Convergent sum of EFT corrections to Schwarzschild metric requires UV locality

Yang Liu, Alexey S. Koshelev, Anna Tokareva, Ziyue Zhu · 2026

Read Convergent sum of EFT corrections to Schwarzschild metric requires UV locality by Yang Liu, Alexey S. Koshelev, Anna Tokareva, Ziyue Zhu (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-22105.txt.

Introduction

Yang Liu, Alexey Koshelev, Anna Tokareva, and Ziyue Zhu test whether corrections to Einstein's black hole can pile up forever. In effective field theory, the Schwarzschild solution of general relativity receives small corrections at every order of a derivative expansion. The authors focus on the region far from the horizon.

They find the dominant corrections at all orders, and their title states the punchline. The sum of corrections converges only if the underlying theory respects UV locality, a constraint from high-energy physics. Their 2026 preprint turns a formal series into a diagnostic. If future observations ever measure deviations around black holes, this work helps say which theories could produce them consistently.

Catalog record

CREATORYang Liu, Alexey S. Koshelev, Anna Tokareva, Ziyue Zhu
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-22105

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Convergent sum of EFT corrections to Schwarzschild metric requires UV locality Yang Liu, Alexey S. Koshelev, Anna Tokareva, Ziyue Zhu Abstract Corrections to vacuum black hole solutions of general relativity (GR) are considered in an effective field theory (EFT) framework, perturbatively in EFT coefficients, focusing on the Schwarzschild solution of GR. We find dominant corrections to the Schwarzschild metric in all orders in the derivative expansion far away from the horizon. These corrections can be summed up in a closed form through EFT coefficients up to all orders in derivatives and to the second order in curvature. It occurs that such a summation is convergent only for localizable theories, making a direct connection between the graviton scattering amplitudes properties and the applicability of a perturbative treatment of an EFT of gravity. We further apply our results to logarithmic form-factors which appear in the 1-loop effective action for GR in four dimensions. We find out that the corresponding corrections to the Schwarzschild metric are stronger than those from the tree-level EFT operators. The developed framework can be extended to account for the corrections to the other BH solutions in GR, such as the Kerr metric. I Introduction Corrections to General Relativity (GR) are inevitable and appear in many contexts. Construction of the 1-loop effective action Deser:1976yx ; Fradkin:1978yw ; Fradkin:1978yf ; Barvinsky:1983vpp to GR revealed the appearance of higher curvature and higher derivative, and even non-local operators. String corrections suggest that higher curvature corrections naturally arise Zwiebach:1985uq . An Effective Field Theory (EFT) approach Weinberg:1980wa to GR Donoghue:1994dn generates an infinite tower of operators of all positive mass dimensions arranged in Hilbert series Ruhdorfer:2019qmk . The more recent idea of asymptotic safety in gravity Dou:1997fg ; Percacci:2007sz ; Reuter:1996cp ; Reuter:2001ag ; Knorr:2019atm brings out a construction based on the RG flow considerations and the existence of an asymptotically safe fixed point. This construction consists of various terms in addition to an initial GR action arranged with the help of operator functions of the d’Alembertian, the so-called form-factors. Moreover, an idea of higher and infinite derivative gravity theories was developed by many authors in an attempt to pinpoint a unitary and renormalizable gravity theory Stelle:1976gc ; Krasnikov:1987yj ; Krasnikov:2024jld ; Kuzmin:1989sp ; Tomboulis:1997gg ; Modesto:2011kw ; Biswas:2016egy . Presence of new terms in an action nearly always implies that known solutions should be modified. In particular, known black hole (BH) solutions of GR are expected to change upon inclusion of GR corrections. Despite several known results (see Boulware:1985wk for a BH solution with a Gauss-Bonnet term in 5 dimensions and a short review Garraffo:2008hu regarding exact BH solutions in Lanczos-Lovelock models of gravity Padmanabhan:2013xyr ), solving gravitational field equations in generalized theories of gravity is known to be a problem of immense difficulty. Very interesting results were obtained in quadratic gravity Stelle:1976gc combining analytic and perturbative methods Lu:2015cqa ; Lu:2015psa . However, in a case when corrections to