Entropy production versus memory effects in two-level open quantum systems

G. Théret, D. Sugny and C. L. Latune · 2026

Read Entropy production versus memory effects in two-level open quantum systems by G. Théret, D. Sugny and C. L. Latune (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-21930.txt.

Introduction

G. Théret, D. Sugny, and C. Latune compare ways of counting entropy production in small quantum systems. Entropy production measures how irreversible a process is. For two-level systems open to an environment, the literature offers several definitions, born from different settings and motives, and they do not always agree.

The authors set those definitions side by side and analyze how each relates to memory effects, where the environment feeds information back into the system. They use a concrete example: a qubit coupled to a single bosonic mode acting as a finite environment. Their 2026 preprint helps physicists choose the right entropy measure for quantum thermodynamics experiments, where sloppy definitions can flip conclusions.

Catalog record

CREATORG. Théret, D. Sugny and C. L. Latune
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE78 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-21930

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Entropy production versus memory effects in two-level open quantum systems G. Théret, D. Sugny and C. L. Latune Abstract We compare several definitions of entropy production rate introduced in the literature from a large variety of situations and motivations, and then analyze their relations with memory effects. Considering a relevant experimental example of a qubit interacting with a single bosonic mode playing the role of a finite bath, we show that all definitions of entropy production coincide at weak coupling. In the strong coupling regime, significant discrepancies emerge between the different entropy production rates, although some similarities in the overall behaviour remain. However, surprisingly, two of these definitions—one based on local quantities of the system and the other on non-local quantities—coincide exactly, even in the case of strong coupling. Finally, a high degree of correspondence is observed when memory effects characterized by P-divisibility are compared with the sign of all entropy production rates in the case of weak coupling. Such correspondence degrades at strong coupling, leading us to extend the concept of entropy production to the dynamical map. We show a perfect equivalence between the sign of this enlarged concept of entropy production and P-divisibility, both numerically and analytically, in the case of phase-covariant master equations. I Introduction The concept of entropy production is central to both classical and quantum thermodynamics Landi and Paternostro 2021 . It is closely related to the irreversibility of the local system dynamics and to the information lost in the bath Esposito et al. 2010 ; Landi and Paternostro 2021 ; Santos et al. 2018 , and is also associated with the arrow of time Parrondo et al. 2009 ; Deffner and Lutz 2011 ; Santos et al. 2019 ; Latune et al. 2020 . From a practical viewpoint, the entropy production also determines and often limits our ability to perform operations and tasks such as cooling a system Taranto et al. 2023 , extracting work Uzdin et al. 2015 , erasing information Van Vu and Saito 2022 ; Rolandi and Perarnau-Llobet 2023 , measuring time Milburn 2020 ; Pearson et al. 2021 , and controlling fluctuations Hasegawa 2020 , to mention a few. More recently, several studies have suggested a close relation between entropy production and memory effects Mazzola et al. 2012 ; Bhattacharya et al. 2017 ; Marcantoni et al. 2017 ; Popovic et al. 2018 ; Santos et al. 2018 ; Strasberg and Esposito 2019 , often refereed to as non-Markovian effects, in reference to classical dynamics. In Ref. Strasberg and Esposito 2019 , the authors establish the conditions in classical systems for which a negative entropy production rate implies non-Markovianity, and raises the question of its quantum version. Indeed, one of the difficulties in the quantum case is the non-unique characterization of non-Markovianity, which stems from the inability to extend the classical notion straightforwardly to quantum systems Rivas et al. 2014 . For open quantum dynamics, the intuitive relation between entropy production and memory effects can be traced back to a measure of memory effects such as the BLP criterion Breuer et al. 2009 , which relies on the contractivity of the dynamical map. More precisely, when the map is contractive, i.e. when the trace distance between two arbitrary initial states decreases monotonically in time, there is a monotonic loss of information from the system to the bath, which is interpreted as the absence of memory effect. Otherwise, information flows back from the bath to the system. In Ref. Mazzola et al. 2012 , the authors provide an upper bound on contractivity in terms of system-bath correlations. On the other hand, many definitions of entropy production are based on the contractivity of the pseudo-distance (the relative entropy) between an arbitrary initial state and a specific state, such as the steady state (for weak coupling time-independent dissipator) Spohn 1978 ; Alicki 1979 ; Breuer et al. 2002 , or the instantaneous steady state (for strong coupling and time-dependent dissipator) Colla and Breuer 2022 , or even the joined uncorrelated state of the system and the initial state of the bath Esposito et al. 2010 . This contractivity is analogous to the BLP criterion, and therefore suggests, to explore the precise link between memory effects and entropy production, as studied in Bhattacharya et al. 2017 ; Marcantoni et al. 2017 ; Popovic et al. 2018 ; Santos et al. 2018 . It can be shown that negative entropy production rates lead to memory effects, and more precisely to Non-Markovianity (defined as non CP-divisibility, see below for a description and Breuer et al. 2016 ). The reverse implication is not true, and potential alternative witnesses of memory effects are introduced such as the purity Bhattacharya et al. 2017 , and the influence of the form of the instantaneous steady state of the map Marcantoni et al. 2017 . These previous works also raised the key issue of which definition of entropy production should be used. This problem was studied in Colla and Breuer 2021 , where two definitions of entropy production, the traditional one Spohn 1978 ; Alicki 1979 ; Breuer et al. 2002 and the Esposito definition Esposito et al. 2010 –tailored for strong coupling between system and bath– are compared. Interestingly, the two solutions exhibit very different behaviour, except in the case of very weak coupling and high temperature. In this paper, we propose to pursue efforts in this direction using a simple but relevant model consisting of a qubit interacting with a single-bosonic-mode bath. Such a model combines strong coupling and finite bath, two characteristics that are currently receiving a lot of attention due to their complexity and close proximity with experimental situations. In the first part of the paper, we compare several definitions of entropy production, ranging from traditional to more recent ones that are specifically designed for strong coupling and finite baths. In a second part, we investigate the relation to memory effects. The main result is that, at vanishing or small coupling, all definitions of entropy production coincide. However, in the strong coupling regime, important discrepancies emerge, even though the global behaviour remains similar. Furthermore, we observe that two definitions of entropy production exactly coincide. Finally, we show numerically the equivalence between P-divisibility and the sign of the entropy production rate of the dynamical map, which is an extension at the map level of the concept of entropy production. This equivalence is then proven mathematically for a large class of open quantum systems governed by a phase-covariant dynamics Filippov et al. 2020 ; Théret et al. 2025 . These results provide a broad physical interpretation of some of the suggested entropy production definitions and of the concept of P-divisibility. More generally, our study establishes a direct equivalence between the presence of memory effects and the sign of an entropy-production-related quantity. The paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II , we provide the different definitions of entropy production used in this work. Our illustrative example is introduced in Sec. III . A systematic numerical comparison of entropy production rates is proposed in Sec. IV . Section V focuses on the link between entropy production and memory effects. The analytical proof of the equivalence between P-divisibility and the positivity

Read the complete text