Opinion Consensus Formation Among Networked Large Language Models

Iris Yazici, Mert Kayaalp, Stefan Taga, Ali H. Sayed · 2026

Read Opinion Consensus Formation Among Networked Large Language Models by Iris Yazici, Mert Kayaalp, Stefan Taga, Ali H. Sayed (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-21540.txt.

Introduction

Iris Yazici, Mert Kayaalp, Stefan Taga, and Ali H. Sayed test whether classic opinion models can predict how groups of language models settle on a view. Agents trade text messages over varied network layouts for several rounds. Each message is scored for its stance by sentiment tools.

The frame is the DeGroot model, where each agent averages the views it hears. The question is whether that simple math tracks real model behavior. If it does, designers can forecast group drift before running costly trials. If it fails, the gaps show where model talk departs from classic social dynamics.

Catalog record

CREATORIris Yazici, Mert Kayaalp, Stefan Taga, Ali H. Sayed
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE27 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-21540

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Opinion Consensus Formation Among Networked Large Language Models Iris Yazici, Mert Kayaalp, Stefan Taga, Ali H. Sayed Abstract Can classical consensus models predict the group behavior of large language models (LLMs)? We examine multi-round interactions among LLM agents through the DeGroot framework, where agents exchange text-based messages over diverse communication graphs. To track opinion evolution, we map each message to an opinion score via sentiment analysis. We find that agents typically reach consensus and the disagreement between the agents decays exponentially. However, the limiting opinion departs from DeGroot’s network-centrality-weighted forecast. The consensus between LLM agents turns out to be largely insensitive to initial conditions and instead depends strongly on the discussion subject and inherent biases. Nevertheless, transient dynamics align with classical graph theory and the convergence rate of opinions is closely related to the second-largest eigenvalue of the graph’s combination matrix. Together, these findings can be useful for LLM-driven social-network simulations and the design of resource-efficient multi-agent LLM applications. 1 Introduction Mathematical models of opinion formation have been instrumental in understanding social network behavior and in designing multi-agent information-processing systems. The DeGroot consensus model [ 7 ] , in particular, has received a lot of attention from the signal processing, microeconomics, and control communities, where many variants [ 21 , 15 , 8 , 11 , 20 , 14 ] have been proposed to better reflect group decision dynamics and to design better decentralized signal processing and optimization algorithms. In this work, we study social interactions among large language models (LLMs) through the lens of the DeGroot framework. Our goals are twofold. First, despite a rich theoretical literature, empirical validation in real-world social settings remains limited, largely because collecting behavioral data from human subjects is costly and time-consuming. We examine whether LLMs can provide a controllable and low-cost testbed for modeling the dynamics observed in human social networks. Second, as LLMs are increasingly deployed in real applications, including social media platforms, it becomes important to understand how opinions evolve within networks of LLM-based agents. To that end, we conduct experiments where LLM agents interact on communication graphs, and exchange text-based statements with their immediate neighbors over multiple rounds. We enforce the network weights and agent characters through system prompts, conduct multi-round simulations, and assign opinion scores to all responses via sentiment analysis. We vary the topics and graph topology, and compile the resulting conversations into a dataset. We then analyze the underlying opinion dynamics. We find that agents typically converge to a consensus. Somewhat surprisingly, however, the final beliefs are largely insensitive to their initial positions, which is a departure from the DeGroot prediction that consensus should equal a network-centrality–weighted average of initial opinions. Instead, the consensus point appears to be dependent on the discussion subject and on biases the LLM carries, possibly from pretraining and alignment phases of their training. Despite this mismatch, the rate of convergence to the consensus agrees with well-established graph-theoretical results: it is related to the second-largest modulus eigenvalue of the combination matrix [ 12 , 24 ] . Moreover, we find that when the combination matrix’s weights are instructed to the LLM agents through system prompts, agents are more likely to reach a consensus. In order to stimulate further research, we open-source our dataset totaling 764 experiments with 8 different topics, containing more than 1,200,000 LLM responses. It is available on Hugging Face 1 1 1 https://huggingface.co/datasets/asl-epfl/Social-LLM-Networks . 