys priors for binomial proportions. Across assessments, pooled pass rates were higher under AL than under TL, with the strongest separation observed for the global (final comprehensive) exam and for the final mark. The 95 % 95\% confidence intervals for the global exam and the final mark did not include zero, even when using a random-intercept Bayesian model. We emphasize a constrained interpretation of these results consistent with the available data: the results provide a student-weighted benchmark of “AL as implemented” versus “TL as implemented” in this setting, but do not isolate the causal effect of any single instructional technique. Implications are discussed for departmental decision-making and for feasible next steps in evaluation, including improved student data collection in future terms and more robust qualitative analysis of the change initiative. I Introduction Introductory physics courses occupy a consequential role in STEM curricula: they are both foundational for subsequent coursework and, for many students, the first sustained encounter with formal quantitative modeling. In many departments, however, these courses remain characterized by low pass rates and high repetition rates, which carry substantial academic and institutional costs. These challenges are often amplified in settings where entering preparation is heterogeneous 4 ; 5 , class sizes are large, and instructional resources are constrained—conditions that are common across a wide range of institutions, including many in Latin America. In such contexts, improving passing outcomes is not merely an administrative target; it is tightly linked to persistence in STEM pathways 20 , equity of opportunity, and the feasibility of scaling high-quality instruction. Over the past five decades, Physics Education Research (PER) and the broader science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) education literature have converged on a robust empirical finding: instructional approaches that engage students actively in sense-making, and are based in theories of cognition, tend to improve learning and reduce failure rates in large-enrollment courses relative to purely didactic lecturing 9 ; 22 ; 7 ; 10 ; 15 . The umbrella term active learning covers a family of practices rooted in constructivist theories 16 such as Ericsson’s theory of “deliberate practice” 8 ; 12 . These practices are broadly characterized by a shift from students listening to doing in the classroom, with the instructor orchestrating frequent formative assessment and targeted explanation. This can be through the use of in-class “clicker” questions, as in Peer Instruction, the use of educational simulations, and guided group problem-solving activities, to name a few examples. The literature also stresses that outcomes depend on local implementation: the specific practices adopted, the fidelity with which they are sustained, instructor experience, course constraints, and the degree to which assessments are aligned with intended learning goals 25 . These challenges can make it difficult for instructors to affect sustained instructional change 6 . Though the evidence in support of active learning is overwhelming—to the point that many now argue that it should be treated as the standard of care when conducting research on learning strategies 14 ; 24 —there is simultaneously a dearth of research on the implementation of these practices in student populations beyond those at predominantly white, research-intensive, doctoral-granting universities in the United States and Europe 13 . This raises important questions about generalizability of the findings, particularly those concerning large-scale instructional change efforts. This paper documents the first results from an institutional-scale implementation of active learning at a large, urban research university in México which offers primarily STEM degrees, where improving gateway-course outcomes is an urgent priority. As a result, the academic unit has begun a coordinated instructional change effort for which introductory physics was selected as a testbed. We report results from the pilot term of this program Elementary Mechanics I (EM1) in the Autumn trimester 2025 (coded at this institution as 25-O), using common departmental assessments that allow comparisons across sections under a shared grading standard. While the experimental design of comparing student outcomes in active learning classrooms to traditional lecturing is not novel, the context in which this study was conducted is comparatively understudied in the PER literature because of the student population and the context of the instructional change initiative. The goal is to provide a transparent benchmark of student passing outcomes under AL as implemented versus TL as implemented in this setting, using official, aggregated records. Our research questions are: (1) Under a shared departmental assessment standard, how do pooled student-level pass probabilities differ between AL-labeled and TL-labeled sections across the major assessments of the course? (2) Are any observed differences consistent across midterm exams, the global exam, and the final mark? The remainder of the paper is organized as follows. Section II describes the initiative and the operational meaning of the AL and TL labels in this implementation. Section III documents the data provenance and caveats associated with aggregated reporting. Section IV presents the statistical analysis and discussion of the results, including both frequentist uncertainty intervals and a Bayesian reference analysis. Section V concludes with implications for instructional decision-making and priorities for future evaluation. II Background and Institutional Context At our institution, historical outcomes in the core physics curriculum have been a persistent concern for student progression and for the sustainability of teaching loads. In 2025, the Departamento de Física at this university, under the lead of the new core curriculum coordinator, launched an active-learning initiative aimed at improving gateway-course outcomes while maintaining a common assessment standard. The implementation was designed as an institutional-scale intervention that includes instructor and teaching assistant (TA) preparation, explicit alignment of course activities with shared learning goals, and observational monitoring of classroom practices to document and

Read the complete text