Trade uncertainty impact on stock-bond correlations: Insights from conditional correlation models

Demetrio Lacava, Edoardo Otranto · 2026

Read Trade uncertainty impact on stock-bond correlations: Insights from conditional correlation models by Demetrio Lacava, Edoardo Otranto (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-21447.txt.

Introduction

Demetrio Lacava and Edoardo Otranto study how trade policy uncertainty moves the link between stocks and bonds. The pair uses daily United States data across a recent decade. Major stock indexes are tracked against the benchmark long-term Treasury bond.

A two-step framework based on volatility models estimates how their correlation shifts over time. Several model types, from fixed to smoothly shifting correlation, are compared. When trade news turns shaky, investors often flee stocks for bonds, which changes the link. Knowing how that link moves helps investors balance portfolios when policy risk spikes.

Catalog record

CREATORDemetrio Lacava, Edoardo Otranto
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-21447

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Trade uncertainty impact on stock-bond correlations: Insights from conditional correlation models Demetrio Lacava, Edoardo Otranto Abstract This paper investigates the impact of Trade Policy Uncertainty (TPU) on stock–bond correlation dynamics in the United States. Using daily data on major U.S. stock indices and the 10-year Treasury bond from 2015 to 2025, we estimate correlation within a two-step GARCH-based framework, relying on multivariate specifications, including Constant Conditional Correlation (CCC), Smooth Transition Conditional Correlation (STCC), and Dynamic Conditional Correlation (DCC) models. We extend these frameworks by incorporating TPU index and a presidential dummy to capture effects of trade uncertainty and government cycles. The findings show that constant correlation models are strongly rejected in favor of time-varying specifications. Both STCC and DCC models confirm TPU’s central role in driving correlation dynamics, with significant differences across political regimes. DCC models augmented with TPU and political effects deliver the best in-sample fit and strongest forecasting performance, as measured by statistical and economic loss functions. Keywords: Conditional Correlation Models, Smooth Transition Models, Dynamic Conditional Correlation, Stock–Bond Correlations, Trade Policy Uncertainty, Presidential Cycle JEL codes: C32, C58, E44. 1 Introduction Financial operators largely agree that asset allocation is one of the most critical decisions in the investment process. A key challenge in this context is that correlations between asset returns vary over time in response to economic shocks, policy changes, and geopolitical events. Accurately capturing and forecasting time-varying correlations is therefore crucial for effective for portfolio construction, diversification, and risk management. More in detail, diversification reduces exposure to idiosyncratic risk, but it depends directly on the correlation structure among assets. Assuming constant correlations can lead to suboptimal allocations as well as an underestimation of risk, particularly during periods of market turbulence or abrupt changes in investor risk perceptions. Moreover, asset prices often react in a similar way to common external shocks, suggesting that these shared influences should be explicitly taken into account when modeling asset comovement. For instance, Yilmazkuday 2025 documents a sharp decline in major U.S. stock indices associated with geopolitical risk ( Yilmazkuday 2024 ) and the COVID-19 pandemic ( Yilmazkuday 2023 ) . Economic and policy uncertainty (EPU) is also recognized as a key determinant of both oil–stock correlations ( Fang et al. 2018 ) and stock-bond correlations ( Connolly et al. 2005 ; Fang et al. 2017 ) . With respect to stock–bond correlations, evidence shows that they are positively related to inflation but negatively related to market uncertainty ( Andersson et al. 2008 ) ; in addition, they are also influenced by market liquidity ( Baele et al. 2010 ) , risk aversion ( Bekaert et al. 2010 ) , and the U.S. presidential cycle ( Demirer and Gupta 2018 ) . More recently, the international political landscape has been dominated by pervasive trade uncertainty, with repeated tariff announcements and frequent adjustments to existing trade measures. From an investment viewpoint, understanding the impact of trade uncertainty on asset class correlations is particularly important, as sudden shifts in trade policy can materially alter diversification benefits and hedging effectiveness. To the best of our knowledge, however, the impact of trade uncertainty on