1.1 Related Work Models of opinion dynamics and distributed inference study how a network of agents aggregates and updates its beliefs by repeatedly incorporating others’ views. The standard DeGroot model [ 7 ] captures this via repeated averaging, where each agent forms a weighted average of neighbors’ opinions over time. Beyond DeGroot, richer variants allow for Bayesian reasoning at the agent level [ 1 ] and for distinct communication patterns, such as private interactions [ 11 ] or randomized processes [ 20 , 14 ] . There is also experimental work evaluating these mechanisms in real-world social settings [ 4 , 17 , 18 ] , though such empirical tests remain relatively rare. Because experiments within human social networks are difficult to run, recent work examines the use of LLMs for simulation. They have been used for political processes [ 9 ] , social-platform design choices [ 22 ] , spread of misinformation [ 16 ] , and for replicating classical social-psychology experiments [ 3 ] . Motivated by the emergence of human-LLM collectives, there is also a line of work that frames LLMs as “distributed sensor networks” integrating textual inputs [ 13 ] . Likewise, opinion dynamics among LLMs have been studied to assess how closely they mirror social networks. For example, [ 5 ] finds that standard LLMs initialized with human-like personas tend to reach factual consensus, likely due to their knowledge priors. Similarly, [ 6 ] shows intrinsic training-induced biases: alignment-trained models exhibit a consensus-seeking tendency even when used as-is, without persona prompts. In comparison, we analyze opinion dynamics from a DeGroot perspective, and focus on topics that are also debated in real-world social networks rather than factual questions with ground-truth answers. Furthermore, we study the impact of the communication network topology by evaluating the consensus rate among LLMs. Doing so assists in clarifying the potential of LLMs for social-simulation research, and also helps guide the design of multi-agent LLM systems that are resource-efficient in both communication and context-length. 2 Problem Formulation We consider a network of K agents. Initially, each agent k has a belief vector (i.e., opinion) \mu_{k,0} , which it updates based on the opinions of its neighbors. The peer-to-peer communication is constrained on a weighted and directed graph topology. Each agent k receives information from its neighbors \mathcal{N}_{k} . In the DeGroot model [ 7 ] , agents repeatedly average their neighbors’ opinions in order to update theirs. Namely, at each time instant i , agent k updates its belief with \mu_{k,i}=\sum_{\ell\in\mathcal{N}_{k}}a_{\ell k}\mu_{\ell,i-1}, (1) where a_{\ell k} denotes the level of trust agent k assigns to the belief vector it receives from agent \ell . These coefficients satisfy \sum_{\ell\in\mathcal{N}_{k}}\!\!a_{\ell k}=1\ \ \text{and}\ \ a_{\ell k}>0\ \text{if, and only if,}\ \ell\in\mathcal{N}_{k},\ \text{0 if}\ \ell\notin\mathcal{N}_{k} (2) where the combination matrix A=[a_{\ell k}] is left-stochastic. If the underlying graph is also strongly connected [ 21 ] , that is, if there exists a path between any agent pair (\ell,k) and there exists at least one agent k that does not discard its own information (i.e., \exists k a_{kk}>0 ), then, the matrix A becomes both aperiodic and irreducible. This implies that under ( 1 ) and by the Perron-Frobenius theorem [ 21 , 19 ] , all agents will reach consensus with asymptotic beliefs given by \lim_{i\to\infty}\mu_{k,i}=\sum_{\ell=1}^{K}\pi_{\ell}\ \mu_{\ell,0} (3) Here, \pi denotes the Perron eigenvector of the combination matrix A and satisfies A\pi=\pi,\ \ \ \sum_{k=1}^{K}\pi_{k}=1,\ \ \text{and}\ \forall k,\ \pi_{k}>0. (4) Entry \pi_{k} represents how central agent k is in the network. Equation ( 3 ) then means that the final opinions of all agents are going to be the same and equal to a weighted average of initial opinions. A strongly connected graph also implies that the matrix A has a unique eigenvalue at 1 and all its other eigenvalues

Read the complete text