When Life Gives You AI, Will You Turn It Into A Market for Lemons? Understanding How Information Asymmetries About AI System Capabilities Affect Market Outcomes and Adoption Conference: Proceedings of the 2026 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems; April 13–17, 2026; Barcelona, Spain

Alexander Erlei, Federico Cau, Radoslav Georgiev, Sagar Kumar, Kilian Bizer, Ujwal Gadiraju · 2026

Read When Life Gives You AI, Will You Turn It Into A Market for Lemons? Understanding How Information Asymmetries About AI System Capabilities Affect Market Outcomes and Adoption Conference: Proceedings of the 2026 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems; April 13–17, 2026; Barcelona, Spain by Alexander Erlei, Federico Cau, Radoslav Georgiev, Sagar Kumar, Kilian Bizer, Ujwal Gadiraju (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-21650.txt.

Introduction

Alexander Erlei, Federico Cau, Radoslav Georgiev, Sagar Kumar, Kilian Bizer, and Ujwal Gadiraju study how hidden gaps in knowledge about AI systems warp consumer markets. Buyers cannot easily tell a strong system from a flawed one. A product can look highly accurate while hiding costly errors or defects.

The classic economics of lemons predicts that such gaps drive good products out. Disclosure rules try to close the gap, but large parts remain open. The authors examine how these asymmetries shape adoption and market outcomes. Their analysis helps regulators aim disclosure where it protects buyers without choking useful tools.

Catalog record

CREATORAlexander Erlei, Federico Cau, Radoslav Georgiev, Sagar Kumar, Kilian Bizer, Ujwal Gadiraju
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE95 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-21650

