Position: Certifiable State Integrity in Cyber-Physical Systems — Why Modular Sovereignty Solves the Plasticity-Stability Paradox

Enzo Nicolás Spotorno, Antônio Augusto Medeiros Fröhlich · 2026

Read Position: Certifiable State Integrity in Cyber-Physical Systems — Why Modular Sovereignty Solves the Plasticity-Stability Paradox by Enzo Nicolás Spotorno, Antônio Augusto Medeiros Fröhlich (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-21249.txt.

Introduction

Enzo Nicolás Spotorno and Antônio Augusto Medeiros Fröhlich argue that big unified models are a risky fit for safety-critical physical systems. Foundation models now handle time series and physical change well in smooth, slow settings. Real systems, though, shift over their life cycle and must meet strict reliability demands.

The authors make a position case for a modular design instead. Separate parts hold their own state, and that state can be checked and certified. A single large model must stay flexible yet stable, and the paper calls that tension the core problem. Modularity, they argue, is how both needs can be met at once.

Catalog record

CREATOREnzo Nicolás Spotorno, Antônio Augusto Medeiros Fröhlich
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-21249

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Position: Certifiable State Integrity in Cyber-Physical Systems — Why Modular Sovereignty Solves the Plasticity-Stability Paradox Enzo Nicolás Spotorno, Antônio Augusto Medeiros Fröhlich Abstract The machine learning community has achieved remarkable success with universal foundation models for time-series and physical dynamics, largely overcoming earlier approximation barriers in smooth or slowly varying regimes through scale and specialized architectures. However, deploying these monolithic models in safety-critical Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS), governed by non-stationary lifecycle dynamics and strict reliability requirements, reveals persistent challenges. Recent evidence shows that fine-tuning time-series foundation models induces catastrophic forgetting, degrading performance on prior regimes. Standard models continue to exhibit residual spectral bias, smoothing high-frequency discontinuities characteristic of incipient faults, while their opacity hinders formal verification and traceability demanded by safety standards (e.g., ISO 26262, IEC 61508). This position paper argues that the plasticity-stability paradox cannot be fully resolved by global parameter updates (whether via offline fine-tuning or online adaptation). Instead, we advocate a Modular Sovereignty paradigm: a library of compact, frozen regime-specific specialists combined via uncertainty-aware blending, which we term ”HYDRA” (Hierarchical uncertaintY-aware Dynamics for Rapidly-Adapting systems). This paradigm ensures regime-conditional validity, rigorous disentanglement of aleatoric and epistemic uncertainties, and modular auditability, offering a certifiable path for robust state integrity across the CPS lifecycle. 1 Introduction: From Approximation Breakthroughs to the Lifecycle Certifiability Barrier Cyber-Physical Systems (CPS) are shifting from controlled, static environments, to open-world autonomy, where systems must operate over extended lifecycles characterized by degradation, wear, and shifting contexts ( 16 ; 19 ) . Yet, machine learning strategies for monitoring and control must evolve to meet the broader requirements of State Integrity . We define State Integrity as the continuous maintenance of a valid causal link between the physical system and its digital representation throughout the lifecycle . Unlike accuracy, which minimizes output error, State Integrity requires that the model’s internal states remain physically interpretable and consistent with the current operational regime. This encompasses three requirements: (1) Reliable Virtual Sensing (trustworthy estimation of unobservable states) ( 13 ) , (2) Drift-Aware Operation (distinguishing physical aging, and operational regime/condition changes from model failure, or faults) ( 49 ; 31 ) , and (3) High-Fidelity Digital Twinning (preserving dynamic features like frequency response) even during non-stationary transitions ( 41 ) . Driven by successes in generative AI, the field has embraced “Universal Foundation Models” for time-series analysis ( 32 ) . Architectures from Transformers (e.g., MOMENT ( 18 ) , TimeGPT ( 17 ) ), TimesFM ( 12 ) ) to neural operators (FNO, DeepONet ( 30 ; 37 ) ) have delivered impressive zero-shot and few-shot capabilities, largely mitigating earlier challenges such as spectral bias in low-frequency prioritization ( 50 ) and slow Kolmogorov n -width decay in certain advective regimes (i.e., transport-dominated dynamics where coherent structures are translated rather than diffused). These advances have resolved many approximation pathologies for smooth or diffusion-dominated dynamics. However, as monolithic models enter safety-critical CPS applications, new structural limitations emerge, rooted not in raw learning capacity, but in adaptation stability and certifiability. Recent empirical studies demonstrate