EWOCS-V: Is Wd1-72 a recent post-interaction WR+O binary?

C. J. K. Larkin, J. Mackey, H. Jin, A. A. C. Sander, B. Reville, K. Anastasopoulou, M. Andersen, A. Bayo, J. J. Drake, E. K. Grebel, M. G. Guarcello, T. J. Haworth, V. M. Kalari, R. R. Lefever, F. Najarro, B. W. Ritchie, E. Sabbi · 2026

Read EWOCS-V: Is Wd1-72 a recent post-interaction WR+O binary? by C. J. K. Larkin, J. Mackey, H. Jin, A. A. C. Sander, B. Reville, K. Anastasopoulou, M. Andersen, A. Bayo, J. J. Drake, E. K. Grebel, M. G. Guarcello, T. J. Haworth, V. M. Kalari, R. R. Lefever, F. Najarro, B. W. Ritchie, E. Sabbi (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-21788.txt.

Introduction

C. J. K. Larkin and co-authors ask how one unusual pair of massive stars came to be. Wolf-Rayet stars are hot, stripped stars, and how they form at the Sun's metal content is still unclear. Simple single-star paths are hard to square with the orbit patterns seen in different Wolf-Rayet pairs.

Their 2026 study focuses on Wd1-72, a Wolf-Rayet plus O-star binary inside the young massive cluster Westerlund 1. The pair sits inside the shared wind of the whole cluster. The title poses the question the evidence must answer: is this system a recent case where the two stars interacted and exchanged material? The answer would help pin down how often binary interaction, not solo aging, makes Wolf-Rayet stars.

Catalog record

CREATORC. J. K. Larkin, J. Mackey, H. Jin, A. A. C. Sander, B. Reville, K. Anastasopoulou, M. Andersen, A. Bayo, J. J. Drake, E. K. Grebel, M. G. Guarcello, T. J. Haworth, V. M. Kalari, R. R. Lefever, F. Najarro, B. W. Ritchie, E. Sabbi
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-21788