GR are treated perturbatively, one can also implement perturbative schemes to find corrections to known GR solutions. In this case coefficients of the GR corrections play the role of small perturbation parameters. Perturbative corrections to BH solutions in such an approach in an EFT of GR were intensively studied. Remarkable results concerning the corrections to the metric of vacuum BH solutions are presented in Kats:2006xp ; Cheung:2016yqr ; Melville:2024zjq ; Arkani-Hamed:2021ajd ; Bueno:2024dgm ; Bueno:2025qjk ; Wang:2022sbp ; Boyce:2025fpr ; Miguel:2023rzp . Recently, such corrections for the case of near extremal Kerr metric received a lot of attention due to the significant modifications in the observables Horowitz:2023xyl . Finding and analyzing the dominant perturbative corrections to all orders in an EFT of gravity expansion far away from the horizon to BH solutions in GR using Schwarzschild as the primary departure point comprises the context of the present paper. It is clear that in the case of EFT expansion, a set of operators determined by the Hilbert series represents a derivative expansion. It means that the perturbations are, in fact, higher derivative terms compared to those already present in the model. This can give more solutions to equations of motion, including unstable ones. In the EFT context, one should be careful not to take such solutions into account, as they usually cannot be properly described by EFT, since the EFT description will break. The very existence of such unstable solutions depends on the UV completion, which is unknown in the case of gravity. Moreover, even for small corrections to GR solutions, it is not guaranteed that the perturbative construction of the solution is a convergent procedure. There are two reasons for this. The first reason is as follows. Consider the EFT corrected action truncated to a certain order of mass dimension and derivatives. As the equations are nonlinear, the next order in EFT couplings of the truncated action may be larger than the previous one for certain values of the spacetime coordinates (presumably, in the near-horizon limit of a BH). This can well be the case of near-extremal BH-s, where linear order in EFT couplings naively predicts a near-horizon EFT breakdown Horowitz:2024dch . However, it seems to be more accurate to expect that in reality, this behavior corresponds to the breaking of the linear approximation of the perturbative scheme of constructing a corrected solution Horowitz:2022mly ; Horowitz:2023xyl ; Horowitz:2024dch ; Horowitz:2024kcx ; Chen:2024sgx ; DelPorro:2025fiu . The other reason is connected to the truncation of the infinite sequence of the EFT operators. The question is whether it is correct to assume that only a finite subset of operators is responsible for the dynamics at low energies, even below the cutoff scale. It is important to note at this point that consistent EFTs having unitary, causal, and local UV completion must have an infinite subset of operators leading to the s^{n} terms in the forward limit ( t\to 0_{-} ) of the 2\rightarrow 2 scattering amplitudes Adams:2006sv ( s,t,u are standard Mandelstam variables here). These terms are constrained by positivity bounds and are required to be present without a large hierarchy among them Hong:2023zgm . In general, corrections to BH solutions generated by EFT operators should form a power series in 1/r . One would naively expect that for a large enough BH, only the first corrections are important. But the situation can be more subtle because under a certain choice of the sequence of EFT couplings, these series can have too small (not allowing to continue the solution from spatial infinity to the horizon) or even zero radius of convergence. In our work, we focus on studying whether and when a perturbative approximation scheme for finding a vacuum BH solution in the EFT of gravity will be well defined and result in a physically meaningful outcome. We mainly consider an EFT parametrization capturing, among any given mass dimension, all the operators with the maximal number of derivatives acting on a metric field. Such operators are naturally expected to provide dominant corrections to BH solutions among those of the same mass dimension, and these operators have the form {\cal O}_{n}=C_{\mu\nu\lambda\rho}\,\frac{\square^{n}}{\Lambda^{2n}}\,C^{\mu\nu\lambda\rho} (1) for n\geq 0 where C_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta} is the Weyl tensor, \Box is the covariant d’Alembert operator, and \Lambda is the mass parameter associated with the

Read the complete text