stock–bond correlations has not yet been thoroughly investigated. Trade uncertainty can affect such correlations through multiple channels. First, higher trade uncertainty increases overall economic uncertainty and risk aversion, leading to the flight-to-safety phenomenon ( Pastor and Veronesi 2012 ; Brogaard and Detzel 2015 ) , in which investors reallocate wealth away from riskier assets toward safer ones, thereby generating negative stock–bond correlations. Second, trade shocks, such as the imposition of tariffs, may alter inflation expectations and, in turn, monetary policy decisions, producing periods of higher positive correlations between asset classes, as highlighted in the trade war context by Caldara et al. 2020 . Finally, trade uncertainty can dampen corporate earnings expectations and global aggregate demand. According to Bloom 2009 , this mechanism also contributes to form the flight-to-safety phenomenon and, as a consequence, to the time-varying nature of cross-asset correlations. All these mechanisms motivate the inclusion of Trade Policy Uncertainty (TPU) in multivariate volatility models, allowing us to capture an important source of time-varying correlations and to improve both in-sample fit and out-of-sample forecasts. Caldara et al. 2020 introduced a TPU index, which we employ in this study to assess whether TPU influences stock–bond correlations and whether such effects vary depending on the prevailing political agenda. From a computational perspective, modeling covariances and correlations raises two main challenges ( Bauwens et al. 2006 ) : (i) ensuring the positive definiteness of the estimated covariance (or correlation) matrix, and (ii) addressing the curse of dimensionality – i.e., the exponential growth in the number of parameters as the number of assets increases – which may render models computationally unfeasible. This issue is particularly severe in models such as the VECH GARCH ( Bollerslev et al. 1988 ) and the BEKK ( Engle and Kroner 1995 ) . An elegant and parsimonious solution, which accounts for much of the success of the approach, was proposed by Engle 2002 . His Dynamic Conditional Correlation (DCC) framework relies on a two-step estimation procedure: in the first step, univariate GARCH models are estimated for the conditional variances of each return series; in the second step, conditional correlations are estimated based on the standardized residuals. Different specifications have been provided for the representation of the conditional correlation matrix. Earlier contributions include Bollerslev 1990 , who proposed the Constant Conditional Correlation (CCC) model, in which correlations are fixed over time, while variances evolve according to univariate GARCH dynamics. Silvennoinen and Teräsvirta 2015 later extended the CCC model by allowing smooth transitions between two correlation regimes, typically representing low and high correlation states, driven by an exogenous transition variable. The most widespread model in this framework, however, remains the DCC model of Engle 2002 , which introduces a GARCH-type structure for conditional correlations. In this paper, we extend these models along two dimensions: (i) by incorporating trade policy uncertainty, proxied by the TPU index, as a driver of correlation dynamics; and (ii) by accounting for the political cycle effect, captured through a dummy variable that reflects differences across broader policy regimes and macro-policy conditions over the political cycle. Our empirical analysis focuses on major U.S. stock indices – namely the Standard and Poor’s 500 (S&P500), the Dow Jones Industrial Average, the Nasdaq Composite, and the Russell 2000 – as representative of the stock market, and the 10-year Treasury Bond (T-Bond), as representative of the bond market, which is particularly suitable for investigating the structural (i.e., long-term) impact of trade uncertainty on correlations. Our results reveal several novel findings. First, stock–bond correlations alternate between positive and negative phases, with turning points coinciding with spikes in TPU. Second, Republican administrations are associated with stronger stock–bond comovements, thereby reducing the hedging role of bonds, while Democratic administrations tend to display weaker or negative correlations. Third, models that incorporate political regimes and TPU provide a superior representation of correlation dynamics compared with the baseline CCC. Finally, DCC models augmented with TPU and political effects deliver the best in-sample fit and significantly improve the accuracy of out-of-sample correlation forecasts, with direct implications for portfolio allocation and risk management. The remainder of the paper is organized as

Read the complete text