A Costing Framework for Fusion Power Plants
Simon Woodruff · 2026
Read A Costing Framework for Fusion Power Plants by Simon Woodruff (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-21724.txt.
Introduction
Simon Woodruff gathers two decades of fusion power plant costing work into one framework. The work was done for a United States energy agency across several years. Early studies leaned on scaling rules from older designs to estimate the cost of a first-of-a-kind plant.
The framework later grew toward standards-aligned, auditable costing. A pilot study with industry partners checked the plant-level numbers for realism. Costing is where fusion dreams meet budgets, and weak estimates have burned the field before. A documented, checkable framework helps funders compare designs on equal terms.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Simon Woodruff |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 84 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-21724
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Costing Framework for Fusion Power Plants Thanks: Citation : Authors. Title. Pages…. DOI:000000/11111. Simon Woodruff Abstract This paper summarizes and consolidates fusion power-plant costing work performed in support of ARPA-E from 2017 through 2024, and documents the evolution of the associated analysis framework from early capital-cost-focused studies to a standards-aligned, auditable costing capability. Early efforts applied ARIES-style cost-scaling relations to generate Nth-of-a-kind (NOAK) estimates and were calibrated through a pilot study with Bechtel and Decysive Systems to benchmark balance-of-plant (BOP) costs and validate plant-level reasonableness from an engineering, procurement, and construction (EPC) perspective. Subsequent work, informed by Lucid Catalyst studies of nuclear cost drivers, expanded the methodology to treat indirect costs explicitly and to evaluate cost-reduction pathways for non-fusion-island systems through design-for-cost practices, modularization, centralized manufacturing, and learning. As ARPA-E’s fusion portfolio expanded, these methods were applied across BETHE and GAMOW concepts (and select ALPHA revisits), including enhanced treatment of tritium handling and plant integration supported by Princeton/PPPL expertise. In 2023 the capability was refactored to align with the IAEA–GEN-IV EMWG–EPRI code-of-accounts lineage, while key ARIES-derived scaling relations were replaced by bottom-up subsystem models for dominant fusion cost drivers (e.g., magnets, lasers, power supplies, and power-core components) coupled to physics-informed power balances and engineering-constrained radial builds. These developments were implemented in the spreadsheet-based Fusion Economics code (FECONs) and released as an open-source Python framework (pyFECONs), providing a transparent mapping from subsystem estimates to standardized accounts and a consistent computation of LCOE. 1 Introduction Economic credibility is now a central requirement for fusion energy: as concepts mature from physics demonstrations toward integrated pilot plants, developers, funders, and policymakers require cost estimates that are transparent, comparable across architectures, and traceable to underlying technical assumptions. The ARPA-E support work summarized here was motivated by precisely this need: to move beyond one-off, non-comparable fusion costing exercises toward a repeatable programmatic capability that can identify dominant cost drivers, test cost-reduction strategies, and enable like-for-like comparisons with advanced fission and other low-carbon generation options. Foundation and guiding philosophy The work builds on three complementary foundations: (i) the ARIES family of fusion power plant studies, which couple physics-informed power balances, engineering-constrained radial builds, conceptual plant layouts, and high-level cost scalings; (ii) ARPA-E’s 2017 pilot study with Bechtel and Decysive Systems, which benchmarked and sanity-checked fusion plant capital costs from an EPC standpoint; and (iii) Lucid Catalyst analyses of nuclear cost drivers, which emphasize the importance of indirect costs, construction methodology, modularization, and learning in determining achievable $/kW outcomes. Across these efforts, the guiding workflow remained consistent: begin with a physics-informed power balance, translate performance requirements into a feasible radial build subject to engineering constraints, size dominant driver systems (e.g., magnets, lasers, power supplies), and then translate thermal performance and layout into BOP equipment and buildings, with conventional plant subsystems anchored primarily to NETL baselines where appropriate. Program evolution: from pilot studies to portfolio support The program evolved through distinct stages. In 2017, the immediate objective was to establish an initial fusion costing workflow suitable for ARPA-E needs and to calibrate ARIES-derived outputs against EPC experience; this phase highlighted sensitivities to layout, buildings, and major equipment sizing and established a credible baseline for