How isotropic is dark energy?

Richard A. Battye, Adam Moss · 2026

Read How isotropic is dark energy? by Richard A. Battye, Adam Moss (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-22351.txt.

Introduction

Richard Battye and Adam Moss ask a plain question: must dark energy push the same way in all directions? Dark energy drives the late growth of the cosmos. Their 2026 preprint lets the push vary by direction and by time, in a stretched-space model.

They shape the model so a key bound from the faint early glow holds by design. That bound comes from how the glow's heat shifts as it crosses space. The work maps how much warp the data still allow. It tests a core claim of the standard cosmic story.

Catalog record

CREATORRichard A. Battye, Adam Moss
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-22351

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

How isotropic is dark energy? Richard A. Battye, Adam Moss Abstract Tensions in late-time expansion data have renewed interest in models beyond Λ \Lambda CDM. We ask: how isotropic must dark energy be? Working in Bianchi I, we allow time-dependent anisotropic stress and introduce a parameterisation that enforces a vanishing line-of-sight integral of the shear, thereby satisfying the CMB ISW quadrupole bound by construction. Using Pantheon+SH0ES SNe together with DESI BAO distances, single-bin (constant) and five-bin anisotropic models improve the fit over w w CDM by Δ ⁡ ( − 2 ​ ln ⁡ ℒ iso ) = 14.8 \Delta(-2\ln\mathcal{L}_{\rm iso})=14.8 and 26.6 26.6 respectively, but both violate the quadrupole constraint. In contrast, a five-bin constrained model achieves Δ ⁡ ( − 2 ​ ln ⁡ ℒ iso ) = 15.4 \Delta(-2\ln\mathcal{L}_{\rm iso})=15.4 while remaining compatible with the quadrupole limit. The fit improvement arises from two sources: capturing directional structure in the Pantheon+ SNe data, and partially alleviating the tension between the SH0ES H 0 H_{0} value and DESI BAO distances. I Introduction The origin of the dark energy that drives the observed acceleration 23 ; 22 is one of the great mysteries of modern cosmology 12 . Within the framework of the homogeneous and isotropic Friedmann-Robertson-Walker (FRW) model, acceleration requires the density, \rho_{\rm de} , and pressure, P_{\rm de} , to have an equation of state parameter w=P_{\rm de}/\rho_{\rm de}<-\textstyle{\frac{1}{3}} which violates the Strong Energy Condition (SEC). For many years the consensus has been that this dark energy comes from a cosmological constant, \Lambda , with w=-1 . Recent observations from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) 2 ; 18 when combined with those from the Planck Satellite 3 ; 5 and of Type Ia Supernovae (SNe) 27 ; 1 ; 24 have been used to claim evidence that w is not only time-varying, but that w<-1 is required at some point during the evolution of the Universe. This is a significant challenge to the orthodoxy of the \Lambda CDM model, even though combining so many probes requires care since it can amplify any systematic uncertainties. Given these tensions in the standard model, it is worth exploring alternative frameworks. Anisotropic dark energy models represent one such possibility, allowing the pressure to vary with direction. In the Bianchi I cosmological framework, dark energy can exhibit different pressures along different spatial axes, characterized by an anisotropic stress tensor. Previous observational constraints on cosmic anisotropy have been derived from diverse probes: CMB temperature and polarization anisotropies limit large-scale shear to \sigma_{0}/H_{0}\lesssim 10^{-10} 25 , while Type Ia SNe analyses have found evidence for preferred directions at various significance levels 7 ; 11 , with recent Pantheon+ studies reporting dipole 28 ; 26 and quadrupole 13 signatures. However, direct fits of anisotropic Bianchi models to SNe data yield much larger shear parameters 29 , creating tension with early-universe constraints. The challenge for anisotropic dark energy models is to produce observable late-time signatures while remaining consistent with the stringent constraints from the CMB 8 . Several dark-energy and modified gravity models admit spatially homogeneous but anisotropic backgrounds, providing a microphysical rationale for a time-dependent anisotropic equation of state \Delta w(a) . One example is ‘‘solid’’ (elastic) dark energy 1 1 1 Early work on solid dark energy 9 ; 10 considered an isotropic background but anisotropic perturbations, due to a direction dependent sound speed. , built from a triad of scalar fields arranged so that homogeneity is preserved even though rotational invariance is broken, which can yield anisotropic accelerated attractors 19 . Other possibilities include spatial vector-field dark energy, where a spacelike background vector picks out a preferred axis and the resulting