Reformulating Energy Storage Capacity Accreditation Problem with Marginal Reliability Impact

Qian Zhang, Feng Zhao, Tongxin Zheng, Le Xie · 2026

Read Reformulating Energy Storage Capacity Accreditation Problem with Marginal Reliability Impact by Qian Zhang, Feng Zhao, Tongxin Zheng, Le Xie (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-22096.txt.

Introduction

Qian Zhang, Feng Zhao, Tongxin Zheng, and Le Xie revisit how energy storage gets credited in capacity markets. Many United States electricity markets are adopting marginal accreditation reforms, judging each resource by the reliability it adds at the margin. Storage complicates that judgment, since a battery's value depends on when it discharges.

The authors reformulate the storage accreditation problem using Marginal Reliability Impact, a measure of how a resource changes the risk of shortfalls. Their 2026 preprint draws new insights from that framing. As grids add storage at scale, accreditation rules gain weight. They decide what gets built and paid for. Getting the storage math right shapes the future grid's reliability and cost.

Catalog record

CREATORQian Zhang, Feng Zhao, Tongxin Zheng, Le Xie
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-22096

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Reformulating Energy Storage Capacity Accreditation Problem with Marginal Reliability Impact Qian Zhang, Feng Zhao, Tongxin Zheng, Le Xie Abstract To enhance the efficiency of capacity markets, many electricity markets in the U.S. are adopting or planning to implement marginal capacity accreditation reforms. This paper provides new insights into energy storage capacity accreditation using Marginal Reliability Impact (MRI). We reformulate the commonly used reliability-based storage dispatch model as an optimization problem, enabling direct calculation of the MRI from the Lagrange multipliers, rather than using brute-force perturbation analysis. The analysis demonstrates that the EUE is a piecewise linear function and the storage MRI retains a non-negative property across various system scenarios. We further explore the influence of qualified capacity (QC), storage dispatch rules, and other key factors on storage accreditation, providing practical insights for system operators. Additionally, comparisons of storage capacity accreditation under different reliability criteria offer valuable guidance for policymakers in setting future standards. Numerical results from a modified California system validate our findings and highlight several important phenomena associated with the MRI-based accreditation scheme. I Introduction The Forward Capacity Market (FCM) ensures long-term resource adequacy in deregulated electricity markets by providing financial incentives for resources to commit their capacity in advance, thereby meeting reliability standards typically defined by a loss of load expectation (LOLE) of ”one day in ten years.” [ 13 , 4 ] . However, the rapid integration of renewable energy and energy storage technologies has introduced new challenges to the conventional FCM framework due to the intermittent and variable nature of renewables and the unique operational characteristics of storage. In recent years, many Independent System Operators (ISOs) have been exploring or implementing new reforms targeting both the demand and supply sides of the FCM [ 11 , 19 , 21 , 17 ] . On the demand side, the capacity demand curve has been reconstructed from fixed capacity requirements or vertical lines to price-elastic demand curves based on the estimation of marginal reliability benefits of capacity and the value of loss load (VOLL) in FCM [ 11 , 35 ] . On the supply side, seasonal and locational factors have been incorporated into resource models to make the Resource Adequacy Assessment (RAA) process more precise, while capacity accreditation methods are being re-evaluated to appropriately account for the diverse contributions of different resources to system reliability [ 21 , 36 , 17 ] . Additional reform suggestions from the academic community have also contributed by exploring innovative methods to address the complexities of an evolving resource mix [ 3 , 30 , 32 , 39 ] . Together, these efforts aim to establish a framework where accredited capacity is more substitutable across resource types, thereby enhancing market efficiency and facilitating the transition to a decarbonized grid. Among all the different reform ideas, marginal capacity accreditation has become a pivotal element in both demand and supply side reforms across most ISOs in the US. Unlike average methods, which compensate each resource based on the aggregate reliability benefit of all units of that resource type, the marginal approach compensates resources based on the incremental reliability benefit provided by the next unit of that type [ 16 ] . The marginal methodology offers a more precise investment signal to market participants, reflecting the true reliability value of various resources. Recognizing these advantages, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) has approved marginal-based accreditation reforms for several ISOs in the past years [ 8 , 9 ] . Currently, there are two primary methods used in this context: marginal effective load carrying capability (ELCC) and MRI. While marginal ELCC and MRI yield similar results under the same reliability metric, their impact on the existing market has not been fully understood due to uncertainties and complex interactions with other market parameters [ 34 ] . Despite its advantages, the marginal accreditation methods present computational challenges as compared to class-level average accreditation, primarily due to the need to accurately measure the gradient of each resource’s contribution to system reliability. This method typically requires calculating the incremental reliability values of individual resources ,which requires modeling each resource in detail. To alleviate these challenges, similar resources might be grouped into a resource class to ensure computational traceability [ 6 ] . These issues are particularly pronounced for energy-limited resources, especially energy storage [ 14 ] . With energy limited resources, load cannot be assumed met independently in each operating period. For energy storage, the ability to serve load in one time period is highly dependent on the operating conditions and energy availability from previous periods, complicating the marginal contribution calculation [ 23 , 31 , 24 ] . Additionally, modeling appropriate charging and discharging orders of multiple storage resources remains a complex task. These challenges not only increase the computational burden but also raise questions about the accuracy and fairness of marginal accreditation in accurately reflecting the reliability value of diverse resources. In this paper, we address the energy storage capacity accreditation problem using MRI. Rather than relying on perturbation results from commercial RA simulators, we reformulate the energy storage model in resource adequacy as an optimization problem. This new model generates theoretical MRI results, providing insights into the effects of various factors on storage capacity accreditation. The key contributions of this work are as follows: • Enhancing the understanding of energy storage’s marginal reliability impact on system performance. • Examining the influence of QC definitions and other factors on storage capacity accreditation, offering practical insights for system operators. • Comparing storage capacity accreditation under different reliability criteria, offering valuable suggestion for policymakers in setting future reliability standards The remainder of this paper is organized as follows: Section II introduces the definition of MRI and its significance in the capacity market. Section III provides an overview of different energy storage dispatch models in RA assessments, with a detailed explanation of the most commonly used reliability dispatch model. The main contributions of this paper are presented in Section IV , where the storage model is reformulated as an optimization problem to maximize system reliability. Section V discusses key factors that may influence the reformulated model. Finally, Section VI demonstrates the efficiency of the proposed method through a modified California system, including comparative analysis. II Marginal Reliability Impact The MRI of a resource indicates how a small change in the resource’s qualified capacity impacts system reliability, as measured by reliability metrics like Expected Unserved Energy (EUE) or Loss of Load Expectation (LOLE). In this paper, we adopt EUE as the primary reliability metric. II-A MRI as a Rectifier for Qualified Capacity Definition 1 (Marginal Reliability Impact [ 37 ] ) : The MRI is defined as the expected unserved energy (EUE) change over a small increase in Qualified Capacity (QC), i.e. \text{MRI}=-\frac{\partial\text{EUE}}{\partial\text{QC}}. (1) where the derivative is calculated around the installed capacity requirement (ICR), which is estimated by the system operator for the market clearing year. Fig. 1: The Calculation Process of Reliability Metrics and MRI The process for calculating reliability metrics and MRI is illustrated in Fig. 1 , where the adequacy assessment tool is a probabilistic simulator utilizing the Monte Carlo method for resource adequacy analysis. MRI is typically computed through perturbation of the input data, though

Read the complete text