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

EWOCS-V: Is Wd1-72 a recent post-interaction WR+O binary? C. J. K. Larkin, J. Mackey, H. Jin, A. A. C. Sander, B. Reville, K. Anastasopoulou, M. Andersen, A. Bayo, J. J. Drake, E. K. Grebel, M. G. Guarcello, T. J. Haworth, V. M. Kalari, R. R. Lefever, F. Najarro, B. W. Ritchie, E. Sabbi Abstract The evolutionary origin of Wolf-Rayet (WR) stars at Solar metallicity is unclear. Single-star evolution from massive O stars, possibly via a Luminous Blue Variable phase, is challenged by binary period distributions of different WR subtypes. Wd1-72 is a WN7b+O binary embedded in the collective wind of the Galactic young massive cluster Westerlund 1 (Wd 1). It is surrounded by highly structured nebulosity, with cometary tails pointing away from Wd 1 and quasi-spherical droplets towards it. In this letter, we demonstrate that this morphology can be qualitatively reproduced by a hydrodynamic simulation of non-conservative Roche Lobe Overflow (RLOF) mass-loss into a cluster wind. Our model is based on a detailed binary evolution track consistent with key known properties of Wd1-72. Our work suggests Wd1-72 could be only ∼ \sim 10 kyr \mathrm{kyr} post-RLOF, and the hydrogen-free nature of Wd1-72 favours this being a second or subsequent RLOF episode. Follow-up observations could make Wd1-72 a valuable benchmark for probing mass-loss and mass-transfer in forming gravitational-wave binary-progenitor systems. 1 Introduction In the classical single-star scenario proposed by 11 , massive O stars undergo intense mass-loss ( \dot{M} ), stripping the hydrogen (H) envelope and producing a Wolf-Rayet (WR) star. This may apply to the most massive stars ( 43 , M_{\text{init}}\gtrsim 100\,M_{\odot} , e.g.,) , but steady winds alone are potentially insufficient to do this for a wider range of initial masses. A brief Luminous Blue Variable (LBV) phase with eruptive \dot{M} has therefore been suggested ( 30 ) and is applied in grids of massive-star evolution models ( 17 , e.g.,) . In such evolution models, the resulting WR stars usually begin with a nitrogen-rich surface (WN-type) of a late subtype and then pass gradually to earlier subtypes and eventually to the carbon-rich WC stage ( 21 , e.g.) . However, while there are a few observations of transitional WN/WC and even WN/WO stars ( 12 ; 46 , e.g.,) , the single-star nature of larger LBV eruptions has been questioned ( 5 ; 26 , e.g.,) . The majority of massive stars are in multiple systems and will experience some binary interaction in their lifetime ( 44 ; 14 , e.g.) . Such effects have long been suggested as an alternative path to strip away enough of the outer envelope to form a WR star ( 35 , e.g.) . Binary stripping could also break the presumption of self-stripping where WR stars form as (very) late WN subtypes and then consecutively evolve to earlier ones. 16 showed that the Galactic WN binary population have mostly short periods (1-10 d) whereas the WC population distribution peaks at \sim 5000 d. This implies their formation pathways are different, leaving many open questions about descendants of these systems. This has implications for not only our understanding of WR formation, but also the properties of the progenitors of gravitational waves from black-hole binary mergers ( 25 ; 34 , e.g,) . The young massive cluster Westerlund 1 (Wd 1) is an ideal laboratory to study massive stellar evolution due to its large, diverse and likely coeval (age \sim 6 Myr, 7 , although this is debated by e.g. 4 ) population of massive stars. This includes 24 WR stars ( 13 ; 2 , > 90% of which are binaries,) as well as the sgB[e] star Wd1-9 ( 10 ) , likely a WR+OB binary system that recently experienced Case-B mass transfer ( 1 ) . JWST observations of Wd 1 by the Extended Westerlund 1 and 2 Open Clusters Survey (EWOCS) collaboration show the cluster is surrounded by complex nebulosity ( 22 ) —a finding unexpected for a cluster this old because feedback should disperse leftover natal gas on much shorter timescales ( 41 ) . In the west and south of Wd 1, the nebulosity appears to be embedded in a collective radially expanding cluster wind, driven by the powerful WR stars in the core. In the east however, the cometary-like droplets appear to be centered on Wd1-72, a WN7b + late O supergiant binary system (alias WR A or WR 77sc) with two periods observed. A 7.63 d period ( P ) was reported by 6 in optical data and also observed in X-rays by 2 , who found an additional stronger P of 81 d. The X-ray spectrum of Wd1-72 is very similar to that of Wd1-9 ( 8 ; 2 ) . Wd1-72 is also a binary with both components similar to the Wd1-9 model proposed by 1 , who suggest it as an analogue for the near future of Wd1-9. In this letter, the fifth in the EWOCS series, we demonstrate how both key aspects of the qualitative morphology of the nebulosity around Wd1-72 as seen at 11 \mu m can be reproduced with a hydrodynamic model of intense non-conservative Roche Lobe Overflow (hereafter RLOF) \dot{M} into a cluster wind. The \dot{M} properties are motivated by a bespoke binary stellar evolution track consistent with the known properties of Wd1-72. We briefly discuss implications for massive binary evolution, and how follow-up observations are required to constrain the recent \dot{M} history, and test the possible post-interaction nature of, Wd1-72. Our letter is organised as follows: In Sect. 2 we describe our simulation setup. In Sect. 3 we present our simulation and compare it qualitatively with JWST observations. We discuss our findings and present our conclusions in Sect. 4 . In the appendices we show how our evolutionary track compares to the measured properties of Wd1-72 (App. A ), why a giant LBV eruption cannot explain the observations (App. B ), and estimates of dust emission from the dense clumps produced in the simulation (App. C ). 2 Methods 2.1 MESA evolutionary track We use a newly computed MESA ( 36 ; 37 ; 38 ; 39 ; 40 , version 10398,) track with the same physics assumptions as in 28 , except for the wind \dot{M} rates (see 29 for details). In test hydrodynamic simulations the RLOF material was found to disperse after \lesssim\, 50 \mathrm{kyr} , setting an upper limit for the timescale of depletion of surface H after a RLOF event. O stars are expected to retain some surface H after rapid RLOF in an intermediate slow RLOF phase for \gtrsim\, 100 \mathrm{kyr} ( 9 ) , which would appear as e.g. a WN9h spectral type, so this favours an evolutionary path with multiple RLOF episodes. One model with two RLOF events was identified in the grid of 28 which was close to the known age, luminosity ( L_{\mathrm{bol}} ) and P of Wd1-72, but was H free after \sim 70 \mathrm{kyr} . This model is at Solar metallicity, has an initial P of 3.98 d, primary (initially more massive) M_{\text{init}}=28.18\,M_{\odot} and secondary M_{\text{init}}=19.73\,M_{\odot} . We reran this evolutionary track with a factor 4.7 increase in the \dot{M} of the primary star starting immediately after

Read the complete text