Bianchi I system exhibits scaling and accelerating solutions in dynamical-systems analyses 17 . Higher-form fields provide another route: interacting two-form models have been studied directly in a Bianchi I background and can admit late-time de Sitter-like attractors with non-trivial anisotropy 20 . Finally, preferred-frame theories such as Einstein–æther constructions also support homogeneous anisotropic cosmologies, including Bianchi I solutions 6 . In this paper we explore time-dependent anisotropic dark energy within the Bianchi I framework. We develop a novel parameterization that circumvents the stringent CMB constraints through a constrained basis function approach that automatically ensures the integrated shear vanishes over cosmic time. We then apply this framework to fit the complete Pantheon+SH0ES SNe dataset, constraining both the amplitude and temporal evolution of anisotropic dark energy. II Bianchi I universe The Bianchi classification can be used to describe homogeneous, anisotropic, expanding spacetimes 14 . For the purposes of our discussion we will use the Bianchi I model which can be thought of as having non-isotropic pressure and different scale factors in each of the 3 coordinate directions. It can be formulated using the flat metric 21 ds^{2}=a(\eta)^{2}\left(-d\eta^{2}+\gamma_{ij}(\eta)\,dx^{i}dx^{j}\right)\,. (1) The Friedmann equation is 3{\cal H}^{2}=8\pi Ga^{2}\rho_{\rm tot}+\textstyle{1\over 2}\sigma^{2}\,, (2) where \sigma_{ij}=\textstyle{1\over 2}\gamma_{ij}^{\prime} , \sigma^{2}=\sigma_{i}^{j}\sigma_{j}^{i} and {\cal H}=a^{\prime}/a where ′ denotes derivative with respect to \eta . We will consider a Universe where the total density is \rho_{\rm tot}=\rho_{\rm m}+\rho_{\rm de} where \rho_{\rm m}\propto a^{-3} is the matter density. The pressure tensor for the dark energy will be assumed to be anisotropic and of the form P_{i}^{j}=\rho_{\rm de}\left[w_{\rm de}\delta_{i}^{j}+\Delta w_{i}^{j}\right]\,, (3) where w_{\rm de} is a constant, but the traceless anisotropic equation of state parameter \Delta w_{i}^{j}\equiv\Delta w_{i}^{j}(\eta) is time-dependent. The dark energy density \rho_{\rm de} and shear \sigma_{i}^{j} satisfy 8 \displaystyle\rho_{\rm de}^{\prime} \displaystyle= \displaystyle-3{\cal H}(1+w_{\rm de})\rho_{\rm de}-\sigma_{i}^{j}\Delta w_{j}^{i}\rho_{\rm de}\,, (4) \displaystyle\sigma_{i}^{j\,\prime} \displaystyle= \displaystyle-2{\cal H}\sigma_{i}^{j}+8\pi Ga^{2}\Delta w_{i}^{j}\rho_{\rm de}\,. (5) Without loss of generality we choose the principal-axis frame, aligning the symmetry axis with \hat{z} (i.e. \hat{\lambda}\parallel\hat{z} ), so that \Delta w_{i}{}^{j}=\mathrm{diag}(\Delta w_{1},\Delta w_{2},-[\Delta w_{1}+\Delta w_{2}]) . Allowing time variation provides significant freedom in choosing these components, which we exploit in our parameterization. III Integrated Sachs-Wolfe (ISW) effect Anisotropic dark energy models generate an ISW effect in the CMB through the integrated shear along photon paths. The temperature anisotropy is given by {\Delta T\over T}=-\int_{\eta_{\rm rec}}^{\eta_{0}}\sigma_{ij}(\eta)n^{i}n^{j}d\eta\,, (6) where n^{i} is the line-of-sight direction, \eta_{0} is the present conformal time, and \eta_{\rm rec} is the conformal time at recombination. This generates a CMB temperature quadrupole with coefficients a_{2m}^{\rm aniso} . Treating these as a 5-vector, the inflationary and anisotropic contributions add with an arbitrary relative orientation. Since the observed quadrupole is lower than the \Lambda CDM prediction, cancellation between these contributions is possible, implying the envelope \bigl(\sqrt{D_{2}^{\rm inf}}-\sqrt{D_{2}^{\rm obs}}\bigr)^{2}\;\leq\;D_{2}^{\rm aniso}\;\leq\;\bigl(\sqrt{D_{2}^{\rm inf}}+\sqrt{D_{2}^{\rm obs}}\bigr)^{2}, (7) where superscripts “obs/inf/aniso” denote observed, inflationary, and anisotropic values, and D_{\ell}\equiv\ell(\ell+1)C_{\ell}/(2\pi) . Using D_{2}^{\rm obs}\approx 226~\mu\mathrm{K}^{2} (Planck DR3 4 ) and D_{2}^{\rm inf}\approx 1000~\mu\mathrm{K}^{2} ( \Lambda CDM), this yields an approximate range D_{2}^{\rm aniso}\in\bigl[\,275\,,\,2177\,\bigr]~\mu\mathrm{K}^{2}. (8) This envelope places a restrictive upper bound on anisotropic contributions, yet it has been neglected in recent SNe-based analyses 29 . IV Parameterization We choose the axisymmetric case \Delta w_{1}=\Delta w_{2}=\Delta w(a) and parameterize \Delta w(a) using a piecewise constant representation (bins) over the interval a\in[a_{*},a_{0}] . We divide the interval into N bins with contiguous top-hat functions B_{k}(a) \Delta w(a)=\sum_{k=0}^{N-1}c_{k}B_{k}(a)\,, (9) where c_{k} represents the constant value of \Delta w(a) in the k -th bin. We will choose a_{*}=1/4 (corresponding to z_{*}=3 ) as this is the region most relevant for dark energy. In the axisymmetric case, the shear

Read the complete text