that sequential fine-tuning of time-series foundation models causes catastrophic forgetting, with severe degradation on previously mastered regimes ( 23 ) . This exacerbates the classic plasticity-stability dilemma ( 39 ; 33 ) : global parameter updates provide plasticity for new conditions (e.g., icy roads) but interfere with the entangled representations of prior ones (dry asphalt). Although monoliths might appear equivalent to ensembles given enough capacity, they differ fundamentally: monoliths lack the runtime prediction‑error signal that, in ensembles, is produced by regime‑specific specialists and sharply separates operational modes. Introducing that signal as an input to a monolith would dramatically expand the space of input combinations and internal state representations required for training, increasing the risk of catastrophic forgetting or severe inefficiency. Three persistent pathologies in non‑stationary physical domains further compound the problem: 1. Drift as Noise vs. Directed Trajectory: Monoliths often average out aging and shifts as noise, whereas physical degradation follows directed trajectories through parameter space ( 36 ) , yielding representations that fit neither nominal nor degraded states precisely. This stems from the absence of a training-time signal to distinguish varying operational conditions, regimes, and degraded states caused by expected aging; at runtime, the prediction error residual provides this discriminator for separating modes. 2. Residual Spectral Bias: Despite mitigations, standard networks prioritize low-frequency correlations, smoothing high-frequency discontinuities (the earliest precursors to faults) ( 50 ; 57 ) . By minimizing residuals globally, monoliths mask these signatures, destroying the runtime signal required for anomaly detection. 3. Invalid Manifold Interpolation: Generative approaches can produce physically invalid states by interpolating disjoint modes (e.g., distinct bifurcations), creating plausible but prohibited “hallucinations” that violate conservation laws ( 2 ; 29 ) . These issues render retraining computationally risky and opaque in safety loops. More critically, the opaque ”black box” nature of these models obstructs the formal verifiability and traceability required by standards like IEC 61508 ( 27 ) , as hazard analyses indicate that the lack of explicit requirements traceability remains a primary barrier to certification ( 48 ) . We critique not foundation models per se, but their centralization in safety-critical CPS. A physical system requires a federation of experts, not a single adaptable dictator. To rigorously formalize this conflict between global approximation and local validity, we adopt the terminology of ” Modular Sovereignty ”. We employ this political isomorphism because the mathematical challenge of managing conflicting local models (arbitrating ”jurisdiction” over specific state-spaces) is structurally identical to federated governance. We define Sovereignty as exclusive local validity (a model’s validity within a specific regime enforcing physical invariants) , Jurisdiction as the specific subset of the state-space (local partition) where error bounds hold , Governor as uncertainty-aware blending , and Constitution as physical invariants . We posit that certifiable state integrity is only feasible through the Modular Sovereignty path. Here, ”certifiable” refers to auditability and the facilitation of formal methods, rather than an immediate mathematical proof of the entire system. By decomposing the black box into locally valid operators, we enable the application of existing verification tools (like RPI Zonotopes for each specialist) that are intractable for monolithic networks. Drawing on advances in generative meta-learning for PDEs ( 11 ; 22 ) , we advocate this Modular Sovereignty paradigm, which, for conciseness, we term ”HYDRA” (Hierarchical uncertaintY-aware Dynamics for Rapidly-Adapting systems): a curated library of frozen, regime-specific specialists. Decoupling offline library construction from online uncertainty-aware blending guarantees retention (no forgetting), restores exchangeability for rigorous uncertainty quantification, disentangling sensor noise (aleatoric) from domain shifts or epistemic novelty (faults), and enables modular certification. Uncertainty becomes a semantic control signal for precise fail-safe interventions, transforming non-stationarity into a structured, auditable asset. By enforcing that the global output is always a convex combination of valid specialists ( \sum\pi=1 ), we ensure the system state remains within the convex hull of the valid local manifolds, providing the geometric basis for compositional completeness tied to polytopic LPV theory. The contributions of this position paper are threefold: (1) we identify persisting theoretical and practical barriers to deploying universal foundation models in safety-critical CPS, highlighting how their monolithic architecture masks the runtime residual signal necessary for regime observability, (2) we propose Modular Sovereignty (HYDRA) as a paradigm that resolves

Read the complete text