When inflationary perturbations refuse to classicalise: the role of non-Gaussianity in Wigner negativity
Aurora Ireland, Vincent Vennin · 2026
Read When inflationary perturbations refuse to classicalise: the role of non-Gaussianity in Wigner negativity by Aurora Ireland, Vincent Vennin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-22219.txt.
Introduction
Aurora Ireland and Vincent Vennin ask whether the seeds of galaxies ever lost their quantum traits. Their 2026 preprint studies the tiny ripples born in the fast growth of the early cosmos. Most work treats those ripples as plain chance fields, like tossed dice.
The pair look for a sign that the ripples stayed truly quantum. They focus on phase links between branches of the state, which can leave marks of quantum clash. They also weigh how odd, non-bell-shaped spread in the ripples shapes that sign. The work tests a deep claim about cosmic birth.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Aurora Ireland, Vincent Vennin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 112 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-22219
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
When inflationary perturbations refuse to classicalise: the role of non-Gaussianity in Wigner negativity Aurora Ireland, Vincent Vennin Abstract Inflationary perturbations are quantum in origin. Yet, when computing cosmological observables, they are often treated as classical stochastic fields. Do they nevertheless retain quantum birthmarks? A hallmark of genuinely quantum behaviour is quantum interferences, arising from phase coherence between distinct branches of the wavefunction. Such interference is diagnosed by the non-positivity of the Wigner function, and according to Hudson’s theorem, the only pure states with positive Wigner functions are Gaussian states. Consequently, any departure from Gaussianity necessarily implies a non-positive Wigner function, precluding a description in terms of a classical distribution. This motivates us to compute the Wigner function of curvature perturbations, accounting for primordial non-Gaussianities, using the EFT of inflation. We find that the Wigner function develops pronounced interference fringes on super-Hubble scales, and in particular its negativity grows as a 2 a^{2} in ultra-slow-roll backgrounds. These results demonstrate that quantum effects can remain significant at late times, and that squeezing alone does not ensure classicality, contrary to standard lore. This suggests that the prospects for detecting genuinely quantum signatures of the universe’s origins in cosmological observables may be less bleak than previously thought. 1 Introduction The leading paradigm for the formation of cosmic structure in our universe posits that it originates from quantum fluctuations of the vacuum during an early epoch of inflation 111 ; 106 ; 52 ; 68 ; 7 . As the comoving Hubble horizon shrinks, these fluctuations are stretched to super-Hubble scales, where they undergo parametric amplification. Later, following the end of inflation and a period of reheating, the perturbations re-enter the horizon during either radiation or matter domination, subsequently evolving into the density perturbations that seed the large-scale structure observed today. The predicted spectrum and statistical properties of these perturbations 110 ; 92 ; 51 ; 113 ; 11 are in exceptional agreement with observations of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) anisotropies 5 . In this picture, inflationary perturbations are fundamentally quantum in origin. In practice, however, there are many contexts in which it is appropriate to treat these quantum fields as classical stochastic variables. In particular, two-point correlation functions can always be reproduced with a stochastic description 84 : one simply needs to consider a Gaussian random field whose covariance matrix matches the quantum two-point expectation values of the underlying quantum field. A standard approach in cosmology is thus to start from stochastic, Gaussian initial conditions at the end of inflation and evolve them as classical fields afterwards, according to the equations of cosmological perturbation theory. This standard practice raises two issues, however. First, at the practical level, it is not guaranteed that it properly captures higher-point statistics. Second, at the conceptual level, how a definite classical field configuration emerges from a quantum superposition of states remains elusive (this is the so-called quantum measurement problem). Quantum-to-classical transition The usual way to sidestep both problems and justify the replacement of quantum operators by classical stochastic fields is to assume that some sort of quantum-to-classical transition occurs at super-Hubble scales during inflation. Note that this transition is also essential to the stochastic approach to inflation 115 , which provides an effective description of the long-wavelength modes by modeling the influence of shorter-wavelength fluctuations as an effective noise term. There are two main arguments in support of such a transition. First, on super-Hubble scales the the Heisenberg-picture curvature perturbation operator can be decomposed into a frozen mode and a decaying mode. The commutator between the curvature perturbation and its conjugate momentum, when compared with the anti-commutator, scales as the decaying mode, and hence becomes strongly suppressed. This has been argued to render the field and its momentum approximately commuting, and thus “classical” 96 ; 64 ; 58 ; 59 ; 35 . 1 1 1 This is sometimes referred to as “decoherence without decoherence”, although we shall avoid such terminology since cosmological perturbations are described by a pure (i.e. non-decohered) state in this approach. In the Schrödinger picture, this corresponds to quantum squeezing 50 : as the quantum state becomes localised along one phase-space direction, the squeezed direction becomes too suppressed to be measured, and the commutator cannot be accessed. However, this criterion is not invariant under field reparametrisations: by performing a phase-space rotation, the anti-commutator between the field and its momentum can always be made zero, contrary to the commutator whose size is fixed by \hbar . More generally, squeezing can always be undone by an appropriate linear canonical transformation 46 , and hence it does not capture intrinsic (in technical terms, symplectic-invariant) properties of the quantum state 1 . Second, curvature perturbations do not form an isolated system: they may interact with other fields present in the early universe, becoming entangled with them. Even in the absence of other fields, gravitational self-interactions inevitably couple observable scales to inaccessible, small-wavelength modes 23 . There also exists entanglement in real space between the spatial regions inside and outside our observable horizon 108 . When tracing over these environmental degrees of freedom, curvature perturbations need to be described by an open quantum system, subject to decoherence 55 . In the “pointer basis” selected by the interaction, quantum interferences become strongly suppressed 123 , and the system effectively behaves as a statistical mixture of states, rather than a coherent superposition 20 ; 69 ; 24 ; 90 ; 108 ; 94 ; 107 ; 87 ; 86 ; 78 ; 31 ; 32 ; 34 ; 23 ; 70 . Can we prove that cosmic structures have a quantum-mechanical origin? Even though decoherence does not solve the quantum measurement problem 117 ; 81 , it erases some of the quantum signatures in primordial perturbations, making it difficult to establish whether cosmological structures are of quantum origin. In this work, we address this question while neglecting the role of decoherence for two main reasons. First, as we shall see, the framework we develop is already quite involved even for closed systems, and so we postpone the inclusion of environmental effects to future works in order to better organise the discussion. This also allows us to critically assess the role of squeezing (if any), which is already present at the pure-state level. Second, even if decoherence is effective, it does not necessarily imply that all quantum features are erased: as shown in 78 , what matters is the rate at which decoherence proceeds, rather than the final amount. 2 2 2 Concretely, in inflating spacetimes for decoherence to erase self-entanglement within curvature perturbations, purity needs to decay faster than a^{-4} , where a is the scale factor. There have been several attempts to reveal the presence of genuine quantum features in primordial perturbations. These range from calculating entanglement measures such as quantum discord 67 ; 84 , to constructing Bell 25 ; 76 ; 82 ; 29 ; 85 ; 56 or Leggett-Garg 83 ; 9 inequalities, to searching for features in the primordial bispectrum 49 ; 48 ; 14 . These analyses reveal substantial entanglement between opposite Fourier modes, which are spontaneously created from the quantum vacuum. However, this does not lead to significant entanglement between disjoint regions of physical