BOP-related costs. In 2019, the emphasis broadened to separate and scrutinize BOP and (especially) indirect costs, and to identify actionable pathways for reducing non-power-core costs via standardized layouts, modularization, centralized manufacturing, and learning effects—a key shift driven by the recognition that non-fusion-island costs often dominate total plant cost. During 2022–2023, the capability matured into a portfolio-scale support function for BETHE and GAMOW awardees (and selected ALPHA revisits), providing concept-consistent analyses across diverse private-sector architectures while improving realism in tritium handling and fuel-cycle assumptions through PPPL’s operational and safety expertise. Standards alignment and tool release By 2023, ARPA-E’s growing portfolio and the need for cross-concept comparability motivated a refactor toward a standardized, auditable, and extensible framework. This refactor aligned the costing structure with the IAEA (2001), GEN-IV EMWG (2007), and EPRI (2024) code-of-accounts lineage, and prioritized replacement of legacy ARIES scalings with bottom-up subsystem models for major fusion-unique drivers, coupled to explicit power-balance and radial-build calculations (including multi-fuel and blanket option coverage). The resulting capability was implemented in FECONs (spreadsheet) and released as pyFECONs (open-source Python), emphasizing transparency, traceability, and extensibility as a reference implementation for credible fusion costing and consistent LCOE evaluation. Scope and contributions Accordingly, this paper (i) documents the evolution of the ARPA-E fusion costing methodology from ARIES-derived scalings to bottom-up subsystem models, (ii) summarizes how portfolio-scale application sharpened identification of dominant cost drivers and improved tritium/fuel-cycle realism, and (iii) presents the standardized account structure and implementation philosophy embodied in the FECONs/pyFECONs tools, enabling auditable and like-for-like cost comparisons across fusion concepts and against other generation technologies. 2 Background This work adopts a deliberately conservative and well-documented costing lineage, drawing on established power-plant cost-accounting methodologies that have been developed and refined within the nuclear sector. Specifically, the cost-category structure and economic accounting conventions used here are informed by (i) International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) guidance on economic evaluation of nuclear power plants, (ii) the Generation IV International Forum (GIF) Economics Modeling Working Group (G4EMWG) guidelines, and (iii) the synthesis and interpretation of these methods in Rothwell’s Economics of Nuclear Power framework [ 7 , 6 , 9 ] . The purposeful use of these contemporary, externally vetted methodologies improves transparency and facilitates reproducibility for researchers who wish to perform comparable analyses. A key departure from many prior fusion costing studies is the explicit reorganization of the capital cost accounts. Direct costs are separated into Category 10 (pre-construction) and Category 20 (construction), while indirect and capitalized ancillary costs are grouped into Categories 30–60 (formerly Categories 91–98 in some legacy nuclear accounting structures). This structure retains substantial continuity with established practice—for example, the Category 20 construction accounts remain closely aligned with conventional plant breakdowns—while adding or clarifying elements that are particularly important for modern fusion development programs (e.g., explicit treatment of a digital twin and contingency). Additionally, the treatment of decommissioning is modified to improve accounting clarity: rather than embedding decommissioning in the LCOE in a manner that can be difficult to audit, decommissioning costs are represented as a capitalized indirect cost, enabling clearer attribution, sensitivity studies, and discussion of the drivers of end-of-life obligations. Although the accounting structure is derived from fission-centered references, the cost drivers for fusion plants can differ substantially in the heat island, fuel cycle, remote handling, and replacement schedule of major components. Those fusion-specific departures are therefore made explicit throughout the paper at the subsystem level. Where possible, we adopt the GEN-IV subcategory descriptions from the G4EMWG guidance, editing them to capture fusion-specific hardware and operational realities without losing the comparability benefits of a standardized taxonomy. Our costing philosophy is to (i) provide recent cost-basis information for each cost category wherever possible, (ii) state the cost basis and its provenance directly in the text, and (iii) provide references that enable users of the accompanying models and code to trace assumptions back to primary sources. We are also judicious in terminology. In some contexts, the term “reactor” carries connotations that may hinder broader adoption of fusion energy systems; accordingly, we use the term “heat island” where it more precisely conveys