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

When Life Gives You AI, Will You Turn It Into A Market for Lemons? Understanding How Information Asymmetries About AI System Capabilities Affect Market Outcomes and Adoption Conference: Proceedings of the 2026 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems; April 13–17, 2026; Barcelona, Spain Proceedings of the 2026 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems (CHI ’26), April 13–17, 2026, Barcelona, Spain DOI: 10.1145/3772318.3791420 ISBN: 979-8-4007-2278-3/2026/04 CCS: Human-centered computing CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI) CCS: Information systems CCS: Computing methodologies Artificial intelligence Alexander Erlei, Federico Cau, Radoslav Georgiev, Sagar Kumar, Kilian Bizer, Ujwal Gadiraju Abstract . AI consumer markets are characterized by severe buyer-supplier market asymmetries. Complex AI systems can appear highly accurate while making costly errors or embedding hidden defects. While there have been regulatory efforts surrounding different forms of disclosure, large information gaps remain. This paper provides the first experimental evidence on the important role of information asymmetries and disclosure designs in shaping user adoption of AI systems. We systematically vary the density of low-quality AI systems and the depth of disclosure requirements in a simulated AI product market to gauge how people react to the risk of accidentally relying on a low-quality AI system. Then, we compare participants’ choices to a rational Bayesian model, analyzing the degree to which partial information disclosure can improve AI adoption. Our results underscore the deleterious effects of information asymmetries on AI adoption, but also highlight the potential of partial disclosure designs to improve the overall efficiency of human decision-making. Figure 1. Task interface that participants interacted with during the study. This illustration represents the deceptive review detection task (A) with full information disclosure about the AI systems in the available pool. On the left side (A1), participants viewed the hotel review they needed to verify. On the right side, participants saw the binary decision options for the current trial, and an AI pool of ten AI systems (A2). By hovering over an AI system, participants could access the available information ( i.e., quality indicators) corresponding to the AI system in conditions with partial or full information disclosure. Participants could select an AI system from the pool for delegation by first clicking on it—which makes the selected AI system light up with a green border—and then clicking the ‘ Delegate decision to AI ’ button to complete the current trial. Figure 1 depicts the interface used by participants for the deceptive review detection task. The screen is divided into two main sections. On the left, participants read the hotel review they need to evaluate. On the right, they see two binary response options (i.e., classifying the review as either genuine or deceptive) and a pool of ten AI systems represented as individual tiles. When participants hover over a tile, the system displays the available quality indicators for that AI model with partial (i.e., AI accuracy) or full (i.e., AI accuracy and data quality) information disclosure. Participants can either make the decision themselves or delegate it by selecting one of the AI systems, which becomes highlighted with a green border, and then clicking the \enquote{Delegate decision to AI} button. † † cc-license: by 1. Introduction AI systems are increasingly integrated into consumer-facing applications, yet their complexity often obscures critical quality dimensions such as reliability, safety, and fairness from end-users ( 109 ; 108 ; 74 ) . While these systems can appear highly accurate, they may still make costly mistakes or exhibit hidden defects ( 29 ; 143 ; 116 ; 38 ; 135 ; 131 ; 90 ) . From an HCI perspective, this opacity creates significant challenges for trust calibration, appropriate reliance, and user agency. Users often lack the ability to verify system quality either before or after use ( 18 ; 49 ) , which can lead to misaligned mental models and poor decision-making. In the field of economics, this is traditionally framed as a “market for lemons” problem, where uncertainty about product quality drives inefficient outcomes ( 2 ) . In the context of human-AI interaction, this translates into information asymmetry between designers or deployers of AI systems and their users, where users cannot easily assess whether an AI system is fit for their task. This can lead to sub-optimal user decisions not only on whether to adopt an AI system, but also on which AI system to adopt, given the presence of alternatives. While mechanisms such as reputation systems, third-party certifications, and disclosure labels (e.g., Apple’s privacy “nutrition” labels) aim to bridge this gap ( 60 ; 126 ; 127 ; 132 ) , they often fail in practice due to selective reporting, high cognitive load, or strategic complexity that undermines transparency ( 91 ; 3 ; 72 ) . Recent regulatory efforts, such as the EU AI Act, mandate transparency, but standards remain fragmented and lack empirical grounding in user behavior ( 77 ; 142 ) . Evidence suggests that current disclosure practices (e.g., model cards) vary widely in informativeness and usability ( 91 ; 120 ) . Importantly, providers of these systems are generally incentivized to reveal favorable but hide unfavorable information ( 117 ; 71 ) , or use unnecessary complexity to shroud information ( 72 ) , which constraints the usefulness of voluntary transparency efforts. Addressing this requires a regulatory framework that is strategy-proof, such that suppliers cannot “game” the system through partial information revelation ( 114 ) . In this paper, we provide the first experimental evidence on how information asymmetries (modeled through disclosure design) and the relative density of low-quality AI systems (also referred to as lemons ) in the available pool for users, influence their adoption and reliance on AI systems. To this end, we simulate an interactive decision-making environment in which participants complete three different tasks across 10 rounds, in each of which they can decide to use assistance from an AI system of their choice from a pool of alternatives. Our controlled study follows a 3 (lemon density: Low Density vs Medium Density vs High Density ) \times 2 (information disclosure: No Disclosure vs Partial Disclosure ) between-subjects design, with an additional benchmark condition of High Density with Full Disclosure . The overall quality of an AI system in our study is represented by an accuracy score and a data quality score, where the latter represents the AI system’s generalizability. 1 1 1 Note that our technical operationalization of AI system quality does not consider other relevant dimensions of system quality such as robustness, fairness, uncertainty, or alignment with human values—where data quality remains a fundamental enabler. This operationalization is a principled simplification that necessarily excludes other important dimensions of AI system quality that fall outside the scope of our study, while remaining externally valid. Several dimensions of AI system quality in the real world are often encapsulated in composite metrics that are conveyed to consumers to help shape their mental models of the systems. In the Partial Disclosure conditions, participants only observe the accuracy score, whereas the Full Disclosure conditions reveal both accuracy and data quality. This design allows us to examine how users interpret and act on these cues under varying conditions of low-quality AI system density, as illustrated in Fig. 1 .

Read the complete text